Life Insurance Cash Value: Market Volatility Risks?

Cash value life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that features a cash value savings component. This means that the policyholder can borrow or withdraw cash from the policy or use it to pay premiums. The cash value of a permanent life insurance policy can function as a tax-deferred savings or investment account. However, the volatility of cash value life insurance depends on the type of policy chosen. Whole life insurance policies, for example, offer fixed premiums and cash-value interest rates, while variable life policies allow the policyholder to choose where to invest their cash value, with the potential for greater gains or losses.

Cash value life insurance as an investment

Cash value life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that features a savings component, allowing the policyholder to use the cash value for several purposes, including borrowing or withdrawing cash, or using it to pay policy premiums. This type of insurance is more expensive than term life insurance because of the cash value element.

When you pay your premium, a portion goes towards the policy's cash value, which earns interest over time at either a fixed or variable rate, depending on the type of permanent policy. Whole life, universal life, variable universal life, and indexed universal life insurance are all examples of cash value life insurance.

The cash value component serves as a living benefit for policyholders, who may access the funds in several ways. Most policies allow for partial withdrawals or surrenders, though these reduce the death benefit. Some policies also allow for loans from the cash value, which must be repaid with interest. If the loan is not repaid, the insurer will subtract the outstanding amount from the death benefit.

The cash value of life insurance accumulates on a tax-deferred basis, providing tax advantages. However, if you withdraw cash value or terminate the policy, you may be taxed on the portion of money that came from interest or investment gains.

While cash value life insurance can be a good investment option for those looking to build a nest egg over several decades, it is not the best choice for everyone. It tends to have higher premiums than term life insurance, and managing policies often requires a hands-on approach. Additionally, it can take years to build up enough cash value to access the money within the policy.

Before deciding on cash value life insurance, consider your financial goals and risk tolerance. It is recommended to first maximise other savings options like IRAs and 401(k)s before opting for cash value life insurance as an investment.

Cash value life insurance and market volatility

Cash value life insurance is a form of permanent life insurance that lasts for the lifetime of the holder and features a cash value savings component. The cash value of a life insurance policy is subject to market forces, and the impact of market volatility depends on the type of policy. Traditional cash value policies, like whole life insurance, have a fixed interest rate set when you purchase your policy. This safeguards your policy against market volatility.

On the other hand, indexed universal and variable universal life insurance policies rely on stock market performance and are more volatile than whole life policies, offering higher risk and higher reward. The cash value in these policies can decrease if the market underperforms. Variable universal life policies allow the policyholder to choose where to invest their cash value, and their growth depends on the performance of these underlying investments.

While cash value life insurance can be used as a savings vehicle, it is generally not recommended as an investment due to the high cost of premiums and minimal payoff in returns. Additionally, combining your life insurance policy with your investments puts all your eggs in one basket, and you risk losing both your life insurance and your investment.

Cash value life insurance costs

Cash value life insurance policies are a form of permanent life insurance that features a cash value savings component. This means that the policyholder can use the cash value for various purposes, such as borrowing or withdrawing cash, or using it to pay policy premiums. The cash value of life insurance earns interest, and taxes are deferred on the accumulated earnings.

The cost of cash value life insurance policies is typically higher than that of term life insurance policies. This is because cash value life insurance is permanent, whereas term life insurance expires after a specific number of years. Additionally, a portion of each premium payment for cash value life insurance goes into the policy's cash value, which increases over time. The cost of cash value life insurance will depend on several factors, including the type of policy chosen, the death benefit amount, age, gender, health, and hobbies.

For example, the average cost of a $500,000 whole life insurance policy for a healthy 30-year-old is $440 per month as of October 2024. This cost can vary depending on personal factors, with women generally securing lower rates than men due to their longer life expectancy. It is important to note that different insurance providers will also consider an individual's medical history, lifestyle, occupation, and family medical history when determining rates.

While cash value life insurance policies offer the benefit of lifelong coverage and flexible access to funds, they may not be the best option for everyone. Those primarily concerned with short-term coverage or looking for the most cost-effective option may find that term life insurance better suits their needs.

Cash value life insurance withdrawals

Cash value life insurance is a form of permanent life insurance that lasts for the lifetime of the holder and features a cash value savings component. The policyholder can use the cash value for several purposes, including borrowing or withdrawing cash from it, or using it to pay policy premiums.

Withdrawing Cash from Cash Value Life Insurance

Partial withdrawals from cash value life insurance policies are usually permissible, although they may be limited in number and amount. Withdrawals will generally reduce the death benefit, sometimes by more than the amount withdrawn, depending on the specific terms of the policy. Withdrawals up to the amount paid into the policy are typically tax-free, but withdrawals above this amount may be taxed as ordinary income.

Borrowing Cash from Cash Value Life Insurance

Policyholders can usually borrow money through their cash value life insurance policy. The amount that can be borrowed varies and is typically based on the value of the policy's cash-accumulation account and the contract's terms. Borrowing from a cash value life insurance policy usually does not require a loan application or credit check, and the interest rate is often lower than that of a personal loan. Borrowed amounts are generally not taxable, but they do accrue interest, and if the loan is not repaid, the outstanding balance will be deducted from the death benefit.

Surrendering Cash Value Life Insurance Policy

Policyholders can also choose to surrender their cash value life insurance policy, which involves cancelling the policy and receiving a cash payment equal to the surrender value. However, this option should be considered a last resort, as it results in the loss of life insurance coverage, and the cash received may be subject to surrender fees and taxes.

Cash value life insurance alternatives

Cash value life insurance is a permanent life insurance policy that lasts for the lifetime of the holder and features a savings component. While it has its benefits, it may not be the best option for everyone. Here are some alternatives to cash value life insurance:

Income Protection Insurance

Income protection insurance provides monthly, tax-free income if you are unable to work for a prolonged period due to an illness or injury. It can be a good alternative if you are unable to qualify for or renew your life insurance policy.

Guaranteed Coverage Plan

A guaranteed coverage plan does not require a medical exam or records, making it a great alternative if you have been denied coverage due to medical factors. However, it typically comes with high premiums, and the death benefit is usually capped at a relatively low amount.

Critical Illness Insurance

Critical illness insurance provides a tax-free lump sum if you develop a life-threatening illness. It is designed to replace income rather than provide a death benefit. Some policies do not have a waiting period, allowing immediate access to funds for treatment or living expenses during recovery.

Accidental Death and Dismemberment (AD&D) Insurance

AD&D insurance covers fatal accidents or the accidental loss of a limb. It does not consider your medical history or lifestyle choices, making it an option for those who may not qualify for life insurance. The premiums for this type of insurance can be very affordable.

Mortgage Protection Insurance

Mortgage protection insurance pays off the remaining balance of your mortgage if you pass away or are unable to work due to a disability. The payout goes directly to your mortgage lender, ensuring your loved ones won't have to worry about losing their home.

Pre-paid Funeral Plan

A pre-paid funeral plan covers the expenses associated with a funeral, alleviating the financial burden on your loved ones during their time of grief. This option can be a good alternative to life insurance for covering final expenses.

Asset-Based Long-Term Care Insurance

Asset-based long-term care insurance combines long-term care coverage with an investment component. The investment component builds cash value over time, which can be used to pay for long-term care services, with any remaining proceeds passed on to beneficiaries.

Employer-Issued Insurance

If you are employed, you may be eligible for employer-issued insurance, which is sometimes offered as an optional benefit. Some employers provide a minimum amount of coverage at no cost, and you may be able to increase the coverage if needed.

Self-Funded Savings

If you are not eligible for insurance or prefer not to maintain coverage, you can create your own savings to provide for your loved ones upon your passing. This could involve putting money into a savings account or reallocating your portfolio to maximize interest.

Frequently asked questions