Black Americans And Life Insurance: Who Has Coverage?

The topic of how many Black people have life insurance is a complex one, with historical and social factors influencing the rate of coverage. Despite Black Americans being more likely to own life insurance than whites, a significant coverage gap exists, with Black individuals having around a third of the coverage of their white counterparts. This disparity can be attributed to various factors, including discriminatory practices, the way life insurance was historically sold to the Black community, and the impact of COVID-19.

The issue of life insurance coverage among Black Americans is particularly pertinent given the racial wealth gap and the desire to pass on generational wealth. While the exact number of Black individuals with life insurance is challenging to pinpoint, studies and surveys provide insights into the rates of coverage and the factors influencing them.

Black Americans are more likely to own life insurance than whites but have less coverage

The relationship between life insurance and the African American community is complex. Although Black Americans are more likely to own life insurance than whites, their coverage is often far less. Black Americans typically have one-third of the coverage of their white counterparts, with policies that are often sold as burial insurance—smaller, cheaper policies that cover the bare minimum. This disparity has been caused by years of discriminatory practices that have reduced access to coverage and segregated the industry.

Historical discrimination in insurance

After the Civil War, insurers began classifying Black people who were former slaves as higher mortality risks, meaning they were charged more or denied coverage altogether. These practices continued into the 1960s, with separate sets of rates for Black and white applicants. While some states banned race-based underwriting, many insurers simply took their business elsewhere, further reducing access to coverage.

Mistrust in the insurance industry

Discriminatory practices have led to a level of mistrust between the Black community and the insurance world, with insurance companies finding creative ways to not pay claims. This has resulted in a situation where Black people have often been excluded from the conversation about protecting their assets and loved ones.

Factors affecting the cost of insurance

Years of discriminatory policies have also reduced access to medical care, housing, and education for many Americans, and all these things can factor into the cost of life insurance. If an applicant with a high school diploma, living in a poor neighborhood, applies for the same policy as someone with a Ph.D. living in an affluent neighborhood, the less educated applicant may get approved for coverage but will likely pay more for it. If premiums then become too expensive, coverage becomes inaccessible, and wealth is harder to pass down.

The impact of the coverage gap

The legacy of segregation, redlining, and discriminatory policies has made accumulating generational wealth a challenge for many in the Black community. The coverage gap means that when a person dies and is underinsured, assets that would have been passed down are often liquidated to pay for expenses, and less wealth is passed on.

Black Americans have one-third the coverage of white counterparts

Black Americans are more likely to own life insurance than their white counterparts, but they have significantly less coverage. According to a 2020 study by Haven Life, a life insurance company, Black Americans have one-third the coverage of white Americans. The study also found that both groups had less than the recommended coverage amount of five to ten times annual income. However, Black Americans reported having life insurance equal to about a year's income, while whites had almost three years' worth. This disparity is due to various factors, including historical discrimination, the way life insurance was sold to the Black community, and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Historical Discrimination

After the Civil War, insurance companies classified Black people, particularly former slaves, as higher mortality risks, resulting in higher charges or denial of coverage. These discriminatory practices persisted until the 1960s, with separate rate sets for Black and white applicants. While some states banned race-based underwriting, many insurers simply moved their business elsewhere, reducing coverage access and segregating the industry. This history of discrimination has impeded Black Americans' access to medical care, housing, and education, all of which are factors in determining life insurance costs.

Life Insurance Sales Tactics

For a long time, life insurance was often sold to African Americans as burial insurance, which are smaller and cheaper policies. These policies only cover the bare minimum, and sales agents often did not inform Black clients about other options. As a result, Black Americans were excluded from the conversation about protecting their assets and loved ones, leading to a lack of trust in the insurance industry.

Impact of COVID-19

The COVID-19 pandemic brought the idea of mortality to the forefront, increasing the demand for life insurance among all Americans, especially Black Americans, who suffered the highest death rate per 100,000 people. The pandemic highlighted the need for financial security and protection for loved ones, with many Black Americans seeking to ensure they could provide a proper burial for their family members.

Addressing the Coverage Gap

The coverage gap between Black and white Americans is a significant issue that needs to be addressed. It stems from broader historical and social injustices, making it challenging for policyholders to close the gap. Financial advisors, insurance agents, and online calculators can help individuals determine the appropriate amount of coverage based on their goals and financial obligations. Additionally, increasing education and representation among minority groups in the insurance industry can help bridge the gap and ensure equal access to financial protection for all Americans.

Life insurance was historically sold to Black Americans as burial insurance

After the Civil War, insurers began classifying Black people, particularly former slaves, as higher mortality risks, which led to higher charges or denial of coverage. These practices continued into the 1960s, with separate sets of rates for Black and white applicants. Although some states banned race-based underwriting, many insurers simply moved their business elsewhere, reducing access to coverage for Black Americans and further segregating the industry.

The emergence of Black-owned insurance companies, such as the African Insurance Company founded in 1810, provided an alternative for the Black community. However, these companies often faced challenges and were short-lived. The legacy of discriminatory practices, redlining, and segregation has contributed to a lack of trust and a coverage gap between Black and white Americans.

Today, Black Americans are more likely to own life insurance than whites, but they often have significantly less coverage. This coverage gap can be attributed to historical and social issues, such as the way life insurance was sold to the Black community and the impact of discriminatory practices on access to medical care, housing, and education, all of which can affect the cost of life insurance.

Black Americans are more likely to overestimate the cost of life insurance

The historical context plays a crucial role in understanding this disparity. After the Civil War, insurers classified Black people, particularly former slaves, as higher mortality risks, resulting in higher charges or denial of coverage. These discriminatory practices persisted into the 1960s, with separate rate sets for Black and white applicants. While some states banned race-based underwriting, many insurers simply moved their business elsewhere, reducing access to coverage for Black Americans and perpetuating segregation in the industry.

The legacy of these discriminatory policies has made it challenging for Black Americans to accumulate generational wealth. Life insurance is often viewed as a means to protect and pass on assets to the next generation. However, due to the coverage gap, when a person from the Black community dies and is underinsured, their assets are often liquidated to pay for expenses, resulting in less wealth being passed on.

Furthermore, life insurance was historically sold to African Americans as burial insurance, which are smaller and cheaper policies. Black Americans were often not informed about other options and ended up with less comprehensive coverage. This further contributes to the coverage gap and the financial challenges faced by the Black community.

To address these issues, it is crucial to increase financial literacy and education within the Black community, particularly regarding the true costs and benefits of life insurance. Efforts should be made to dispel misconceptions and build trust between the insurance industry and the Black community, which has been strained due to historical mistreatment.

Black Americans are more likely to view life insurance as a way to build generational wealth

Historical Discrimination

Following the Civil War, insurers began classifying Black people, particularly former slaves, as higher mortality risks, leading to higher charges or outright denial of coverage. These discriminatory practices persisted into the 1960s, with separate rate sets for Black and white applicants. While some states banned race-based underwriting, many insurers simply moved their business elsewhere, reducing coverage access for Black individuals and perpetuating segregation in the industry.

Exclusion from Asset Protection

For a long period, Black individuals were "excluded from the conversation" of protecting their assets and loved ones, according to Malcolm Ethridge, executive vice president and financial advisor with CIC Wealth. Insurance companies also devised creative ways to avoid paying claims, fostering a deep mistrust between the Black community and the insurance industry.

Impact of Discriminatory Policies

Years of discriminatory policies have hindered access to medical care, housing, and education for Black Americans, all of which influence the cost of life insurance. An applicant with a lower level of education living in a disadvantaged neighbourhood may be approved for a policy but will likely pay a higher price than a more educated applicant living in an affluent area. If premiums become unaffordable, coverage becomes out of reach, making wealth accumulation and intergenerational wealth transfer more challenging.

Life Insurance as Generational Wealth

The Haven Life study revealed that Black Americans are more likely than whites to view life insurance as a means to pass down generational wealth. However, when a person is underinsured, their assets are often liquidated to pay for expenses upon their death, resulting in less wealth being passed on. This perpetuates the cycle of generational wealth disparities between Black and white families.

Addressing Underinsurance

Black Americans' underinsurance is a complex issue rooted in historical and social injustices. While challenging to resolve, financial advisors, insurance agents, and online calculators can assist individuals in determining the appropriate amount of coverage for their needs. It is crucial to consider the purpose of the life insurance funds and the amount of money required to achieve those goals.

Frequently asked questions