Double Insuring Vehicles: Legal Or Not?

While it is not illegal to have two car insurance policies on the same vehicle, it is generally discouraged by insurance companies. Double-insuring a car may violate the policies of one or both of your insurers, and if one of your insurers finds out about the other policy, they may ask the other insurer to pay your claims in the future. This can result in delayed or unpaid claims. Additionally, if you file the same claim with two different insurance companies, it is considered insurance fraud, which is illegal.

Double insurance is legal, but it's not recommended

While it is not illegal to double insure a vehicle, it is generally not recommended. There are several reasons for this.

Firstly, double insurance will cost you more money. You will have to pay two separate premiums, which will be very expensive, with no added benefit. This is because, in the event of an accident, only one provider will pay out. The primary insurance policy will pay out first, and the other company, known as the excess policy, will only make payments after the primary policy has used up all of its limits.

Secondly, having two insurance policies can make the claims process more complicated and lengthy. In the event of an accident, the two insurance companies will need to agree on who will cover what part of the claim, which can dramatically extend the time it takes for you to receive a settlement. There is also a risk that neither company will pay out, leaving you without insurance.

Thirdly, filing the same claim with two insurance companies is considered insurance fraud, which is illegal and could result in serious legal consequences. Even if you do not intentionally file the same claim with both providers, this could be seen as an attempt at fraud if not properly coordinated.

Finally, if you add another driver to your policy, your premium may increase. However, if you live with your partner, it is usually recommended that you share one policy, as this will make you eligible for a multi-vehicle discount.

Filing the same claim with two insurers is insurance fraud.

While it is not illegal to have two insurance policies on the same vehicle, filing the same claim with two different insurers is insurance fraud. This is known as unjust enrichment.

If you have two insurance policies and you file a claim, you can only file it with one of the insurance companies. If your claim exceeds the sum assured by the first insurer, you can then claim the remaining amount from the second insurer. However, you cannot receive the full amount from both insurers.

For example, if your claim is for $15,000 and your first insurer only covers up to $10,000, you can then claim the remaining $5,000 from your second insurer. But you cannot receive $15,000 from each insurer as this would be considered fraud.

In the case of health insurance, it is permitted to file claims with two different insurance companies for the same medical emergency or treatment. However, you must keep both insurance companies informed about your existing policies.

Double insurance is costly and doesn't provide extra benefits

While it is not illegal to have two insurance policies on the same vehicle, double insurance is costly and doesn't provide extra benefits.

Firstly, double insurance is expensive. You will have to pay two separate premiums, which is very costly, for no added benefit. Secondly, a claim can become complicated as both insurance companies will need to agree on who will cover what part of the claim, which can dramatically extend the time it takes to receive a settlement. Thirdly, your premium costs from both insurers will likely rise after a claim. Fourthly, you could lose your good driver discount on both policies if applicable. Fifthly, each insurance policy may require you to add every driver in your home to your coverage, as well as every automobile parked at your household, which can significantly increase your insurance costs.

Instead of purchasing two insurance policies, you can expand your coverage by exceeding your state's requirements for liability insurance and adding optional types of coverage like comprehensive, collision, rental car, and roadside assistance. You can also add extra coverage to a single policy instead of paying for a second one.

It can cause confusion and delays in the claims process

Double insuring a vehicle can cause confusion and delays in the claims process. If a vehicle is double-insured and an accident occurs, both insurance companies will need to be involved in the claims process. This can cause delays as the two insurance companies will need to decide which of them is responsible for paying out and how much. This can also cause confusion as the policyholder might not know which insurer to contact.

In the event of an accident, the policyholder will need to file a claim with their insurance company. However, if the policyholder has two insurance policies on the same vehicle, it may not be clear which insurer to contact. This can cause confusion and delays in the claims process.

Additionally, if the policyholder has two insurance policies on the same vehicle and files a claim with both insurers, it may be considered insurance fraud. Insurance fraud is a serious offence and can result in legal consequences.

Furthermore, having two insurance policies on the same vehicle can result in higher premium costs. The policyholder will need to pay two separate premiums, which can be expensive and may not provide any additional benefits.

Overall, while it is not illegal to have two insurance policies on the same vehicle, it can cause confusion and delays in the claims process, higher premium costs, and potentially insurance fraud. It is important for policyholders to carefully review their insurance policies and understand their coverage to avoid any issues in the event of a claim.

It may violate the policies of one or both insurers

While it is not illegal to have two car insurance policies on the same vehicle, double-insuring your car may violate the policies of one or both of your insurers. This is because insurers generally discourage the practice of double auto insurance coverage.

If you have two insurance policies on the same vehicle, one of your insurers may ask the other insurer to pay your claims in the future. This can result in delayed or unpaid claims. Additionally, if both insurers find out about your dual policies, they may terminate your coverage, leaving you without insurance.

Having two insurance policies on the same vehicle can also cause confusion if you need to file a claim. It may be challenging to determine which insurance company should pay for damages in the event of an accident. This confusion could lead to an unpaid claim.

Furthermore, double-insuring your vehicle will cost you more money as you will have to pay two separate premiums, both of which will increase if you file a claim.

Therefore, while it is not illegal to have two car insurance policies, it may violate the policies of your insurers and can lead to complications and increased costs.

Frequently asked questions