Auto Insurance: Recession-Proof Or Not?

With the world on the brink of a recession, it's only natural to wonder how this will impact different industries. While auto insurance is not entirely recession-proof, it is required in most states, which explains why people continue to buy it even in times of economic downturn. During past recessions, people have been able to lower their auto insurance costs by dropping add-ons, raising deductibles, or paying for repairs out of pocket instead of submitting insurance claims. However, while these strategies can provide short-term savings, they also shift the financial risk back to the policyholder, defeating the purpose of having insurance in the first place.

Drivers may drop add-ons and assume more risk

During a recession, drivers may opt to reduce their auto insurance costs by dropping add-ons and assuming more risk. This strategy can result in significant savings but also carries financial risks.

One way to reduce auto insurance costs is to forgo optional coverages, such as comprehensive and collision insurance, especially for older vehicles. Between 2006 and 2010, the average percentage of older vehicles without collision or comprehensive coverage increased from 53% to 63%, resulting in annual savings of $229 per vehicle. However, dropping these coverages leaves drivers more financially vulnerable in the event of an accident or claim.

Another tactic to lower insurance costs is to increase the deductible, which is the amount the policyholder must pay out of pocket before the insurance policy begins to pay. During the recession, there was a shift towards higher deductibles, as this reduces the immediate out-of-pocket costs of auto insurance. However, opting for a higher deductible places drivers at risk of economic hardship in the event of a loss.

While dropping add-ons and increasing deductibles can lead to short-term savings, it is important to carefully consider the potential financial risks associated with these decisions. In the event of an accident or claim, drivers may be faced with higher out-of-pocket expenses, which could result in economic hardship, especially during a recession when finances are already strained.

It is worth noting that a recession can also prompt drivers to shop around for more competitive rates and take advantage of discounts to save on their auto insurance without assuming additional risk.

There will be less demand for auto insurance

During a recession, there will be less demand for auto insurance. This is because people have less money to spend on insurance, even though it is important and, in some cases, required. This decrease in demand will make the market more competitive, and insurance companies will need to pair competitive prices with convenient and personal digital experiences to attract customers.

In addition, people may be less likely to buy new cars during a recession, which could reduce the demand for auto insurance. People may also be more likely to drive less during a recession, which could lead to a decrease in the number of insurance claims and, consequently, a decrease in the demand for auto insurance.

Furthermore, a recession could cause insurance companies to tighten their belts and be more selective about the policies they offer. This could result in fewer policies being available and more expensive premiums for consumers.

Overall, while auto insurance is not necessarily recession-proof, the demand for it may be somewhat insulated from the effects of a recession, as people may still need insurance for their vehicles, even if they are driving less or have older cars. However, the impact of a recession on the auto insurance industry will depend on various factors, including the severity of the recession and the state of the economy before the recession.

Companies will face more regulation

In an uncertain economic climate, the scrutiny of financial institutions becomes even more crucial. During a recession, stricter consumer protection laws are implemented to safeguard consumers from any exploitation by financial institutions. As a result, insurance companies will likely find themselves under greater scrutiny by the government through complex rules and elaborate procedures. This will mean extra expenditure on compliance and regulations.

In the United States, auto insurance companies are regulated and governed on a state-by-state basis, with state regulators issuing licenses and examining company coverage, policies, and financial health. While the federal government does not regulate auto insurance rates, it does oversee state legislatures that govern insurance through the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). The NAIC brings together the heads of each state's insurance regulation department to unify procedures and policies and share ideas without official federal oversight.

State regulators' primary responsibilities are to preserve the long-term solvency of insurance companies and protect insurance consumers from unfair and discriminatory treatment. They ensure that insurance companies can offer fair prices and match the coverage needs of policyholders. To achieve this, regulators require auto insurance companies to prove that they can pay out large claim amounts and offer customers fairly priced options.

The trend in the U.S. is moving towards more states adopting a competitive rating system, also known as "file-and-use," which relies on marketplace forces to keep insurance rates consistent with underlying costs. As of 2024, 38 states have some form of file-and-use for auto insurance, while 13 have a prior approval system where rates must be individually approved by regulators before taking effect.

While increased regulation can be a burden for insurance companies, it is important to note that it ultimately aims to protect consumers and ensure fair practices in the industry.

Inflation may leave you underinsured

Inflation has also led to significant increases in the costs of vehicle repairs, medical care services, and vehicle parts and equipment. These increases in replacement costs can result in insurance holders being underinsured, as the cost to replace their losses is now much higher than what was previously insured. For example, the average bodily injury liability payout in 2022 was $24,211 per accident, a $4,246 increase from the average claim in 2020. This means that if your coverage limit has remained the same, you may be underinsured in the event of an accident.

Additionally, inflation has impacted the insurance industry as a whole, with insurers facing increased costs and challenges in settling claims efficiently. Insurers invest the premium payments they receive from policyholders, and during a slow economy, the returns on these investments are lower. As a result, insurance companies may need to recover their invested money by challenging their existing operations, including the way they settle claims. This could lead to delays in paying out claims and impact your financial protection.

To address the risk of underinsurance due to high inflation, it is recommended to review your insurance arrangements with your insurer or broker. Ensure that the 'declared asset values' or the insured value of your properties and assets are still accurate and up to date. By increasing your coverage limits, you can ensure that you have sufficient financial protection in the event of a claim.

Consumers will adopt new coverage options

One of the new coverage options that consumers are adopting is rideshare insurance. This type of insurance is designed for those who use their personal vehicles for ridesharing or food delivery services. It fills the gaps in coverage that may exist when using a personal vehicle for commercial purposes. As more people turn to ridesharing and food delivery services for income, the demand for rideshare insurance will likely increase.

Another coverage option that is gaining traction is gap insurance. Gap insurance is particularly useful for those who lease or finance their vehicles. In the event of a total loss, gap insurance covers the difference between the actual cash value of the vehicle and the amount still owed on the lease or loan. With the increasing popularity of leasing and financing options, gap insurance provides valuable protection for consumers.

Additionally, consumers are also showing interest in custom parts and equipment (CPE) coverage. CPE coverage is ideal for those who have modified their vehicles with custom parts, such as a stereo system, navigation system, or custom wheels. This type of coverage ensures that these modifications are protected in the event of an accident or theft. As more people invest in customizing their vehicles, the demand for CPE coverage is likely to rise.

Furthermore, consumers are also adopting pet injury coverage, which is now offered by some insurance companies. This coverage takes care of veterinary bills if a pet is injured in an accident while riding in the insured's vehicle. For pet owners, this coverage provides peace of mind and financial relief during difficult times.

By adopting these new coverage options, consumers are able to tailor their insurance policies to their specific needs and ensure that they have the protection they require. These options not only provide added flexibility but also enhance the overall auto insurance experience for consumers.

Frequently asked questions