Smoking Status: Truth Or Lie?

Lying about smoking habits on insurance applications is a common occurrence. People may be tempted to lie about their tobacco use to benefit from lower premium rates or maintain eligibility for an insurance policy. However, lying about smoking on an insurance application is considered insurance fraud and can lead to serious consequences. If an insurance company finds out about the deception, the policy could be revoked, or they may refuse to pay the claim amount. Additionally, the insurance company may retroactively impose a tobacco surcharge. While it is rare for insurers or employers to actively investigate smoking habits, medical records and routine blood and urine analysis can provide evidence of tobacco use.

What are the consequences of lying about smoking on an insurance application?

Lying on an insurance application is a form of insurance fraud and can have serious consequences. While it may be tempting to lie about smoking to benefit from lower premium rates or maintain eligibility for an insurance policy, there are ramifications to doing so.

Insurance companies define a smoker as someone who uses tobacco or nicotine in any form, including cigarettes, cigars, nicotine patches, and chewing tobacco. If you answer "yes" to the question of smoking on your insurance application form, you will be listed as a smoker. The failure to disclose tobacco use is one of the most common lies in an insurance application. Given that premiums rise by 25-50% if one consumes tobacco, it can be tempting to say that you do not smoke to keep costs low. However, lying about smoking on a life insurance application likely constitutes a misrepresentation, even if you only smoke occasionally.

If you are caught lying during the application process, the insurance company can immediately decline coverage. If the lie is accidental or relatively minor, you might still be able to get approved for coverage, but you could pay a higher rate or face coverage limitations based on the accurate representation of your medical history.

After your policy goes into effect, many life insurance providers apply a contestability period during which they may review your policy for false statements or misrepresentations. If you pass away during this time and your insurer discovers that you lied on your initial application, it could result in a claim denial or a decreased death benefit.

Additionally, insurance companies have ways to find out whether you have lied or hidden facts on your application form. They often conduct medical tests, review your medical records, and may even interview your friends and relatives. They are also members of the Medical Information Bureau (MIB), a cooperative database that shares confidential coded data about medical conditions and risk factors to alert insurers of potential omissions or errors in applicants' reported medical histories.

If the insurance company discovers that you have lied about smoking or tobacco use, the policy could be revoked, or the insurance company may refuse to pay the claim amount. It is essential to be honest with your insurance company from the start, as lying puts the insurance benefits and the financial security of your family at risk.

How do insurance companies find out about applicants' smoking habits?

When applying for insurance, it is important to be honest about your smoking status. Insurance companies consider smoking to be a significant health risk and a factor in determining life expectancy, which is a major cost component when setting rates. Smokers can expect to pay higher premiums than non-smokers, and lying about tobacco use on an insurance application can result in serious consequences, including insurance fraud charges. While it is rare for insurers to actively investigate an applicant's smoking habits, they do have several methods to verify this information.

One common method is through medical records. Insurance companies often request medical records as part of the application process, and nicotine use is typically noted in these records based on routine blood and urine analysis. Additionally, insurance companies may also access pharmaceutical databases to review an applicant's prescription history, which could reveal the use of smoking-cessation drugs.

Another way insurance companies verify smoking status is through medical exams, which typically include blood and urine tests that screen for nicotine and cotinine, a byproduct of nicotine. These substances can be detected in the bloodstream for a few days to a week, and even longer in urine samples. While nicotine may only be detectable for a short period, cotinine can remain in the body for up to a month. Therefore, it is challenging to hide smoking habits from these tests.

In addition to medical records and exams, insurance companies may also refer to past life and health insurance applications stored by companies like MIB, which flag discrepancies in an applicant's answers. Social media sites, such as Facebook, are also increasingly being used by insurance companies to gather information about applicants. Verisk, a data analytics provider, offers analytics that predict smoking status based on the sound of an applicant's voice, combined with other demographic and socioeconomic data.

While it may be tempting to lie about smoking status to secure lower insurance rates, the potential consequences outweigh the benefits. Insurance companies have a keen interest in accurately assessing smoking habits due to the financial risks associated with tobacco use. Therefore, they employ various methods to verify this information and detect any discrepancies.

What are the consequences of lying about smoking on a life insurance application?

Lying on a life insurance application is considered fraud and can have serious consequences. If you are caught lying during the application process, the insurance company can immediately decline coverage. If the lie is discovered after your policy goes into effect, your provider may review your policy for false statements or misrepresentations during the contestability period, which could result in a claim denial or a decreased death benefit.

Insurance companies have various methods to verify the information provided in your application. They may require a medical exam that includes blood and urine tests to detect nicotine or cotinine, a nicotine byproduct that stays in your blood longer than nicotine. They may also review your medical records, conduct personal interviews with your friends and relatives, and refer to databases such as the Medical Information Bureau (MIB), which stores coded data about medical conditions and risk factors.

If you lie about smoking on your life insurance application and are caught, your insurer may deny or delay the payout of your policy. Additionally, they can cancel your coverage or charge you a surcharge for the higher rate you should have been paying. In some cases, misrepresenting your smoking habits may be considered soft fraud, a misdemeanour that can result in legal consequences such as probation or community service.

It is important to be honest on your life insurance application, even if it means paying higher rates as a smoker. Lying about your smoking status may result in your loved ones being left with nothing if your insurer denies the claim due to misrepresentation.

What are the consequences of lying about smoking on a health insurance application?

Lying on a health insurance application is considered insurance fraud and can have serious consequences. While it is rare for an insurer to actively investigate whether an applicant smokes, there are still ways for them to find out. For example, during medical tests or blood and urine analysis, doctors can detect nicotine or tobacco use and will note this in the applicant's medical records. If an insurer discovers that an applicant has lied about their smoking habits, the policy could be revoked, or the insurer may refuse to pay the claim amount.

In the US, insurers consider an applicant a smoker if they have used tobacco or nicotine products four or more times a week in the past six months. If an applicant is a smoker, their premiums will be higher—up to 50% more than non-smokers. While it may be tempting to lie about smoking status to avoid these higher costs, doing so puts insurance benefits at stake. If an insurer discovers that an applicant has lied, they can retroactively impose the tobacco surcharge to the beginning of the plan year.

Additionally, if an applicant lies about their smoking status and is then diagnosed with something related to long-term smoking, the insurer may drop them for submitting fraudulent records. It is important to remember that insurance coverage is intended to protect loved ones financially, and lying to an insurance provider puts that financial security at risk.

Why do people lie about smoking on their insurance applications?

People may be tempted to lie about their smoking habits on insurance applications because of the significant financial implications. Insurance companies are allowed to charge smokers up to 50% more for premiums than non-smokers. This surcharge can amount to hundreds of dollars per month for some consumers. Given that insurance is already expensive, this can be a very tempting lie to tell.

However, lying on an insurance application is a form of insurance fraud and could come with serious consequences. If the lie is discovered, the insurance company can revoke the policy or refuse to pay the claim amount. The policyholder could also be prosecuted for fraud, which can result in sentences of probation, community service, or even jail time.

Despite the potential consequences, some people believe that insurance companies have no way of enforcing the truthfulness of applicants' responses regarding their smoking habits. For example, even if insurers could test applicants for the presence of nicotine, an applicant could claim that a positive result stemmed from a few cigarettes smoked outside their favorite bar on Friday nights. It would be difficult for the insurer to disprove such a claim.

Nevertheless, insurance companies do have ways of discovering lies or misrepresentations on insurance applications. During the medical tests, insurance companies can uncover lies about nicotine or tobacco use. Additionally, doctors will probably note tobacco use in the insured's medical records as a result of routine blood and urine analysis, creating a paper trail that could be flagged by the insurer when reviewing treatment bills.

Frequently asked questions