Disputing Life Insurance Beneficiaries: Is It Possible?

Disputes over life insurance beneficiaries are common and often complex, lengthy, and financially taxing for all involved parties. While it is possible to dispute a beneficiary, it requires a legal court process, and it can be challenging to prove that the beneficiary is the wrong one. Disputes can arise due to various reasons, such as a change in family circumstances, lack of clarity in the policy, allegations of fraud, undue influence, or coercion, and reduced mental capacity of the policy owner. To successfully dispute a beneficiary, it is crucial to seek legal assistance and provide valid evidence supporting the claim.

Contesting a beneficiary designation

• The policyholder changed the beneficiary right before their passing: In some cases, a policyholder may attempt to change their beneficiary before their death but fail to do so successfully. This could be due to not following the insurer's process correctly or not complying with the policy provisions.
• The policyholder remarried: If a policyholder gets divorced and remarried but doesn't update the beneficiary from their former spouse to their current spouse, the current spouse may have a valid claim to contest the designation.
• Lack of mental capacity or undue influence: There may be disputes over the policyholder's mental capacity to change beneficiaries or allegations of coercion or undue influence.
• Improper beneficiary change: Sometimes, a policyholder tries to change the beneficiary but fails to do so correctly. Even if the intention to change beneficiaries is clear, it might not impact the distribution of proceeds if the insurance company's procedures are not followed.
• Divorce: In some states, a divorce automatically revokes a prior beneficiary designation in favour of an ex-spouse. However, if there is a court order or divorce decree requiring the insured to maintain the ex-spouse as the beneficiary, they may have a valid claim to the benefits.
• Community property claim: In community property states, a surviving spouse may have a claim for constructive fraud if an insurance policy was purchased with community funds for the benefit of someone outside the marriage.

It is important to note that preventing disputes is ideal. Policyholders should review and update their policies after major life changes, follow insurance company procedures when making changes, and discuss any changes with loved ones.

Lack of clarity in a policy

Disputes over life insurance beneficiaries are common and often complex, lengthy, and financially taxing for all involved parties. One of the main reasons for these disputes is a lack of clarity in the policy. This can occur when there is a change in family circumstances, such as marriage, divorce, the birth of a child, or a death, and the policy owner neglects to update the beneficiary. For instance, a policyholder may get divorced and remarried without updating the beneficiary from their former spouse to their current one, leading the current spouse to contest the policy.

In other cases, the policyholder may attempt to change the beneficiary before their death but fail to do so successfully, either because they didn't follow the insurer's process correctly or comply with the provisions outlined in their policy. This can result in confusion over who is entitled to the benefits, especially in cases of blended families or previous marriages.

To avoid disputes, policyholders should update their beneficiaries as needed, especially after major life events such as divorce. It is also crucial to follow the insurance company's procedures when making beneficiary changes and to discuss any changes with loved ones. Keeping both wills and insurance policies up-to-date, with clear and accurate information, is essential to preventing lengthy and expensive legal battles.

Additionally, complex terms and lengthy applications can pose challenges during the onboarding stage, making it difficult for policyholders to understand their coverage and benefits. This lack of transparency and clarity in the policy can contribute to disputes, as beneficiaries may not fully comprehend their rights and entitlements.

Failure to update the beneficiary

To avoid disputes, it is crucial for policyholders to review and update their beneficiary designations regularly, especially after major life changes. This ensures that the policy accurately reflects their wishes and helps prevent confusion or disagreement among potential beneficiaries. It is also important to follow the insurance company's procedures when making updates to avoid any mistakes that could delay or prevent the desired changes.

In some cases, failure to update the beneficiary may be intentional. For example, a policyholder may intend to provide financial security for an ex-spouse or may simply forget to make the necessary changes. However, this can still lead to disputes, especially if the current spouse or other family members feel they have a valid claim to the benefits.

When a dispute arises due to failure to update the beneficiary, it is essential to seek legal counsel. An experienced life insurance lawyer can guide individuals through the complex process of contesting or defending a beneficiary designation. They can help gather evidence, navigate state and federal laws, and determine the best course of action to protect their client's rights and interests.

While challenging a beneficiary designation can be challenging, it is possible to succeed, especially if there are concerns about undue influence, declining mental faculties, or non-compliance with policy requirements. By consulting legal professionals and taking prompt action, individuals can increase their chances of resolving the dispute in a favourable and timely manner.

Undue influence or coercion

In the case of undue influence or coercion, courts will consider whether the policyholder was subject to excessive persuasion that caused them to act or refrain from acting, ultimately overriding their free will and resulting in inequity. This determination includes considering the vulnerability of the victim, the influence of the perpetrator, and the actions or tactics used. Evidence of vulnerability may include incapacity, illness, disability, injury, age, impaired cognitive function, or emotional distress. The influencer's apparent authority, such as their status as a fiduciary, family member, or health care professional, is also taken into account. Tactics used may involve controlling aspects of the victim's life, such as medication or access to information, or using affection, intimidation, or coercion to initiate changes in personal rights.

For example, a beneficiary designation may be contested if the policyholder lacked the mental capacity to change beneficiaries but was pressured to do so. This often involves policyholders diagnosed with dementia or cognitive decline, where financial impairment is one of the earliest clinical signs. Deathbed beneficiary changes are particularly suspect. In such cases, courts will consider whether the new beneficiary took advantage of the policyholder's reliance on them for their daily living needs.

Another example is when a policyholder changes the beneficiary to their current spouse, but the previous spouse, who was the original beneficiary, contests this change. This scenario is common in cases of blended families or previous marriages. In some states, even if the named beneficiary is the former spouse, state law can supersede this in favour of the current spouse.

To successfully contest a life insurance beneficiary designation on the grounds of undue influence or coercion, it is crucial to act quickly and consult an experienced lawyer. The process is complex and time-consuming, often requiring a thorough understanding of specific laws governing life insurance policies in the relevant jurisdiction.

Disputes between beneficiaries

Lack of Clarity in the Policy

In some cases, the policy documents may not be clear about who the beneficiary is, or there may be discrepancies between different documents. This can lead to confusion and disputes among potential beneficiaries.

Changes in Family Circumstances

One of the most common reasons for beneficiary disputes is a change in family circumstances, such as marriage, divorce, the birth of a child, or a death. For example, if a policyholder gets divorced and remarried but fails to update the beneficiary from their former spouse to their current one, the current spouse may contest the policy.

Multiple Potential Beneficiaries with Competing Claims

When there are multiple potential beneficiaries, such as children from different marriages or a blend of family members, disputes may arise over who is entitled to the benefits. This is especially common in blended families or cases of previous marriages.

Allegations of Fraud, Undue Influence, or Coercion

In some cases, beneficiaries may dispute the validity of the policy or the beneficiary designation if they believe that fraud, undue influence, or coercion was involved in changing the beneficiary. For example, they may allege that the policyholder was pressured to change the beneficiary or that someone other than the policyholder made the change.

Reduced Mental Capacity of the Policyholder

If there are questions about the policyholder's mental capacity at the time they made changes to the beneficiary designation, beneficiaries may dispute the validity of those changes. This is particularly relevant if the policyholder was elderly or suffering from dementia or other cognitive impairments.

Disputes Over Validity Due to Cause of Death

In certain situations, beneficiaries may dispute the validity of the policy based on the cause of the policyholder's death. For example, if a beneficiary is suspected of playing a role in the death of the policyholder, disputes may arise over their entitlement to the benefits.

Disagreements Over the Amount or Distribution of Proceeds

Even if the beneficiary is not disputed, there may be disagreements among potential beneficiaries about how much each person should receive or how the proceeds should be distributed. This can occur when the policyholder has not provided clear instructions or percentages for distribution.

To resolve these disputes, it is essential to seek legal advice and, if necessary, take the issue to court. An experienced attorney can help navigate the complex process of disputing a life insurance beneficiary and ensure that the policyholder's wishes are accurately reflected.

Frequently asked questions