Insurance Payouts: Taxable Or Not?

Whether or not insurance payouts are considered taxable income depends on the type of insurance and the nature of the claim. Money received as part of an insurance claim or settlement is typically not taxed, as the purpose of insurance is to make you whole and return you to the state you were in before an incident occurred. However, there are certain exceptions where insurance payouts may be subject to income or estate taxes. For example, life insurance payouts may be taxed if the policy goes into an estate without named beneficiaries, or if the payout exceeds the federal estate tax threshold. Additionally, if you receive a payout for lost income or reimbursement for medical expenses that were previously claimed as deductions, it may be considered taxable income.

Property insurance claims are not taxed

Generally, property insurance claims are not taxed. This is because the money received from such claims is considered reimbursement for expenses rather than income. The purpose of insurance is to "make you whole", meaning that you should only receive enough payment to bring you back to the state you were in before an incident occurred. For example, if your home has been damaged, your insurance claim will only cover the cost of repairs or replacement, and you will not be taxed on this compensation because you are not gaining anything.

However, there are some situations in which property insurance claims may be taxed. If your property damage settlement includes compensation for emotional distress or punitive damages, these portions of the settlement may be subject to taxation. If you receive compensation that exceeds the cost of the damaged property, this may also be considered a taxable gain.

It is important to note that if you are a landlord or own rental properties, there may be different tax implications for property insurance claims. In these cases, it is recommended to consult a tax professional for guidance.

Medical claims are not taxed

Generally, insurance payouts are not considered taxable income. The IRS only levies taxes on income, which is money or payment that results in you having more wealth than you did before. Because the purpose of insurance is to "make you whole," you should only receive enough payment to bring you back to the state you were in before an incident occurred.

When you're making a health insurance claim, health insurance companies usually pay doctors directly, so you won't touch any money at all. But even if you pay out of pocket for a medical expense and are reimbursed later, you won't have to pay taxes on the amount you're paid.

You can save even more on your medical bills and taxes by using a flexible spending account (FSA) to pay the bill. FSAs are most commonly offered as a benefit through your job. With an FSA, you set aside a certain amount of pretax money per year to spend on medical expenses. You can use it to pay deductibles and coinsurance for doctor's visits, filling prescriptions and more. Money you put into an FSA generally expires at the end of each year, so you should only put in as much as you think you will spend in a given year.

Life insurance payouts are generally not taxable

However, there are some exceptions. If the payout is set up to be paid in multiple payments, these payments can be taxable. For example, an annuity paid regularly over the life of the beneficiary may be subject to taxes. The payments include proceeds and interest, and this interest is considered taxable income.

If the policyholder has withdrawn money or taken out a loan against their whole life policy's cash value, any money withdrawn over the cumulative premium payments may be subject to income taxes. Similarly, if you borrow against the cash value and the loan is still outstanding when the policy is terminated, the loan amount in excess of the cumulative premiums may be subject to income taxes.

If you surrender your whole life insurance policy, you can exchange it for a cash payment from the insurance company. If the surrender proceeds exceed the cumulative premiums, the excess may be subject to income taxes. However, if the surrender value is less than the cumulative premiums paid, you likely won't pay income taxes on the cash payment.

If the life insurance policy has no named beneficiaries, the proceeds may be included in the deceased's estate. If the value of the estate exceeds the federal estate tax threshold, which was $13.61 million as of 2020, estate taxes must be paid on the amount over the limit. Some states also assess inheritance or estate taxes, depending on the estate's value and where the deceased lived.

Insurance payouts after damage to property are generally not taxable

For example, if your house was destroyed in a fire, your insurance settlement would pay for a new kitchen, plus repairs, plastering, and decorating to put the kitchen back to how it was before. This is known as the principle of indemnification.

However, there are some exceptions to this rule. If your property damage settlement includes compensation for emotional distress or punitive damages, these portions of the settlement may be subject to taxation. If you profit from the payout, you may also be taxed. This could be the case if the settlement exceeds the original cost of the damaged property, which could happen if your home has increased in value since you bought it.

Insurance claim income for an auto-accident injury is probably not taxable

If you receive insurance claim income for an auto-accident injury, it is probably not taxable. This is because the IRS only levies taxes on income, which is money or payment that results in you having more wealth than you did before.

The purpose of insurance is to "make you whole", meaning that you should only receive enough payment to bring you back to the state you were in before the accident. For example, if you receive a payout to fix your car, this money is not taxable because it is only being used to repair your car to its previous state.

However, there are some instances where insurance claim income for an auto-accident injury may be taxable. This includes when the payment is for:

• Lost income
• Future lost income
• Pain and suffering
• Emotional distress

It is important to note that tax laws vary by state, so it is recommended to consult a tax professional or seek guidance from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to determine the taxability of your specific situation.

Frequently asked questions