Whole Life Insurance Cash Value: Bankruptcy Exempt?

Whole life insurance policies are a type of permanent life insurance that pays out either at the time of the policyholder's death or when the policy matures, for example, at 100 years of age. These policies have a cash value or surrender value, which acts like a savings account that can be withdrawn or borrowed against. In the context of bankruptcy, the cash value of a whole life insurance policy is considered an asset that can be protected up to a certain amount by bankruptcy exemptions. The extent of protection depends on the state's exemption laws and whether the debtor chooses state or federal exemptions. While whole life insurance policies can provide financial safeguards, it is essential to understand the specific conditions and exclusions of bankruptcy exemptions to ensure effective asset protection.

Term life insurance policies have no cash value and are not exempt

Term life insurance policies are fundamentally different from whole life insurance policies. Term life insurance is a temporary contract between the policyholder and the insurance company, lasting for a specific time period, such as 10, 20, or 30 years. During this period, as long as the policyholder continues to make premium payments, the insurance company guarantees a death benefit payout if the policyholder passes away. Once the policy expires, it can be renewed, converted to permanent life insurance, or replaced with a new policy.

Term life insurance policies do not accumulate a cash value. This means that policyholders cannot borrow against the policy or terminate it to collect a cash surrender value. Since there is no cash value, term life insurance is significantly more affordable than whole life insurance. It typically has one of the lowest premium costs compared to other types of life insurance policies.

Because term life insurance policies have no cash value, they are not considered assets in bankruptcy proceedings. In bankruptcy, an individual's assets are controlled by a court-appointed trustee, who liquidates these assets to pay off the individual's debts. However, certain assets are exempt from liquidation, and the treatment of life insurance in bankruptcy depends on the type of policy and the specific state laws. While whole life insurance policies often have exemptions for the cash value, term life insurance policies, with no cash value, are not subject to the same considerations.

Therefore, while it is important to disclose all assets, including term life insurance policies, when filing for bankruptcy, there is no risk of losing any cash value associated with term life insurance. The death benefit payout remains intact, ensuring that the policyholder's loved ones will be financially protected in the event of their death.

Whole life insurance policies have a cash value that can be seized

When an individual files for bankruptcy, the court appoints a trustee to take control of their assets. The trustee then liquidates these assets to pay off the individual's creditors. However, there are certain assets that are protected by exemption laws, which vary by state and by type of bankruptcy. These exemption laws determine whether an asset is categorised as "exempt" or "non-exempt". Exempt assets are protected from creditors, while non-exempt assets may be pursued by creditors to satisfy debt obligations.

The cash value of a whole life insurance policy is protected by bankruptcy exemptions, but only up to a certain amount. This amount varies depending on the state and the type of bankruptcy. For example, under federal exemptions, an individual can exempt up to $12,625 of the cash value of their whole life insurance policy. If the cash value exceeds the exemption amount, the trustee can liquidate the account, pay the individual the exempt portion, and distribute the remaining amount to their creditors.

It is important to note that the failure to disclose the cash value of a whole life insurance policy during bankruptcy proceedings could result in the entire policy being taken and distributed by the trustee. Additionally, the cash value of a whole life insurance policy may be used to help pay off debts as part of the bankruptcy process. If this happens and the individual is unable to make future premium payments, the policy will lapse.

State-specific exemptions exist, such as in Pennsylvania and New Jersey

The federal exemptions, as seen above, allow a debtor to exempt up to $12,625 of the cash value of a whole life insurance policy. The chapter of bankruptcy will determine what a trustee will do if there is any non-exempt equity in a whole life insurance policy.

In most states, the exemptions applicable to bankruptcy are the same as creditor exemptions, though a few use a different standard in bankruptcy cases. A majority of states only allow bankruptcy debtors to use state exemptions, though twenty states – including New York, Pennsylvania, and Texas – allow debtors to choose either state or federal exemptions (but not both).

Federal exemptions allow for up to $12,625-$14,875 exemption

Federal exemptions allow for up to $12,625–$14,875 exemption of the cash value of a whole life insurance policy. This means that if the cash value of your policy is less than the upper limit of this range, you can keep the entire amount. If your policy's cash value is higher than $14,875, you may be able to combine this exemption with the federal wildcard exemption, which protects up to an additional $13,100.

The exemption limit varies depending on the source. According to Young Marr Law, the federal exemption limit is $12,625. However, Haven Life states that there is a federal exemption of $14,875. It is important to note that some states provide additional exemptions, and a bankruptcy lawyer should be aware of these.

The federal exemptions apply to the loan value of your policy. This refers to the amount of money that builds up in a permanent life insurance policy, such as a whole life policy, which acts like a savings account. This cash value can be accessed by terminating the policy and withdrawing the cash value, or by borrowing against it without terminating the policy.

The cash value of a life insurance policy is considered an asset in bankruptcy. If the cash value exceeds the amount covered by your bankruptcy exemptions, the trustee can liquidate the account, pay you the exempt portion, and distribute the remaining amount to your creditors. Therefore, it is important to discuss with a bankruptcy lawyer the effect that a bankruptcy filing will have on your life insurance policy with cash value.

In addition to federal exemptions, some states have their own exemption laws that specifically protect life insurance proceeds. For example, in Ohio, life insurance proceeds from a group policy are exempt, but proceeds from a private policy are not. If your state doesn't have a designated life insurance exemption, you may still be able to protect the proceeds under your state's personal property or wildcard exemptions.

It is important to note that exemptions can vary significantly from state to state, and you must choose between using state or federal exemptions. You are not allowed to mix and match exemptions. Currently, there are 31 "opt-out" states that do not allow you to choose which exemptions to use. If you have lived in an opt-out state for at least two years, you must use that state's exemption laws. If you have lived in an opt-out state for less than two years, you can use the federal exemptions.

Whole life insurance policies may be seized if you can't pay premiums

If you have a whole life insurance policy, it likely has a cash value that can be used to repay creditors in the event of bankruptcy. This cash value is considered an asset and is protected up to a certain amount by bankruptcy exemptions. However, if the cash value exceeds the amount covered by your bankruptcy exemptions, the trustee can liquidate the account and distribute the remaining amount to your creditors.

In the United States, federal exemptions allow debtors to exempt up to a certain amount of the cash value of a whole life insurance policy. As of July 25, 2023, this amount was $13,400. If the cash value is higher, it may be possible to combine this exemption with the federal wildcard exemption. It's important to note that exemption laws vary between states, and some states offer complete exemptions for life insurance, while others cap the exemption amount.

If you are unable to pay the premiums on your whole life insurance policy, it is possible that the accumulated cash value can cover your premiums for a period of time. However, if the cash value is insufficient or if you are unable to make future payments, your policy will lapse, and your beneficiaries will not receive a death benefit in the event of your death.

To protect your whole life insurance policy and its cash value in the event of bankruptcy, it is essential to understand the applicable exemption laws in your state and make informed decisions regarding asset protection. Consulting with a seasoned bankruptcy attorney can help you navigate the complexities of bankruptcy and ensure your interests are protected.

Frequently asked questions