Malpractice Insurance: Texas Lawyers' Necessity?

In Texas, lawyers are not mandated by law to carry malpractice insurance. However, malpractice insurance is highly recommended for lawyers to protect themselves and their firms in the event of a malpractice claim. The average cost of defending against a malpractice claim is $60,000 per year, and the risk of not having insurance is significant. Texas lawyers have a variety of insurance providers to choose from, including Texas Lawyers Insurance Exchange (TLIE) and ALPS, with different coverage options and prices depending on their firm's size, practice areas, and desired policy limits.

Texas lawyers can choose from a variety of malpractice insurance providers

Texas lawyers are not required to carry malpractice insurance. However, malpractice insurance is essential for lawyers to protect themselves and their clients in the event of a mistake or error in judgement. Fortunately, there are several malpractice insurance providers that cater specifically to Texas-based attorneys.

One such provider is ALPS, which offers a 100% online insurance experience and is endorsed by more State Bars than any other carrier. ALPS has been insuring law firms across the country for almost 30 years and is the nation's largest direct writer of lawyers' malpractice insurance. They offer custom quotes and lawyer-recommended policy options to fit the unique needs of each firm.

Another option is Texas Lawyers Insurance Exchange (TLIE), a member-owned company with over 40 years of experience. TLIE offers flexible coverage options and provides resources to help lawyers avoid legal malpractice claims and grievance complaints. They also include $50,000 in cyber liability coverage in their policies.

Other providers of lawyers' professional liability insurance in Texas include Admiral Insurance Company, Allied World Assurance Company, Arch Insurance Group, Attorney Protective, Berkley Insurance Company, Chartis Lawyers Professional Liability Program, Chubb - Executive Risk, First Mercury Insurance Company, Hanover Professionals, Liberty Insurance Underwriters Inc., Liberty Surplus Insurance Corporation, Lloyd's of London - Attorney Select, Medmarc Casualty Insurance Co. (LawyerCare), Navigators Insurance Company, Noetic Specialty Insurance Co., Old Republic Insurance Company, RPS Plus/Markel Insurance Company, State National Insurance Company, Swiss Re Corporate Solutions, Underwriters at Lloyds (Synergy Professional Associates, Inc.), and U.S. Specialty Insurance.

While malpractice insurance is not mandatory for lawyers in Texas, it is a valuable form of protection for both the attorney and their clients. With a variety of reputable insurance providers to choose from, Texas lawyers can find the coverage they need to safeguard their practice and ensure peace of mind.

The average cost to defend against a malpractice claim is $60,000 per year

Lawyers in Texas are not required to carry malpractice insurance. However, the financial burden of malpractice claims can be significant. The average cost to defend against a malpractice claim is $30,000, including attorney's fees, expert witness costs, and reimbursement fees. This amount can vary depending on the venue and whether the case is expert-driven. It is worth noting that claims that go to trial are much more costly to defend than those that are dropped, withdrawn, or dismissed.

The cost of defending a malpractice claim can impact a lawyer's annual premium. Insurance companies consider the premiums collected against the payouts. If the defence costs exceed their thresholds, the insured can expect a rate increase. Additionally, defence costs can impact the marketability of the insured or their organisation.

The cost of a malpractice claim is not limited to defence costs. Expert witness fees, for example, can reach into the tens of thousands of dollars. Court filing fees and medical record acquisition costs are other expenses to consider. These costs are typically covered by the lawyer in a contingency fee agreement, where the lawyer's fee is a percentage of the court award or settlement. If the case is unsuccessful, the lawyer does not earn any legal fees.

While Texas lawyers are not mandated to carry malpractice insurance, clients should be aware of their lawyer's insurance status. It is recommended that clients proactively ask their lawyer about malpractice insurance and the coverage amount. This information can provide financial protection for clients in the event of a malpractice claim.

The cost of malpractice insurance depends on the firm's attorney count, practice areas, and location

In Texas, lawyers are not required to carry malpractice insurance. However, malpractice insurance is essential for attorneys to protect themselves from potential claims and lawsuits. The cost of malpractice insurance for law firms depends on various factors, including the number of attorneys, practice areas, and location.

The number of attorneys in a firm influences the cost of malpractice insurance. As the firm adds new lawyers, the premium increases, but not exponentially. Insurers use a "step rating" system, where a lawyer's premium is lower in their first year and gradually increases over time. The rate typically matures in the sixth year.

The practice areas of a law firm also impact the cost of insurance. Certain areas of law are associated with higher risks, resulting in higher premiums. High-severity areas include personal injury, wills, real estate, and trust and estate work. Insurers evaluate the frequency and severity of losses in different practice areas to determine premium rates.

Additionally, the location of the firm plays a role in insurance costs. Each state has a minimum premium requirement per attorney, and rates may vary depending on the area of practice within the state. For example, legal malpractice insurance in California may be more expensive due to specific state laws.

Other factors that contribute to the cost of malpractice insurance include the amount of deductible, firm's risk management systems, and part-time employment status of attorneys.

It's important to note that while malpractice insurance is not mandatory for Texas lawyers, it is crucial for attorneys to assess their risks and consider the benefits of having insurance to protect themselves and their firms from potential claims and lawsuits.

Criminal defense lawyers pay the lowest insurance premiums

In Texas, lawyers are not required to carry malpractice insurance. However, malpractice insurance is highly recommended to protect lawyers from the financial burden of malpractice claims. The cost of malpractice insurance varies depending on several factors, including the law firm's area of practice, firm size, location, desired policy limits, and risk management practices.

Criminal defense lawyers typically pay the lowest insurance premiums. This is because criminal law is considered a low-severity area of practice, and insurers perceive it as a lower-risk specialty. Other factors that contribute to lower premiums for criminal defense lawyers include the number of lawyers in the firm and the continuity of coverage.

The premium rates for criminal defense lawyers are influenced by the size of the law firm. Generally, as the number of lawyers in a firm increases, the premium rates also increase, but not exponentially. For example, the premium might double when going from one lawyer to two lawyers, but it won't triple or quadruple with each additional lawyer. Insurers often offer discounts to larger firms to retain their business.

Additionally, the continuity of coverage plays a role in premium rates. Insurers typically increase rates gradually over the first five years of a policy. After a law firm has been with the same insurer for five to six years, it is considered a mature firm, and the carrier may stop increasing the premium annually. This indicates that the lack of continuity with the insurance provider is not a factor in premium increases.

While criminal defense lawyers benefit from lower premiums due to their practice area being classified as low severity and low risk, it's important to note that all lawyers, regardless of their specialty, have a significant chance of facing a malpractice suit. Therefore, even lawyers in low-risk areas, such as criminal defense, should strongly consider obtaining malpractice insurance to protect themselves financially.

Malpractice insurance providers offer different policy limits and deductibles

While Texas lawyers are not required to carry malpractice insurance, it is still important to understand the different policy limits and deductibles offered by malpractice insurance providers.

Malpractice insurance policies typically have two types of limits: per-claim limits and overall limits per policy period. The per-claim limit refers to the maximum amount the insurance company will pay for a single claim during the policy period, usually one year. The overall limit, on the other hand, is the maximum amount the company will pay for all claims during the same policy period. For example, a policy might offer $250,000 per claim and $2.5 million in maximum coverage per policy period. This means that if a doctor makes a claim and has $250,000 in assistance available, the insurance company will pay up to that amount for that particular claim. However, if there are multiple claims during the policy period that total $4 million in losses, the policy will only cover up to the $2.5 million limit, leaving a potential gap in coverage.

In addition to policy limits, it is also important to consider deductibles. Some carriers offer lower premiums but charge a high deductible, which is the amount you must pay before the policy covers the remaining costs, awards, or settlements. When choosing a malpractice insurance policy, it is crucial to work with an insurance agent to determine the appropriate policy limits and deductibles that fit your specific needs and financial risks.

Furthermore, malpractice insurance carriers may offer their clients options for "shared limit" or "separate limit" coverage. In a standard medical malpractice group policy, each physician typically has their own individual, separate limit to maintain hospital privileges. However, in some cases, corporations and mid-level providers can be named in a claim, and it is important to properly insure these risks. Separate limit coverage provides each named insured with their own limit of liability, while shared limit coverage requires them to use another's limit of liability, typically one of the physicians on the policy.

While Texas lawyers are not mandated to have malpractice insurance, understanding the different policy limits and deductibles offered by insurance providers can help lawyers make informed decisions about their professional liability coverage.

Frequently asked questions