Understanding Taxable Life Insurance Dividends: A Guide

Life insurance dividends are generally not taxable. The IRS considers them a return of premiums paid rather than a profit, and they are treated as contract distributions. However, there are exceptions. If your dividends exceed the total premiums paid, the excess may be taxable as income. If you leave your dividends in your policy to earn interest, this income may also be taxable if it is more than you have paid in premiums. If your life insurance policy is a modified endowment contract (MEC), most dividends you earn will be taxable, except when used to pay the policy's premiums or purchase additional insurance.

Life insurance dividends are generally not taxable

However, there are a few exceptions. If you leave the dividends in your policy and they earn interest, the gains from this interest may be taxable. If the amount of dividends you receive is greater than the total premiums you have paid into the policy, the excess may also be taxable, as any dividends over the amount you paid are considered income.

If your life insurance policy is considered a modified endowment contract (MEC), most dividends you earn will be taxable, except when used to pay the policy's premiums or to purchase additional insurance. With a MEC, the IRS will tax life insurance dividends that represent a gain in the contract, calculated based on the difference between the policy's cash value and any premiums paid into the policy, minus any tax-free amounts or withdrawals the policyholder previously received.

Life insurance dividends are a benefit from whole life insurance policies that come from the insurer's profits. Dividends are common with whole life policies, but some term life insurance policies also offer this benefit. Policyholders can use the dividends in several ways, including reducing premiums, paying down loans, earning interest, or buying additional insurance.

Dividends exceeding premiums paid may be taxable

Dividends from life insurance are generally not taxable. The IRS considers them a return of premiums paid. However, if your dividends exceed the premiums you've paid into your policy, the excess amount may be subject to taxation. This is because any dividends over and above what you've paid are considered income rather than a return of premium.

For example, if you pay $1,000 in premiums and receive a dividend of $1,250, you may be required to pay taxes on the $250 surplus. It's important to consult with tax professionals to determine your specific tax liabilities in such cases.

Additionally, if you choose to leave your dividends in your policy to accumulate interest, the interest earned may be taxable if it exceeds the amount of premiums you've paid.

Interest earned on dividends is taxable

Life insurance dividends are generally not taxable. This is because the IRS considers them to be a return of premiums paid rather than a profit. However, there is an exception to this rule: if you leave your dividends in your policy to earn interest, this interest income may be taxable.

If you choose to leave your dividends in your policy to earn interest, the interest earned may be taxable if it exceeds the amount you have paid in premiums. This is because any dividends over the amount you paid are considered income, not a return of premium. For example, if you pay $1,000 in life insurance premiums in a year and receive a $1,250 dividend, you may owe taxes on the $250 excess.

The taxability of interest earned on life insurance dividends is an important consideration when deciding how to receive and use your dividends. You may want to consult a tax professional to determine whether you owe taxes on any interest earned.

It is worth noting that the rules and rates around dividends vary by insurer, and this benefit is also not guaranteed. It depends on the insurer's investment returns, expenses, and the number of mortality claims paid out in a given year.

Modified endowment contracts (MECs) make most dividends taxable

A Modified Endowment Contract (MEC) is a cash value life insurance policy that has lost its tax benefits because it contains too much cash. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) reclassifies a life insurance policy as an MEC when the total collected premiums and cash value exceed federal tax-law limits. This permanent change can happen when you pay excess premiums in too short a period.

The MEC limits for a policy depend on its terms and death benefit amount. Your insurance company will warn you if a policy is about to become, or has become, an MEC. The IRS requires a life insurance policy to comply with a strict set of criteria to avoid becoming an MEC.

A life insurance policy is considered an MEC by the IRS if it meets three criteria:

• The policy was entered into on or after June 20, 1988.
• It must meet the statutory definition of a life insurance policy.
• The policy must fail to meet the Technical and Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988 (TAMRA) "seven-pay test."

The seven-pay test determines whether the total amount of premiums paid into a life insurance policy within the first seven years is more than what you'd need to pay it up in full for those seven years. Policies become MECs when the premiums paid to the policy exceed what would be needed to pay within the seven-year time frame.

If your life insurance policy is considered an MEC, most dividends you earn will be taxable, with some exceptions. The IRS will tax life insurance dividends that represent a gain in the contract, calculated based on the difference between the policy's cash value and any premiums paid into the policy, minus any tax-free amounts or withdrawals the policyholder previously took or received.

With an MEC, withdrawals and loans are taxed and possibly penalized if early, similar to those taken from non-qualified annuities. A 10% premature withdrawal penalty may apply for withdrawals before the age of 59 1/2.

Despite the reduced tax benefits and other limitations of MECs, they are often marketed as an estate planning tool. MECs still provide a way to pass assets to beneficiaries tax-free upon the owner's death, without probate proceedings.

Dividends are not guaranteed

When an insurance company has a profitable year, it may share its profits with policyholders in the form of dividends. These dividends are typically paid out annually and are based on the company's financial performance, including investment returns and the number of death claims paid out. However, it's important to note that these dividend payments are not guaranteed.

The likelihood of receiving dividend payments depends on the insurer's financial health and performance. Before purchasing a policy, it's essential to review the insurer's credit rating and history of dividend payments. Most insurers that offer participating life insurance policies aim to pay dividends consistently, but their ability to do so depends on the accuracy of their projections about death benefits, expenses, and investment performance.

In years when the insurer experiences higher-than-expected mortality expenses or poor investment performance, they may be unable to pay dividends. Therefore, it's important for policyholders to recognize that dividends are not guaranteed and should not be the sole factor in choosing an insurance policy.

While dividends can add value to a policy, they should not be the primary reason for selecting an insurer. It's crucial to consider other factors, such as the insurer's financial strength, the policy's coverage, and whether the dividends are guaranteed for the life of the policy.

To make an informed decision, individuals should carefully review the details of different policies and consider seeking advice from financial professionals.

Frequently asked questions