Private Insurance: Profiting From Policyholders' Misfortune

Private insurance companies are for-profit entities that assume the financial risk of covered events on behalf of individuals or businesses. They generate revenue primarily by charging premiums for insurance coverage and reinvesting those premiums into interest-bearing assets. The profitability of insurance companies depends on various factors, including the number of policies written, premiums charged, investment returns, business costs, and claims paid. While insurance companies play a crucial role in providing financial protection, there are concerns about their focus on profits over people, especially in the American healthcare system.

Private health insurance companies make record profits as costs soar in the US

Private health insurance companies in the US are for-profit businesses, and they have been accused of putting profits over people. In 2022, the largest US health insurers made over $41 billion in profits. UnitedHealth Group, the largest insurer in the US, made over $20 billion in profit in 2022, with net earnings of $17.7 billion in the previous year. Other major players, like Cigna, Elevance Health, and CVS Health, also made billions in profits.

While these companies are making record profits, Americans are struggling to afford the rising costs of healthcare and health insurance. The price of an employer-sponsored family policy has increased by 47% since 2011, outpacing wages and inflation. This means that premiums and deductibles now make up a larger portion of the average family's income. As a result, 46% of insured adults find it challenging to afford out-of-pocket expenses, and 29% have skipped medication due to high prices.

The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated these issues, with frontline healthcare workers experiencing burnout and rural hospitals closing at an alarming rate. Despite these challenges, private health insurance companies continue to prioritize profits. They do this by refusing to pay for care, underpaying reimbursements, and denying coverage. Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, for example, had 53% of its medical bills for a quarter in 2021 go unpaid, totalling $2.5 billion.

The Affordable Care Act has tried to address this issue by capping insurance profit margins and mandating that insurance companies spend at least 80% of premiums on healthcare costs and improvements. However, insurance companies have responded by increasing costs to maximise profits further. This has led to calls for more regulation and congressional action to hold insurance companies accountable and ensure they do not put profits before people.

The situation is complex, and while private health insurance companies are businesses that need to make profits to remain viable, the current state of affairs is detrimental to Americans' health and financial well-being.

Private insurers play a growing role in public insurance programs

Private insurers play an increasingly prominent role in public insurance programs, such as Medicare and Medicaid. In 2017, 153 million non-elderly people had private, employer-sponsored health coverage, and this is the most common form of private health insurance. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) of 2010 introduced many new requirements for the federal regulation of private health coverage.

The ACA also created Health Insurance Marketplaces, where individuals can purchase ACA-compliant insurance with federal financial assistance for premiums and cost-sharing if eligible. In the first quarter of 2018, 14 million people had private insurance coverage in the non-group market, with roughly three-quarters purchasing coverage through the ACA Marketplaces.

A growing share of Medicare beneficiaries are enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans, which are sponsored by private insurers and paid for by the federal government. In 2019, about one-third of the more than 60 million people covered by Medicare were enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that nearly half of all Medicare beneficiaries will be enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan by 2029.

The majority of people in traditional Medicare also have additional coverage provided by one or more private plan sponsors. For example, 25 million Medicare beneficiaries in traditional Medicare are enrolled in private stand-alone Part D prescription drug plans.

Private insurers play a significant role in Medicaid as well. Two-thirds of all Medicaid enrollees were enrolled in Medicaid managed care organizations (MCOs) as of July 2017 in the 38 states and DC that contract with these organizations. MCOs are subject to federal and state standards and beneficiary protections, and payments to Medicaid MCOs totalled nearly $264 billion in FY 2017, accounting for about 46% of total Medicaid spending.

The role of private health insurance in the US would vary across different proposals to establish a public program to broaden coverage and make healthcare more affordable. For example, under Medicare-for-All approaches proposed by Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Pramila Jayapal, private health insurers would be prohibited from offering coverage that duplicates Medicare-for-All covered benefits. However, other proposals, such as Medicare for America, would maintain a role for private insurance by allowing employers to offer qualified health plans.

Insurance companies invest premiums in interest-generating assets

Private insurance companies are for-profit entities. They make money by collecting premiums from customers and investing them in interest-generating assets. This strategy, known as "investing the float", allows insurance companies to earn income through interest, dividends, and appreciation. The time lag between the collection of premiums and the settlement of claims provides insurers with an opportunity to invest the premiums and generate returns. This investment income is typically the second largest revenue source for insurers, after the premiums themselves.

Insurance companies invest in a variety of financial instruments, including debt securities (such as bonds, notes, and redeemable preferred stock), equity securities (such as common stock, mutual fund shares, and non-redeemable preferred stock), and short-term investments (such as commercial paper, certificates of deposit, mutual funds, and money market funds). They also invest in securities lending, repurchase agreements, derivatives, and other instruments. These investments provide a steady and reliable source of interest and dividend income, and they can be sold quickly if liquidity needs arise.

By investing the premiums they collect, insurance companies can generate higher returns and offset some of the costs associated with providing insurance coverage. This helps them to keep their prices competitive in the market. The investment income also contributes significantly to the overall profitability of insurance companies, which is crucial for their long-term sustainability and ability to pay out claims.

In addition to investing premiums, insurance companies employ various strategies to maximise profits. They diversify risk by pooling risks from multiple customers and redistributing them across a larger portfolio. They also engage in reinsurance, where they buy insurance to protect themselves from excessive losses due to high exposure. This helps them maintain solvency and avoid default in the event of too many claim payouts.

Insurance companies' net profit margins vary depending on the type of insurance provided

An insurance company's profit depends on several factors, including the number of policies it writes, the premiums it charges, the return on its investments, business costs, and claims. Net profit margin (NPM) is a metric that helps define a company's overall financial health and measures how much net income is generated as a percentage of revenue.

The calculation of net margins is significant for insurance companies because they often operate on low margins, such as 2% to 3%. Small profit margins mean that even slight changes in an insurance company's cost structure or pricing can lead to drastic changes in its ability to generate profits and remain solvent.

Individual insurance companies can have varying profitability ratios based on their strategies in marketing, sales, operations, and risk models. For example, health insurers tend to operate on very thin margins, so they focus on pushing volume. On the other hand, property and casualty insurance companies have slightly higher margins, but they can vary significantly depending on the state and company.

Insurance companies generate revenue through the insurance policies they write and returns from investment activities. They incur typical business costs, including payments to service providers such as hospitals, doctors, or repair shops, and losses due to insurance claims.

Profit margins in the insurance industry can be affected by changes in the costs of services, policy price changes, and the number of claims received. For long-term evaluations, analysts typically consider annualized net profit margin data to account for these fluctuations.

Insurance companies' profits depend on the number of policies written, premiums charged, and claims

Private insurance companies are for-profit entities. Their business model revolves around assuming financial risk on behalf of individuals or businesses. They generate revenue by charging premiums in exchange for insurance coverage and then reinvesting those premiums into interest-generating assets.

An insurance company's profit depends on several factors, including the number of policies written, the premiums charged, the return on investments, business costs, and claims. The more policies an insurance company writes, the more revenue it generates. This is because each policy comes with a premium, which is the price of the insurance coverage, typically charged on a monthly or annual basis.

The premiums an insurance company can charge are based on the risk of a claim being made. The company must assess the likelihood of a claim being made and determine the premium amount that will adequately compensate them for taking on the risk. This process is called underwriting. If a company prices its risk effectively, it will generate more revenue in premiums than it spends on claim payouts.

In addition to premiums, insurance companies also generate revenue through returns on their investments. They invest the premiums they receive in various interest-bearing products, such as U.S. Treasuries and corporate bonds. Higher market interest rates boost earnings, while lower rates may lead insurers to invest in riskier assets.

While revenue is essential, an insurance company's profit also depends on its costs. These include typical business expenses, such as overhead, as well as claims payouts. Insurance companies must carefully manage their expenses to maintain profitability. Even small changes in their cost structure or pricing can significantly impact their ability to generate profits and remain solvent.

To summarize, insurance companies' profits are closely tied to the number of policies they write, the premiums they charge, and the claims they pay out. Effective risk assessment and pricing, along with investment strategies and cost management, are crucial for maintaining profitability in the insurance industry.

Frequently asked questions