Penalty Paid By Uninsured Americans

As of 2024, there is no longer a federal mandate or penalty for not having health insurance in the United States. The federal individual mandate penalty was eliminated at the end of 2018, with the shared responsibility payment or tax penalty ending in 2018. However, certain states have implemented their own health insurance requirements and penalties for non-compliance. These include California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington, D.C. In 2022, over 271,000 households in California paid fines for lacking health insurance, totalling around $312 million.

The federal penalty for not having insurance was eliminated in 2018/2019

The federal penalty for not having insurance was eliminated at the end of 2018, under the terms of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. This means that, as of 2019, there is no longer a federal tax penalty for not having health coverage. The individual mandate itself still exists, but there is no longer a penalty for non-compliance.

The elimination of the federal penalty for not having insurance was the result of a legislative process that began in 2017. The American Health Care Act (AHCA), which would have repealed the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in its entirety, failed to pass in the Senate. However, Congress then passed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which included a repeal of the individual mandate penalty. This was signed into law in December 2017 by President Trump. While the individual mandate penalty was repealed as of 2019, other provisions of the tax bill came into effect in 2018.

The individual mandate, which went into effect in 2014, required almost all Americans to maintain health insurance coverage unless they qualified for an exemption. From 2014 through 2018, the IRS assessed a penalty on tax filers who did not have health coverage and were not exempt. The repeal of the federal penalty for not having insurance does not affect the existence of the individual mandate itself, which remains in effect. However, there is no longer any financial consequence at the federal level for non-compliance.

Despite the elimination of the federal penalty, some states have implemented their own health coverage requirements and continue to assess penalties on residents who do not maintain health insurance coverage. As of 2024, financial penalties for being uninsured exist in Massachusetts, New Jersey, California, Rhode Island, and the District of Columbia. Vermont also requires residents to maintain health coverage and report their status on state tax returns, but there is no financial penalty for non-compliance.

Some states have implemented their own health insurance mandates

Since the federal individual mandate penalty was eliminated at the end of 2018, some states have implemented their own health insurance mandates and penalties for non-compliance. This is because, when healthy individuals are required to have health insurance, it helps spread the costs so that those with chronic conditions don't end up paying as much.

As of May 2023, the states with their own health insurance mandates include:

• Massachusetts: Implemented in 2006, the Massachusetts mandate is unique in that it predates the Affordable Care Act. The penalty only applies to adults and is based on the person's income and the cost of health plans available via the Massachusetts health insurance exchange. There are also affordability exemptions dependent on income.
• California: The state's individual mandate went into effect on January 1, 2020, and carries a penalty for non-compliance. California's definition of "minimal essential coverage" is the same as the federal requirement. The penalty is equal to 2.5% of salary or $695 per adult and $347.50 per child, or up to $2085 per family, whichever is greater.
• New Jersey: Implemented in 2019, the New Jersey mandate includes a penalty that is based on household income, not exceeding the average cost of a bronze plan in the state. Penalty revenue is used to fund a reinsurance program to lower overall healthcare costs.
• Rhode Island: Rhode Island's mandate, which includes an individual penalty for non-compliance, went into effect on January 1, 2020. The revenue generated from the penalty is used to fund the state's reinsurance program to help keep healthcare affordable.
• Vermont: Vermont's mandate went into effect on January 1, 2020, but there is no penalty for non-compliance.
• Washington, D.C.: The District's measure includes an individual penalty for non-compliance, assessed on residents for non-compliance, equal to the federal penalty defined in Section 5000A of IRC 1986.

Other states, such as Hawaii, Washington, Connecticut, Minnesota, and Maryland, are considering implementing their own health insurance mandates.

States with health insurance penalties include California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Rhode Island, and Washington, D.C

While the federal individual mandate penalty was eliminated at the end of 2018, some states have implemented their own health coverage requirements, with penalties for residents who don't maintain coverage. These states include California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Rhode Island, and Washington, D.C.

Massachusetts was the first state to implement an individual mandate and penalty in 2006. The penalty only applies to adults, and the amount is based on the person's income and the cost of health plans available via the Massachusetts health insurance exchange.

The District of Columbia implemented an individual mandate and penalty in January 2019, with flat rates of $695 per adult, half that for a child, or 2.5% of income, whichever is higher. There is a penalty cap based on the average cost of a bronze plan in DC.

New Jersey also implemented an individual mandate and penalty in January 2019, with penalty amounts mirroring the previous federal penalty. The state uses penalty revenue to fund its reinsurance program.

California enacted legislation in 2019 that created an individual mandate starting in 2020, with a penalty for non-compliance. California uses revenue from this program to offer additional state-funded health insurance subsidies.

Rhode Island implemented an individual mandate in 2020, with a penalty for non-compliance. The revenue generated from the penalty is used to fund the state's reinsurance program, which aims to stabilize the individual/family market.

While Vermont enacted a mandate that took effect in 2020, it opted not to impose any penalty for non-compliance. Maryland also removed mandate penalty language from a 2019 bill, instead creating an "easy enrollment health insurance program" to connect uninsured individuals with the state health insurance exchange.

The average penalty per household in California in 2022 was $1,149

Since 2019, there has been no federal penalty for not having health insurance in the US. However, some states have implemented their own health coverage requirements, with penalties for residents who do not comply. California is one of these states. Beginning in 2020, California residents must either have qualifying health insurance coverage or pay a penalty when filing their state tax returns. The penalty for not having coverage for the entire year is at least $900 per adult and $450 per dependent child under 18 in the household. The penalty is calculated based on the number of people in the household and income. For example, a family of four that goes uninsured for the whole year would face a penalty of at least $2,700. The average penalty per household in California in 2022 was $1,149. This amount is likely to vary depending on the size of the household and the income level.

The penalty for not having health insurance in California is known as the "Individual Shared Responsibility Penalty". It is important to note that there are exemptions from the requirement to have health insurance in California. These include having a short coverage gap of three consecutive months or less, being a member of a federally recognized Indian tribe, incarceration, religious conscience exemption, and affordability hardship, among others.

Exemptions to the penalty include low income, short coverage gaps, and unaffordable premiums

The federal individual mandate penalty for not having health insurance was eliminated at the end of 2018. However, some states in the US have implemented their own health coverage requirements, with penalties for residents who don’t maintain coverage. These include California, which enacted legislation in 2019 that created an individual mandate starting in 2020, with a penalty for non-compliance.

California residents must either have qualifying health insurance coverage, obtain an exemption from the requirement to have coverage, or pay a penalty when they file their state tax return. There are several exemptions to this penalty, including low income, short coverage gaps, and unaffordable premiums.

Low income is defined as income below the state tax filing threshold. For the 2023 taxable year, this was income below $57,994 for a married couple, both under 65 years old with one dependent. For the 2024 taxable year, income below the state tax filing threshold is considered an exemption for the 2024 taxable year.

Short coverage gaps refer to a gap in health insurance coverage of three consecutive months or less.

Unaffordable premiums are defined as health coverage that exceeds a certain percentage of household income. For the 2023 taxable year, this was health coverage that exceeded 8.17% of household income. For the 2024 taxable year, health coverage that exceeds 7.97% of household income is considered unaffordable.

Other exemptions to the penalty for not having health insurance in California include citizens living abroad or residents of another state, certain non-citizens who are not lawfully present, members of a health care sharing ministry, members of federally recognized tribes including Alaskan Natives, incarceration (other than incarceration pending the disposition of charges), and religious conscience exemption.

Frequently asked questions