Electric Vehicle Insurance: Higher Costs?

Electric vehicles (EVs) are becoming increasingly popular, but insuring them is generally more expensive than insuring gas-powered vehicles. On average, car insurance for an electric car is about $337 per month or $4,043 per year, which is 20% more than the cost of insuring a gas-powered car. This is mainly due to the higher cost of buying and repairing EVs. For example, a new EV battery can cost between $4,000 and $20,000, compared to $100-$200 for a gas-powered car battery. Additionally, there are fewer repair shops with technicians trained to fix electric vehicles, which can result in higher repair charges. However, insurance rates for EVs have dropped significantly in recent years, and EVs may be eligible for unique discounts and tax incentives that can offset the higher premium costs.

Electric vehicles are more expensive to repair or replace

Electric vehicles are generally more expensive to repair or replace than their gas-powered counterparts. This is mainly due to the higher cost of parts and the specialised knowledge required to repair these vehicles.

Firstly, electric vehicles tend to be pricier to repair because they are more expensive to purchase in the first place. This means that the cost of parts is higher, and the cost of repairs is often commensurate with the value of the vehicle. For example, the average cost to repair an electric vehicle after a collision is $4,041, compared to $3,189 for a non-electric vehicle. This disparity is even more pronounced for luxury SUVs, with the average repair cost for electric vehicles in this category being 53% higher than for non-electric vehicles.

Secondly, there is a scarcity of repair shops that specialise in electric vehicle repair. This means that there is a limited supply of mechanics with the knowledge and skills to repair these vehicles, driving up the cost of repairs. Additionally, some manufacturers make it difficult for mechanics to obtain parts or information about how to repair certain electric vehicle components, which further increases the cost of repairs.

Thirdly, electric vehicles are heavier than similar-sized gas-powered vehicles due to their battery packs. This means that they collide with greater force, potentially causing more damage and increasing the cost of repairs. Electric vehicles also tend to have more advanced driver assistance systems, which are expensive to replace if they are damaged in a collision.

Finally, electric vehicles are often made with lightweight, high-strength materials to offset the weight of the battery. These materials are also expensive to replace if they are damaged.

While electric vehicles may be more expensive to repair or replace, it is worth noting that they require less frequent repairs than gas-powered vehicles. This is because they have fewer moving parts and do not require regular maintenance such as oil changes.

EVs' higher price tag and more complex equipment

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive to buy than traditional gas-powered cars. The average price for an electric vehicle in July 2023 was $53,469, compared to $48,334 for a gas-powered vehicle. This higher price tag is largely due to the high cost of EV batteries, which can range from $4,000 to $20,000, depending on the make and model. In comparison, an internal combustion engine (ICE) car battery costs between $100 and $200.

The high cost of EV batteries is due to the minerals they are made from, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are in high demand and sometimes in limited supply. As a result, the battery can represent up to 50% of an EV's price tag. This makes EVs more expensive to repair or replace if they are damaged in an accident, which can lead to higher insurance rates.

In addition to the higher price tag, EVs also have more complex equipment. The technology behind EVs is still relatively new, and there are fewer repair shops with technicians trained to fix them. This means that qualified repair facilities may charge more for repairs due to the specialized training required.

The scarcity of repair shops and higher repair costs lead to potentially higher costs for insurance companies in the event of a claim involving an EV. This results in higher insurance rates for EV policyholders. However, as EVs become more common, the availability of parts and qualified repair shops is expected to increase, which should drive down the cost of repairs and insurance rates.

Repairing damaged battery packs is costly

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive to insure than traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) or gas-powered vehicles. One of the main reasons for this is that repairing damaged battery packs is costly. Battery packs are expensive to repair and, in many cases, replacing them is cheaper than repairing them, despite batteries representing up to 50% of an EV's price tag. This is further exacerbated by the scarcity of repair shops specialising in EV repairs, as well as the limited availability of specialised labour and replacement parts. As a result, insurance companies often charge higher premiums for EVs to account for the potentially higher repair costs.

The high cost of repairing or replacing EV batteries is due to several factors. Firstly, batteries are a significant component of EVs, contributing a substantial proportion of the vehicle's overall value. Secondly, there is a limited number of repair shops and technicians qualified to work on EV batteries, driving up labour costs. Additionally, the replacement parts market for EVs has not kept pace with the growing demand, leading to higher prices for replacement batteries.

The complexity of EV battery repairs also contributes to the cost. Electric batteries are dangerous to work on and often require specialised equipment and training to handle safely. In some cases, repairing a damaged battery pack may require a complete overhaul or replacement of the battery, rather than a simple fix, further adding to the expense.

Furthermore, EV batteries are more susceptible to damage from extreme temperatures, impact, or improper charging, which can result in reduced performance or premature failure. This can lead to additional repair or replacement costs, especially if the battery is not properly maintained or cared for by the vehicle owner.

While the cost of EV battery repairs can be significant, it is important to note that the technology is constantly evolving. Advances in battery technology and manufacturing processes have led to a significant decrease in battery pack costs over the years, and this trend is expected to continue. As EV technology matures and becomes more widespread, repair costs may decrease, and insurance rates may become more competitive with traditional gas-powered vehicles.

There are fewer repair shops with technicians trained to fix EVs

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive to insure than gas-powered cars, and this is due to a variety of reasons. One of the main reasons is that there are fewer repair shops with technicians trained to fix EVs. This scarcity of qualified repair shops increases the cost of repairs, which in turn affects insurance rates.

The limited number of technicians trained to fix EVs is a result of several factors. Firstly, there is a global shortage of technicians qualified to work on these vehicles. This shortage is exacerbated by the high costs of training and equipment required to service high-voltage EVs. Many garage owners are reluctant to invest in the necessary equipment and training due to the relatively low number of EVs on the road. The risk of electrocution and the danger of EV fires, which are challenging to extinguish, further deter garage owners from investing in EV repair capabilities.

Additionally, independent repair shops, which are typically far cheaper than franchise dealers, often lack access to proper training and resources from EV manufacturers. As a result, even when EVs require repairs, their owners may have to take them back to the dealership, potentially incurring higher repair costs.

To address this issue, some organizations are offering training programs for technicians. These programs aim to provide the necessary skills to diagnose and repair EVs. However, the uptake of these qualifications has been declining, possibly due to the time and investment required.

As EVs become more prevalent, it is expected that more repair shops will invest in the necessary training and equipment to service them. This increased availability of qualified repair shops may contribute to a decrease in insurance rates for EVs over time.

The make and model of an EV can affect its insurance rate

The make and model of an electric vehicle (EV) can significantly affect its insurance rate. EVs tend to be more expensive to insure than traditional gas-powered cars due to their higher purchase price and repair costs. However, the insurance rate varies depending on the brand of the EV.

EVs made by companies that also sell gas cars, such as Ford and Volkswagen, are generally cheaper to insure. For instance, the average cost to insure a Ford F-150 Lightning, an electric version of the popular F-150 truck, is $251 per month, which is $6 less than the monthly rate for its gas-powered counterpart. This is partly because Ford designed the F-150 Lightning to be similar to the standard F-150, reducing repair costs.

On the other hand, EVs from companies that exclusively produce electric cars, like Tesla and Rivian, tend to have much higher insurance rates. The cost to insure a Tesla Model 3 is 49% higher than the national average for full coverage. The Tesla Model X is the most expensive EV to insure, costing over twice as much as the Volkswagen ID.4, the cheapest EV to insure. This discrepancy is partly due to the higher cost of parts for Teslas and Rivians, as well as their limited availability.

Additionally, some insurance companies, such as Travelers and Lemonade, offer exclusive discounts to electric and hybrid car owners. Tesla also has its own insurance program, Tesla Insurance, which is often more affordable than other insurance companies for insuring a Tesla. However, outside of California, Tesla Insurance requires the use of the Tesla Safety Score system, which can lead to significant rate increases for unsafe driving behaviours.

Frequently asked questions