Excess Interest Life Insurance: Taxable Or Not?

Life insurance is often taken out to provide peace of mind that one's family will be financially secure in the event of one's death. However, many worry about the tax implications of such policies, both for themselves and their beneficiaries. While life insurance proceeds are typically tax-free, there are several exceptions and complications that beneficiaries and policyholders should be aware of. Understanding these can help individuals make smart financial choices and avoid unexpected tax burdens.

Interest on life insurance payouts

The same is true for annuities, where the proceeds and accumulated interest are paid out regularly over the life of the beneficiary. The interest on these payments is also taxable.

If you choose to let the life insurance company keep the money and invest it for you, you will only receive the interest on the payout, which is taxable. With this option, you have no control over your money, and the insurance company chooses how to invest it.

It is important to note that the death benefit itself is typically not taxed. However, if the payout is set up to be paid in multiple payments, only the interest portion of those payments is subject to taxes.

To avoid paying taxes on the interest, it is generally recommended to choose a lump-sum payout option. This option gives you more control over your money and allows you to put it to good use immediately. You can then invest the lump sum with the help of a financial advisor and pay taxes on the growth.

Surrendering a life insurance policy

Whole and universal policies accrue cash value over time, making them the most likely option for surrender. The cash value of a policy depends on the type and age of the policy, with older policies likely to have accrued more cash value. Surrendering a policy can be an appealing prospect if the coverage is no longer needed, but it can also result in a significant loss on the investment.

There are a few important things to consider before surrendering a life insurance policy:

• Surrender fees: If a policy is surrendered early on in its term, surrender fees may be incurred, reducing the amount of cash received.
• Taxes: The cash received from surrendering a policy is generally treated as regular income and is therefore taxable. If the cash surrender value is higher than the amount paid in premiums, the excess amount will be taxed as ordinary income.
• Loss of coverage: Surrendering a policy means giving up the death benefit. This should be carefully considered, especially if there are still individuals who depend on the policyholder financially.
• Alternatives: There are other ways to access the cash value of a policy without surrendering it, such as borrowing against the cash value or withdrawing from it.

Before making any decisions, it is important to consult with a tax professional and carefully review the policy documents.

Life insurance and estate taxes

Life insurance death benefits are typically tax-free, but there are exceptions. One such exception is when the policyholder leaves the death benefit to their estate instead of directly naming a person as the beneficiary. In this case, the death benefit becomes part of the taxable estate, and if the estate's total value surpasses the federal estate tax exemption, estate taxes will need to be paid, reducing the amount received by loved ones.

The federal estate tax exemption was $12.92 million in 2023 and $13.61 million in 2024. If the total value of the deceased's estate, including the life insurance proceeds, exceeds this threshold, estate taxes must be paid on the amount over the limit.

To avoid this, it is essential to regularly review beneficiaries and ensure that your estate is not named as the beneficiary. Instead, a trusted person should be directly named, and a contingent beneficiary should also be designated.

Another strategy to minimise potential tax liabilities is to use an irrevocable trust, such as an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT). By transferring the policy to an ILIT, the death benefit can be kept out of the taxable estate, provided certain rules are met and the transfer occurs at least three years before death.

Additionally, it is important to consider the impact of any outstanding loans or withdrawals from the policy, as these can reduce the death benefit and potentially trigger taxable income. Keeping policy loans in check and ensuring the policy remains active can help prevent taxable income from policy loans.

In summary, careful planning and consideration of the tax implications of life insurance and estate taxes can help protect the benefits for loved ones and safeguard them from unexpected tax complications.

Choosing a death benefit annuity

When choosing a death benefit annuity, it is important to understand the different options available and the factors that may impact your decision. Here are some key considerations to keep in mind:

• Type of annuity: Different types of annuities offer different death benefit options. For example, a standard death benefit pays the annuity's contract value at the time of the annuitant's death, while a return of premium death benefit returns the total premiums paid into the annuity (less prior withdrawals) or the account value, whichever is larger.
• Payout structure: Death benefits can be paid as a lump sum or in regular installments. It's important to consider the tax implications of each option. Lump-sum payments are generally tax-free, while installments may be subject to taxes on the interest that accumulates.
• Beneficiary designation: It is crucial to name a beneficiary for your annuity to ensure that the funds go to the intended person after your death. You can choose a primary beneficiary, who has the first right to claim the death benefit, and a secondary beneficiary, who would receive the benefit if the primary beneficiary is unable or unwilling to collect it.
• Tax implications: Annuity death benefits may be taxable for beneficiaries, so it's important to understand the tax consequences for your chosen option. Consult a tax professional to get specific advice for your situation.
• Age, relationship, and financial status of beneficiaries: Consider the age, relationship, and financial circumstances of your beneficiaries when choosing a death benefit annuity. For example, if you name a child as a beneficiary, they won't be able to access the annuity until they reach the age of majority (18). Additionally, if a beneficiary receives government benefits, the proceeds from the annuity might affect their eligibility.
• Review and update beneficiary information: Remember to review and update your beneficiary designations regularly, especially after major life events such as marriage, divorce, or the birth of a child.

Withdrawing from a whole life policy

Whole life insurance is a versatile financial tool that can provide added protection for your loved ones. It is a type of permanent life insurance that provides coverage for your entire life, not just a predetermined amount of time. Whole life insurance also has a cash value component that can be used to supplement income in retirement or cover large purchases. This cash value grows over time, earning tax-deferred interest, and can be accessed through withdrawals, loans, or by surrendering the policy.

Methods of Withdrawing from a Whole Life Policy

There are several ways to withdraw cash from a whole life policy:

• Withdrawal: In many situations, you can take a cash withdrawal from your permanent life policy, and that money is often not subject to income taxes as long as it's not more than the amount you've paid into the policy. However, withdrawing cash may reduce your death benefit, and withdrawals above your cost basis may be subject to taxation.
• Loan: You can typically borrow money through your policy, with the insurer using your policy as collateral. Life insurance loans include interest payments, but they are usually at a lower rate than personal loans. There is no loan application or credit check, and credit rating does not impact your interest rate. You can choose not to repay the loan, but the outstanding balance will typically be deducted from your death benefit.
• Surrender: You can cancel your policy and take the surrender value cash payment. However, this option comes with several downsides. You will no longer have life insurance coverage, and the cash you receive will be lowered by any fees taken out. Surrender fees can be significant, especially for newer policies. Additionally, if you have accumulated cash value in your policy, surrendering it may result in tax liabilities on any gains.

Considerations for Withdrawing from a Whole Life Policy

When considering withdrawing from a whole life policy, it's important to keep the following in mind:

• Tax implications: Withdrawals up to your cost basis (the total amount of premiums paid) are generally not taxable. However, withdrawals above this amount may be subject to income taxes. Additionally, if you surrender your policy, any gains on the policy may be taxed as ordinary income.
• Reduced death benefit: Withdrawing cash from your whole life policy will likely result in a reduction in your death benefit. This could impact your beneficiaries' financial future, so it's important to consider their needs before making a withdrawal.
• Loan interest: While life insurance loans typically have lower interest rates than personal loans, interest accumulates on your outstanding balance. If the balance exceeds the cash value, your policy could lapse, resulting in a taxable event.
• Alternative options: Before withdrawing from your whole life policy, consider other options such as borrowing against your retirement account, taking out a home equity loan, or selling your insurance policy (if allowed). These alternatives may provide access to needed funds without compromising your life insurance coverage.

In conclusion, while withdrawing from a whole life policy can provide needed funds, it's important to carefully consider the potential tax implications, the impact on your death benefit, and alternative options before making a decision.

Frequently asked questions