Stranger-Originated Life Insurance: Legal Or Not?

Stranger-originated life insurance (STOLI) is an illegal practice where a life insurance policy is purchased by someone who has no existing relationship with the insured person and therefore no insurable interest in their life. This means that the purchaser has no financial interest in the ongoing health and well-being of the insured and would not suffer any loss from their death. STOLI policies are generally bought by investors as a speculative investment, with the intention of profiting from the death of the insured. This practice is considered unethical and illegal in many countries, including the United States and Canada, due to the absence of insurable interest and the potential for fraud and illegal wagering.

Stranger-originated life insurance (STOLI) is illegal in the US

STOLI refers to the sale of a life insurance policy to a third party. The owner of the policy sells it for an immediate cash benefit. The buyer then becomes the new owner of the policy, paying future premiums and collecting the death benefit when the insured dies.

STOLI is illegal because it does not feature insurable interest between the policy's owner(s) and the insured. Insurable interest is a legal requirement, meaning the policyholder must benefit financially from the insured's ongoing health and wellbeing. In other words, the policyholder must be someone who would suffer financially or otherwise from the insured's death. This is usually a family member, a spouse, a parent, or a business owner with key employees.

STOLI arrangements are typically promoted to consumers aged between 65 and 85. They are often sold by people with a life-threatening illness, but they can also be sold by those who are healthy. In many cases, the purchase of the policy is for the sole purpose of selling it to a third party, either immediately or in the future.

STOLI is considered unethical as it allows gambling or wagering on the lives of others. It also creates a situation where the policy owner has more interest in the insured dying as soon as possible, rather than living a long life.

STOLI arrangements can also be fraudulent. For example, a senior citizen may use falsely exaggerated financial numbers to purchase a large life insurance policy. A third-party investor then agrees to cover the premiums, and the policy is sold to the investor for a cash payment. The insured gets "free" money, and the investor receives a policy that pays a tax-free benefit when the insured dies.

STOLI is illegal in the US, with many states enacting laws specifically outlawing the practice. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) proposed sample legislation in 2007 for states to adopt to ban these policies. To date, most states have adopted STOLI-related laws.

It is important to note that life settlements, where a valid life insurance policy is legally transferred from its owner to a third-party investor, are different from STOLI and are legal in the US.

STOLI is also illegal in many Canadian provinces

Stranger-originated life insurance (STOLI) is illegal in many Canadian provinces. The anti-trafficking provision was never enacted in Saskatchewan, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia, while Quebec repealed it in 1974.

STOLI refers to the sale of a life insurance policy to a third party. The owner of the life insurance policy sells the policy for an immediate cash benefit. The buyer becomes the new owner of the life insurance policy, pays future premiums, and collects the death benefit when the insured dies.

STOLI is typically promoted to consumers between the ages of 65 and 85 who are not facing a health crisis. In many cases, the purchase of the policy is for the sole purpose of selling the policy to a third party, immediately or in the future.

In the United States, life insurance is regulated by the states. State laws require a policy owner to have an insurable interest in the life of the insured. A STOLI arrangement circumvents this insurable interest requirement, making it illegal. STOLI arrangements may also be considered insurance fraud, carrying civil and criminal penalties for those involved.

The trafficking of life insurance products, or STOLI, is illegal in many Canadian provinces due to the absence of an insurable interest requirement, similar to US state laws. At least one large Canadian insurer warns agents not to sell policies if the policyholder intends to sell or immediately assign the policy to an unrelated third party with a non-insurable interest.

STOLI is considered unethical as it allows gambling on the lives of others

Stranger-originated life insurance (STOLI) is a type of life insurance that is considered unethical and illegal in many jurisdictions. STOLI involves a stranger or a third-party investor purchasing a life insurance policy on an individual without their knowledge or consent, with the intention of profiting from their death. This type of arrangement is seen as a form of gambling on the lives of others, which is morally questionable.

The main issue with STOLI is that it creates an incentive for the policy owner to want the insured person to die sooner rather than later. This is because the policy owner has no insurable interest in the life of the insured person, meaning they would not suffer a financial loss or hardship from their death. In contrast, traditional life insurance policies are purchased by individuals who have an insurable interest in the insured, such as family members or business partners. These individuals typically have a personal relationship with the insured and would suffer a genuine loss from their death.

In the case of STOLI, the policy owner is often a third-party investor who has no relationship with the insured. The investor pays the premiums on the policy and receives the death benefit when the insured person passes away. This arrangement is purely speculative and can be very lucrative for the investor, especially if the insured person has a short life expectancy. However, it also creates a situation where the investor stands to gain financially from the insured person's death, which is inherently unethical.

Furthermore, STOLI policies have been criticised for preying on vulnerable individuals, particularly the elderly. In some cases, elderly individuals have been targeted by insurance agents and investors who convince them to take out large life insurance policies under false pretences. For example, in a 2011 case in New York, insurance agents recruited elderly clients and submitted life insurance applications with inflated net worth information. The agents then paid the premiums on the policies using the commissions they earned, or by finding third-party investors. The elderly clients were either paid monthly for their cooperation or promised a share of the profits when the policies were sold. This type of scheme not only exploits vulnerable people but also constitutes insurance fraud, carrying both civil and criminal penalties.

Overall, STOLI is considered unethical because it allows strangers to gamble on the lives of others. By purchasing life insurance policies on individuals they have no relationship with, investors create a situation where they stand to benefit financially from the insured person's death. This goes against the fundamental purpose of life insurance, which is to provide financial support for the loved ones of the deceased. As such, STOLI policies are illegal in many places and are widely considered to be a predatory and exploitative practice.

STOLI policies are often sold by people with life-threatening illnesses

Stranger-Originated Life Insurance (STOLI) is a controversial practice in the insurance industry. It involves investors purchasing life insurance policies on the lives of strangers, with the aim of benefiting from the eventual death payout. While STOLI can offer immediate financial gains for the insured, it has also been criticised for its ethical and legal implications.

In the past, most STOLI policies were sold by people facing serious health issues. Today, however, it is often promoted to individuals between the ages of 65 and 85 who are not facing a health crisis. In many cases, the sole purpose of purchasing the policy is to sell it to a third party, either immediately or in the future. This allows the insured to access cash while they are still alive.

STOLI arrangements have been criticised for creating an unethical situation where the policyholder has a financial interest in the insured dying as soon as possible. Additionally, these policies are often marketed to vulnerable individuals under false pretences, such as "zero premium life insurance" or "no cost to the insured plans".

Due to the ethical and legal concerns surrounding STOLI, it is now largely illegal in the United States and many other countries.

Seniors are a common target of STOLI scams

Stranger-Originated Life Insurance (STOLI) is a type of insurance fraud that targets seniors. STOLI is a complex concept that involves an investor or representative inducing an individual, typically a senior citizen, to purchase a life insurance policy that they would not normally buy. Seniors are targeted for this arrangement as they are encouraged to sign up for new life insurance policies that they will then sell for a buyout. The main characteristic of a STOLI transaction is that the insurance is purchased solely as an investment vehicle, rather than for the benefit of the policy owner's beneficiaries.

In a STOLI transaction, the senior citizen is presented with the idea of ""free life insurance" by the STOLI broker. The senior is told that they will not have to pay any premiums and will get a life insurance policy for a limited period, usually 2-3 years. However, what they are not told is that during this period, they will be unable to get another life insurance policy. If their health deteriorates during this time, they will be left without any insurance coverage.

The STOLI arrangement is designed to benefit the investor or third-party purchaser, not the senior citizen. The senior applies for the policy with the understanding that after a certain period, they will either have to pay the premiums themselves or give up the policy to the investor. The investor arranges financing for the premiums during the time the senior owns the policy, and this financing is often non-recourse, with the insurance policy itself serving as the only collateral. Once the policy is transferred, the owner continues to pay the premium until the insured dies. When the insured dies, the investor receives the death benefit.

STOLI transactions are illegal and unethical because they circumvent the insurable interest requirement, allowing investors to profit from the death of strangers. State laws in the United States generally require an owner of a policy to have an insurable interest in the life of the insured, such as a family member or business partner. STOLI arrangements, on the other hand, are based on the idea of speculating on the lives of others, which is considered gambling and is prohibited.

To fight back against STOLI scams, seniors can take several steps. Firstly, they can sell the policy themselves and benefit from its current market value instead of letting the STOLI businesses profit. Secondly, they can report the scam to the attorney general in their state. Finally, they may consider a lawsuit against the STOLI businesses, including the insurance agent, on the grounds of fraud. It is important for seniors to be vigilant and seek advice from reputable sources to protect themselves from becoming victims of STOLI scams.

Frequently asked questions