Double Auto Insurance Coverage In California?

It is legal to have two auto insurance policies in California, but it is not recommended. While it is not against the law to have two policies on a single vehicle, most companies discourage this practice. Making two claims with two different insurance companies for the same accident may be considered insurance fraud. If you purchase double insurance policies for two different cars, you’ll miss out on multi-vehicle discounts and other opportunities for savings.

Is it legal to have double coverage in California?

It is not illegal to have double coverage for auto insurance in California. However, it is generally discouraged by insurance companies, and there are several reasons why having two auto insurance policies is not recommended.

Firstly, it is more expensive to have two policies, as you will be paying two separate premiums. Secondly, if you file a claim, the primary insurance policy will pay first, and the other company, known as the excess policy, will only make payments after the primary policy limit has been reached. Thirdly, if you file the same claim with two different insurance companies, it is considered insurance fraud, which is illegal.

Additionally, if you have two insurance policies on the same car, your coverage could be terminated by one or both providers, leaving you without insurance. Also, if you own more than one vehicle, insuring them under separate policies will cause you to miss out on multi-vehicle discounts and other cost-saving opportunities.

In some cases, however, having two auto insurance policies may be beneficial. For example, if you have one vehicle for work and another for personal use, or if you share a vehicle with a roommate or household member and want different coverage levels. In these instances, it is important to carefully review and coordinate the policies to avoid duplication of coverage or gaps in protection.

What are the risks of having two auto insurance policies?

While it is not illegal to have two auto insurance policies, it is generally discouraged by insurance companies. There are several risks associated with having two auto insurance policies, which are outlined below:

Financial Costs

Having two auto insurance policies means paying two separate premiums, which can be very expensive. This is especially true when considering that there is no added benefit to having two policies. In fact, you may lose money by having two policies, as you will likely be ineligible for multi-car or multi-policy discounts.

Complicated Claims

Having two policies can make the claims process more complicated. In the event of an accident, the two insurance companies will need to agree on who will cover what part of the claim, which can dramatically extend the time it takes to receive a settlement. Additionally, the risk of committing insurance fraud increases, as filing the same claim with two different insurance providers is illegal and constitutes unjust enrichment.

Policy Violations

Having two policies may violate the terms of one or both insurance policies. This could result in delayed or unpaid claims, as well as potential termination of coverage by one or both providers.

Premium Increases and Loss of Discounts

Following a claim, your premium costs from both insurers will likely increase. Additionally, you may lose any good driver discounts that you had on both policies.

Difficulty in Adding Drivers and Vehicles

Each insurance policy may require you to add every driver in your household to your coverage, as well as every automobile parked at your household. This can significantly increase your cost of auto insurance.

In summary, while having two auto insurance policies is not illegal, it is generally not recommended due to the potential risks and costs outlined above. It is usually more practical and financially sensible to have a single policy that meets all your coverage needs.

What are the benefits of having two auto insurance policies?

While it is not illegal to have two auto insurance policies, it is generally discouraged. Here are some of the benefits of having two auto insurance policies:

Protection for Different Purposes

In some cases, you may need two policies if you have one vehicle for work and another for personal use. Commercial auto insurance is necessary for business purposes, whereas personal auto insurance typically does not cover commercial vehicles.

Protection for Different Vehicles

If you own a classic, luxury, or exotic car, you may want to ensure it is fully covered by taking out a separate policy. This is because standard auto insurance might not cover the full value of such vehicles, and they may require specialised care or parts.

Protection for Different Drivers

If you share a vehicle with a roommate, friend, or family member, and you both want different coverage levels, you may consider taking out separate policies. However, it is worth noting that this is generally not recommended, as paying for two separate policies will cost more than splitting a fuller coverage policy between two people.

Protection Across Different States

If you have vehicles registered in different states, you will likely need separate policies to meet each state's specific insurance regulations and requirements.

Protection for Different Risks

If your significant other has a bad credit score or poor driving record, you may want to take out a separate policy to avoid them raising your rates.

Protection for Different Scenarios

You may accidentally have two car insurance policies because you mistakenly thought that one policy had expired. Alternatively, you may have a second policy to cover your classic or exotic vehicle.

While there are benefits to having two auto insurance policies, it is important to note that there are also disadvantages, including increased cost, complexity in managing claims, and the risk of accidental fraud. It is recommended that you carefully consider your specific needs and circumstances before deciding to take out two auto insurance policies.

How do I avoid double coverage?

While it is not illegal to have two auto insurance policies on the same car, it is generally discouraged by insurance companies. Having two policies can lead to complications and higher costs without providing any additional benefits. Here are some ways to avoid double coverage:

• Research the level of coverage you require and compare rates from multiple insurance companies. Choose a single policy that meets all your needs instead of paying for two separate policies. A comprehensive policy can cover all your vehicles, and you can usually add multiple vehicles to a single policy at a discounted rate.
• Be aware that making two claims with two different insurance companies for the same accident may be considered insurance fraud. In the event of an accident, only one insurance company will pay out, so there is no benefit to having double coverage.
• If you own multiple vehicles, consider insuring them under one policy. Most insurance companies offer multi-vehicle discounts, which can result in significant savings.
• If you share a vehicle with a roommate or household member, it is more cost-effective to agree on a single policy and split the costs rather than having two separate policies.
• If you are concerned about adequate coverage in the event of an accident, instead of taking out a second policy, consider adding extra coverage options to your existing policy.
• If you are purchasing coverage for a high-risk driver, compare rates from multiple insurance companies to find an affordable policy that suits your needs.
• If you have a loyalty discount on your existing policy, consider keeping it while adding new vehicles to your policy instead of taking out a separate policy.
• Be mindful of the potential for fraudulent claims when having two policies. Insurance companies will coordinate to settle claims, and they will not pay out twice.

What are the alternatives to double coverage?

While it is not illegal to have two auto insurance policies on the same car, it is generally discouraged by insurance companies. If you are considering double coverage, it is important to be aware of the potential complications and higher costs associated with this approach. Here are some alternatives to consider:

• Multi-policy auto insurance: If you have multiple cars, consider insuring them under the same policy with a single insurer. This option provides convenience and potential discounts. You can customise coverage levels for each car while meeting the minimum insurance requirements. Many companies offer multi-policy discounts, which can help lower your rates.
• Uninsured motorist coverage: This type of coverage protects you if you are in an accident with an uninsured or underinsured driver. It helps cover medical expenses, property damage, and other losses.
• Self-insurance: This option is typically available to owners of over 25 vehicles, such as company fleets or rental car companies. It allows you to act as your own insurance company and cover any financial responsibilities arising from accidents.
• Paying an uninsured motorist fee: In some states, you can legally drive without insurance by paying an uninsured motorist fee. However, you will still be responsible for any damages you cause in an accident.
• Surety bond: A surety bond can act as a replacement for a standard car insurance policy. It requires the holder to pay a specific amount of money, which will cover the driver's expenses in an accident up to its value. However, the driver must repay the money used from the bond, with interest. The price of a surety bond depends on your financial stability and ability to make repayments.
• Other financial responsibility methods: Several states have financial responsibility laws that allow car owners to provide proof of financial responsibility through methods other than a car insurance policy. These methods may include a surety bond, cash or securities, or self-insurance. However, these alternatives may be difficult to obtain and may require a significant amount of money readily available.

Frequently asked questions