Life Insurance Benefits: Marital Property In Pennsylvania?

Life insurance policies can be a tricky business, especially when it comes to divorce. In Pennsylvania, life insurance policies are generally considered marital property, especially if they have cash value. However, in a 2021 case, Goodwin v. Goodwin, the state's Superior Court ruled that life insurance death benefits are gifts and therefore not marital property when it comes to equitable distribution in a divorce. This means that, in Pennsylvania, if you receive life insurance benefits that are solely in your name and not commingled with marital assets, they may be considered separate property and not subject to division during a divorce.

Whole life insurance policies accrue value as the insured pays premiums

In Pennsylvania, life insurance death benefits are considered "gifts" and are therefore not deemed marital property for purposes of equitable distribution. However, whole life insurance policies accrue value as the insured pays premiums, and this can complicate matters when it comes to divorce proceedings.

Whole life insurance policies, unlike term life policies, accrue value over time as the insured pays premiums. This cash value component serves as a savings account that the policyholder can draw on or borrow from. The cash value typically earns a fixed rate of interest, and withdrawals up to the total amount of premiums paid are tax-free. However, withdrawals and outstanding loan balances will reduce the death benefits.

In the context of divorce, if one spouse paid premiums on a whole life insurance policy during the marriage, the value of that policy is typically considered a marital asset and is subject to the property settlement agreement. The court will determine how the proceeds from the policy will be divided, depending on whether the marital assets are subject to equal or equitable distribution.

For example, the policy can be cashed out, and the proceeds divided according to the property settlement agreement. Alternatively, the policy can be left intact, and the portion the non-insured spouse is entitled to can be paid through other marital assets.

Term life insurance policies pay out only if the insured dies within the policy's term

Term life insurance policies are distinct from whole life insurance policies in that they do not accrue value over time as the insured pays premiums. Instead, they pay out only if the insured dies within the policy's term. This means that if the policy expires before the insured's death, there will be no payout.

In Pennsylvania, a precedent-setting opinion by the state's Superior Court ruled that life insurance death benefits are "gifts" and therefore not marital property for the purposes of equitable distribution. This means that in the context of a divorce proceeding, life insurance death benefits are not subject to division between spouses.

However, it's important to note that the specific laws governing life insurance and marital property can vary from state to state. In community property states, for example, life insurance may be considered a marital asset if the premiums were paid with income earned during the marriage.

In summary, term life insurance policies provide coverage for a specified term, and the beneficiary will receive a payout only if the insured dies within that term. The treatment of life insurance benefits as marital property during divorce proceedings depends on state-specific laws and the nature of the insurance policy.

Divorce automatically nullifies the designation of an ex-spouse as a beneficiary in Pennsylvania

In Pennsylvania, a life insurance policy may be considered a marital asset depending on the laws that control the policy. Whole life insurance is almost always considered a marital asset. In the case of a divorce, the value of the policy is subject to the property settlement agreement.

Term life insurance, on the other hand, does not accrue present value as premiums are paid. Instead, it pays out only if the insured dies within the policy's term.

About half of the states in the US have "revocation upon divorce" statutes that automatically remove an ex-spouse as a life insurance beneficiary when the divorce is finalised. Pennsylvania is one of these states.

Effective from May 2, 2023, Pennsylvania law requires all divorce decrees to include a notice concerning the designation of beneficiaries for certain assets, including life insurance policies and retirement accounts. This law, 20 Pa.C.S. § 6111.2, states that if a former spouse passes away and is either divorced or if the grounds for divorce have been established, then any beneficiary designation by the deceased ex-spouse to the surviving ex-spouse is invalid. This means that divorce automatically nullifies the designation of an ex-spouse as a beneficiary in Pennsylvania.

The only exception to this law is if the deceased ex-spouse makes clear in a separate, later-executed written document that the designation is meant to remain effective.

Life insurance policies with cash value are considered marital property

Life insurance policies are often a contentious issue in divorce proceedings. In the state of Pennsylvania, a precedent was set by the ruling in Goodwin v. Goodwin, which held that life insurance death benefits are "gifts" and therefore not marital property for the purposes of equitable distribution.

However, in the absence of a pre- or post-nuptial agreement, state laws vary widely on how life insurance policies with cash value are treated during divorce. In community property states, a life insurance policy will almost certainly be subject to distribution in a divorce if the couple paid the premiums with joint funds while married. In these states, the asset is typically divided equally.

On the other hand, in non-community property states, a judge must determine if the life insurance policy was "commingled" with marital assets and should be shared in the divorce. If a spouse was the original beneficiary or joint funds paid the premiums, the life insurance policy is likely to be considered an asset to be divided.

Whole life insurance policies accrue value as the insured pays premiums and can be cashed out, with the proceeds divided according to a property settlement agreement. This cash value is a living benefit that policyholders can access for various purposes during their lifetime. The cash value component can be used to borrow against, withdrawn, or used to pay policy premiums.

Life insurance policies with cash value are considered a type of permanent life insurance, which lasts for the lifetime of the holder. This is in contrast to term life insurance, which only pays out if the insured dies within the policy's term. Due to the permanent nature of these policies and their ability to accrue value, they are often considered marital assets and are subject to distribution during divorce proceedings.

Life insurance death benefits are considered gifts and not marital property in Pennsylvania

In Pennsylvania, life insurance death benefits are considered gifts and not marital property. This means that they are not subject to equitable distribution in a divorce proceeding. Equitable distribution is a process in which marital property is distributed fairly between spouses in the event of a divorce.

Marital property, also known as "marital estate" or "community property," refers to all assets and debts acquired by a couple during their marriage. This can include physical property, financial investments, retirement accounts, business interests, debts, digital property, cryptocurrency, insurance policies, professional degrees, and pets.

However, life insurance death benefits are not considered marital property in Pennsylvania. In the case of Goodwin v. Goodwin, the Pennsylvania Superior Court ruled that life insurance death benefits are "gifts" and, therefore, not subject to equitable distribution. This sets a precedent in Pennsylvania, as there was previously little law discussing whether life insurance death benefits are considered marital property.

It is important to note that the definition of "marital asset" or "marital property" can vary from state to state. Additionally, the laws surrounding life insurance and divorce can be complex, and it is always advisable to consult with a legal professional for personalized advice.

Frequently asked questions