Life Insurance Proceeds: Community Property Or Separate Asset?

Life insurance policies are often a source of confusion for married couples, especially in community property states. In these states, including Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin, married couples are considered joint owners of assets and debts acquired during their marriage. This has implications for life insurance policies and their beneficiaries. In community property states, the policyholder's spouse is automatically considered the beneficiary, and they must receive spousal permission to list anyone else. If income earned during the marriage is used to pay the premiums, the spouse typically has a legal right to 50% of the death benefit. This can lead to complex situations, especially in the case of divorce or when the surviving spouse is not the sole beneficiary. Understanding the specific laws of each community property state is crucial, as they may differ in their treatment of life insurance proceeds.

In community property states, the policyholder's spouse is automatically the beneficiary

In the US, there are nine community property states: Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin. In these states, once a couple gets married, they become equally responsible for and have equal claim to everything they own. This means that in community property states, the policyholder's spouse is automatically considered the beneficiary of their life insurance policy.

In a community property state, both spouses own the money equally earned during the marriage and any property bought with that money. This includes term insurance policies, which are considered community property, and your spouse gets 50% of the death benefit. If the policyholder wants to name someone else as the beneficiary, such as their child, a relative, or a friend, they must receive their spouse's permission.

The characterization of a term insurance policy depends on the source of funding of the premium for the final term of the policy. When the final premium is paid solely with community property, the proceeds of the policy are community property. On the other hand, when the separate estate pays for the final premium with no help from the community, the proceeds are a separate asset.

It's important to note that community property states have different approaches to how they treat the proceeds of life insurance policies. For example, in Washington state, if a spouse uses "community property" to pay the life insurance premiums, their spouse has the right to a portion of the life insurance proceeds.

If you live in a community property state, it's recommended that spouses keep organized records of their personal financial matters to avoid any confusion or disputes.

In common law property states, individual ownership is the default

In contrast, community property states view married couples as joint owners of almost all assets and debts incurred since the wedding. In these states, co-ownership is the default. Any property acquired before marriage can still be owned individually, and there are some other exceptions, such as property acquired by inheritance or bequest from a will.

There are nine community-property states in the US: Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin. Puerto Rico is also a community property jurisdiction.

The status of a life insurance policy as community or separate property depends on the source of funding for the premium. If the final premium is paid with community property, the proceeds of the policy are community property. On the other hand, if the separate estate pays the final premium, the proceeds are a separate asset.

In common law property states, a spouse does not automatically receive the benefit of a life insurance policy. The policyholder could choose another beneficiary, such as a child, relative, or friend. However, in community property states, the policyholder's spouse is automatically considered the beneficiary, and the policyowner must receive the spouse's permission to list anyone else.

In community property states, the policy owner must get spousal consent to list someone else as the beneficiary

To document spousal consent, the spouse must complete a Spousal Consent Form in the presence of a witness. This form is then uploaded to the relevant platform. It is important to note that a spousal consent form only applies to a specific beneficiary designation for a single account. Additionally, in some instances, the insurer may require the non-insured spouse to sign a consent form to waive rights to the death benefits. The specific requirements for creating a "property status agreement" vary by state.

It is worth noting that, even if you do not live in a community property state, it is recommended to still get spousal consent. This is especially relevant if you previously resided or plan to move to a community property state in the future. Consulting an estate attorney for advice based on your personal circumstances is always a good idea.

In permanent life insurance, proceeds are prorated according to the percentage of premiums paid with community money

In the US, permanent life insurance proceeds are prorated according to the percentage of premiums paid with community money. This means that the proceeds of a life insurance policy will be divided between the named beneficiary and the surviving spouse, based on the proportion of premiums paid with money earned during the marriage.

In community property states, both spouses own the money equally earned during the marriage and any property bought with that money. This includes life insurance policies, where the policyholder's spouse is automatically considered the beneficiary. If the policyholder wants to name someone else as the beneficiary, they must get their spouse's permission.

In the case of permanent life insurance, such as whole life or universal life insurance, the proceeds are prorated according to the percentage of premiums paid with community money. For example, if a spouse buys a whole life policy two years before marriage and pays the premiums with their own money, then uses income earned during the marriage to pay for another year before they die, their named beneficiary would receive two-thirds of the death benefit payout, while their spouse would have rights to the remaining one-third.

The community property states in the US are Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin. In addition, Puerto Rico is also a community property jurisdiction.

Life insurance is not an inheritance and is not part of the probate estate

In most cases, the only time life insurance proceeds become part of the probate estate is when there are no named beneficiaries. In this instance, the proceeds may be paid into the estate and distributed according to the will or per state laws. This can be avoided by keeping beneficiary designations up to date.

In community property states, the policyholder's spouse is automatically considered the beneficiary. These states include Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin. In these states, the rules are slightly different, and the surviving spouse has a legal claim to one-half of the proceeds under community property principles.

Life insurance can be a tax-friendly way to provide financial support to beneficiaries, but it's important to be aware of potential estate and inheritance taxes. For example, if a substantial death benefit increases the value of an estate to a certain level, federal or state taxation may apply. Therefore, it's crucial to consult with a tax expert to understand the potential tax liabilities and strategies for managing them.

To summarise, life insurance proceeds are not typically considered an inheritance or part of the probate estate. Instead, they are paid directly to the named beneficiaries, bypassing the probate process and providing immediate financial support. However, there may be exceptions, and it's important to understand the specific rules and regulations that apply in different states and situations.

Frequently asked questions