Life Insurance And Disaster: What's Covered And What's Not?

A common disaster clause is a provision in a will or insurance policy that addresses the situation where multiple individuals, such as spouses or beneficiaries, pass away simultaneously or within a short period of time. It establishes a plan for determining the distribution of assets or the order of succession in the event of a common disaster, such as a car accident, extreme weather event, fire, or plane crash. While it is not mandatory to include a common disaster clause in every life insurance policy, it is an important consideration to ensure that assets are distributed according to the wishes of the policyholder and to prevent unintended financial consequences.

The purpose of a common disaster clause

In the context of wills and estates, a common disaster clause addresses the situation where multiple individuals, such as spouses or beneficiaries, pass away simultaneously or within a short period of time. The clause typically outlines the order of survivorship or alternative distribution methods to ensure that the assets are distributed according to the wishes of the testator (the person making the will).

Within life insurance, a common disaster clause addresses the same scenario, where both the insured and the primary beneficiary of the policy die simultaneously or within a short period of time. The purpose is to establish an order of succession or alternative beneficiaries in case the primary beneficiary is unable to receive the policy benefits due to their simultaneous death with the insured.

The common disaster clause generally states that for the primary beneficiary to qualify to receive benefits, they must survive the insured by a certain number of days (usually 30-90 days). This is designed to prevent assets from passing into the estate of the other deceased individual, only to be immediately distributed from that person's estate. So, if a designated beneficiary dies shortly after the insured, the asset passes as if that person had died before the insured and goes directly to the contingent beneficiary instead. This can help limit financial consequences such as estate taxes and double probate costs.

In summary, the purpose of a common disaster clause is to provide a clear plan for the distribution of assets in the event of simultaneous deaths, ensuring that the wishes of the testator or insured are carried out and helping to prevent unintended financial consequences.

Common disaster clauses in wills

A "common disaster clause" in a will is a provision that addresses the situation where multiple individuals, such as spouses or beneficiaries, pass away simultaneously or within a short period of time, and it becomes necessary to determine the distribution of assets or the order of succession.

Specifying a Survivor

In the will of John and Mary Smith, a common disaster clause stated that if both died in a common disaster, Mary would be considered the survivor. This ensured that the estate distribution followed John's wishes if their order of death was indeterminable. Specifying a survivor can help to ensure that the assets are distributed according to the wishes of the testator (the person making the will).

Alternate Beneficiaries

In Doe v. Roe, the will included a common disaster clause that named alternate beneficiaries in case both spouses died simultaneously. This clause directed that their estate should pass to their children equally, preventing legal disputes over inheritance. Naming alternate beneficiaries can help to prevent legal conflicts and ensure a smooth transfer of assets.

Charitable Donations

A common disaster clause can specify that if a couple dies together, a portion of their estate will be donated to charity. This ensures that their philanthropic goals are met, even in the case of simultaneous death.

Survivor Period

A common disaster clause can establish a survivor period, such as 120 hours or more, that prevents the estate from immediately shifting to the survivor, even when death is imminent. This can help to avoid double taxation and unnecessary paperwork.

Defining How Assets Should Be Divided

A common disaster clause can define how assets should be divided in the event of simultaneous death. This can help to ensure that the estate is distributed in accordance with the wishes of the testator.

Common disaster clauses in life insurance

A "common disaster clause" in life insurance is a provision that addresses the situation where the insured and the primary beneficiary of the policy die simultaneously or within a short period of time. Its purpose is to establish an order of succession or alternative beneficiaries in case the primary beneficiary is unable to receive the policy benefits due to their simultaneous death with the insured.

Designation of Contingent Beneficiaries

One of the key purposes of a common disaster clause is to specify one or more contingent beneficiaries. These are individuals who would receive the policy proceeds if the primary beneficiary dies in a common disaster with the insured. By naming contingent beneficiaries, the clause ensures that the policy benefits are distributed according to the wishes of the insured.

Survivorship Period

Another common provision in a common disaster clause is the requirement that the primary beneficiary survive the insured by a certain length of time to qualify to receive the benefits. This period can vary, typically ranging from 14 to 30 days. If the primary beneficiary dies within this specified time frame, they are considered to have died first, and the proceeds would then be disbursed to the contingent beneficiaries.

Defining Asset Distribution

In the event of simultaneous death, a common disaster clause can define how assets should be divided. This is particularly important when couples have intertwined estates and have named different secondary beneficiaries or percentages of assets. The clause ensures that the estate is distributed according to the wishes of each individual.

Designating Order of Survivorship

When it is not possible to determine who died first, a common disaster clause can designate who is considered to have "died first" for legal purposes. This directive ensures that the estate automatically shifts to the side of the "survivor," following their beneficiary instructions.

Survivor Period

To prevent the immediate shifting of the estate to the survivor, a common disaster clause may establish a survivor period. This period, typically 120 hours or more, prevents the estate from being distributed to the survivor's beneficiaries upon their imminent death, thereby avoiding double taxation and unnecessary paperwork.

The Uniform Simultaneous Death Act

The USDA was first enacted in 1940 and was initially adopted by all 48 states in the US at the time. It has since been revised, with the most recent amendment in 1993. The current version of the USDA has been explicitly adopted by 19 states, the District of Columbia, and the Virgin Islands. Several other states have also indirectly adopted the Act as part of the Uniform Probate Code.

The USDA is particularly relevant in cases where individuals die intestate, or without a will. In such cases, probate courts are tasked with deciding how the estate is administered and distributed. Without the USDA, heirs would have to undergo two separate probate proceedings to transfer the assets of each deceased individual, resulting in increased costs and complexity. The USDA streamlines this process by allowing probate courts to resolve the distribution of inheritances in a single proceeding if the individuals passed away within 120 hours of each other.

The USDA also applies in certain life insurance scenarios. For example, if both the insured and the beneficiary die in a common disaster, the USDA can help determine the distribution of the insurance benefit. If the insured has named a secondary beneficiary, that person will receive the benefit. In the absence of a named secondary beneficiary, it is assumed that the insured outlived the beneficiary, and the benefit is inherited through the insured's estate.

It is important to note that the USDA does not eliminate the need for a common disaster clause in a will or insurance policy. The common disaster clause, also known as a survivorship or simultaneous death clause, provides specific instructions for how assets should be divided in the event of simultaneous or near-simultaneous deaths. This level of detail may be particularly important for high-net-worth couples with complex financial situations or individuals who wish to have greater control over the distribution of their assets after their death.

Estate planning attorneys

A common disaster clause, also known as a survivorship or simultaneous death clause, is designed to address situations where multiple individuals, such as spouses or beneficiaries, pass away simultaneously or within a short period of time. This type of clause outlines the order of survivorship and alternative distribution methods to ensure that assets are distributed according to the wishes of the testator (the person making the will). It provides clarity in cases where it is difficult to determine who died first, which can be common in accidents, natural disasters, or other unforeseen incidents.

In the context of life insurance, a common disaster clause establishes an order of succession or alternative beneficiaries if both the insured and the primary beneficiary die at the same time or within a specified time frame. This clause ensures that the policy proceeds are distributed as intended and helps prevent assets from passing into the estate of the other deceased individual, reducing potential financial consequences such as estate taxes and probate costs.

It is important to note that the role of an estate planning attorney goes beyond the inclusion of common disaster clauses. They provide comprehensive advice on estate planning strategies, tax implications, and the creation of wills and trusts. Consulting with an experienced estate planning attorney allows individuals to make informed decisions that are tailored to their unique circumstances, ensuring their wishes are respected and their assets are protected.

Frequently asked questions