Life Insurance Disintermediation: Risks And Cfa Implications

Disintermediation is a term used to describe the process of removing middlemen from transactions, supply chains, or decision-making processes. In the context of life insurance and the CFA exam, disintermediation risk refers to the possibility that policyholders may surrender their cash-value life insurance policies due to rising interest rates. This could happen if policyholders choose to reinvest their proceeds at a higher interest rate, resulting in a significant impact on the insurance company's equity value. The process of disintermediation in the financial industry allows investors to purchase stocks or other financial products directly, without going through a broker or financial institution, which can reduce costs and increase delivery speed.

Policyholders may cancel policies due to rising interest rates

Disintermediation risk is a term used to describe the potential for policyholders to cancel their policies due to rising interest rates. This risk is particularly relevant in the context of life insurance, as policyholders may be more inclined to surrender their policies when interest rates rise rapidly.

Life insurance policies are long-term commitments that policyholders typically maintain for decades. However, when interest rates rise, policyholders may be incentivised to cancel their existing policies and seek alternative investment options that offer higher returns. This decision-making process is driven by the opportunity cost of holding a life insurance policy versus investing in other financial instruments.

The impact of rising interest rates on policyholder behaviour can be significant. If interest rates climb too rapidly, policyholders may surrender their policies faster than expected. This can create a challenging situation for insurance providers, as they may face cash flow obligations that exceed the returns on their investment assets. The surge in policy cancellations can result in a cash outflow that surpasses the income generated from their investments, leading to a strain on their liquidity.

Consequently, insurance companies must carefully manage their investment portfolios and cash reserves to mitigate the potential impact of disintermediation risk. They need to ensure that they have sufficient liquidity to meet the cash flow obligations arising from policy surrenders while also maintaining profitable operations.

It's important to note that disintermediation risk is not limited to life insurance but can also affect other types of insurance policies, such as commercial insurance. Rising interest rates can affect commercial policyholders' revenues, impacting their ability to pay for their insurance policies. In such cases, businesses may opt to reduce their coverage or even cancel their policies, further exacerbating the challenges faced by insurance providers.

Insurers may struggle to service liabilities due to low interest rates

Interest rates have been in secular decline since the 1980s, but from the time of the 2008 financial crisis until very recently, interest rates were at historic lows. Prolonged periods of low interest rates negatively affect the financial performance of life insurance firms.

Life insurers maintain large balance sheets, with a substantial share of their assets (over 60% in aggregate) being interest-earning bonds. When interest rates are low, investment earnings on bonds decline. In an attempt to increase investment earnings, some life insurers shifted funds out of investment-grade bonds and into inherently riskier but generally higher-earning assets, such as asset-backed securities, collateralized loan obligations, derivatives, and real estate.

The earnings on some life insurance products, such as annuities and cash value life insurance policies, depend on the spread between what life insurers earn in interest and what they credit in interest to the customer. Many of these products have a guaranteed rate of return for the consumer, meaning the interest credited to the consumer by the life insurer is fixed. When market interest rates are low, the spread is compressed, and therefore so are earnings.

As interest rates rise, insurers will be in a better position to offer insured products with more substantive interest rate guarantees. However, if interest rates remain low, insurers may struggle to service liabilities.

During persistent periods of low interest rates, when policy surrender rates tend to decrease, insurers face the risk that investment returns will decline to the point that they are unable to service ongoing liabilities. This is an example of disintermediation risk, which refers to the potential that policyholders may relinquish policies due to rising interest rates. In this scenario, the sensitivity of investment income and policy obligations to interest rate changes could have a considerable impact on equity value.

The impact of disintermediation on equity value

Disintermediation is the process of cutting out the financial intermediary in a transaction, such as a broker or a financial institution. In the context of life insurance, disintermediation risk refers to the possibility that policyholders may give up their policies due to rising interest rates. This can have a significant impact on equity value in two ways:

Firstly, if interest rates rise too quickly, policyholders may surrender their policies faster than expected. This could result in cash flow obligations exceeding returns on investment assets, impacting the insurer's ability to service ongoing liabilities. Secondly, during prolonged periods of low-interest rates, policy surrender rates tend to decrease. However, insurers face the risk of declining investment returns to the point that they are unable to meet their ongoing liabilities. In both scenarios, the sensitivity of investment income and policy obligations to interest rate changes can significantly affect equity value.

Disintermediation can also occur in other industries, such as when a consumer buys directly from a wholesaler instead of through a retailer. The primary reasons for disintermediation are usually cost reduction and faster delivery. However, it's important to note that disintermediation increases the burden on the company as they need to duplicate the roles previously handled by intermediaries, including shipping and distribution.

In the financial industry, disintermediation has been facilitated by the internet, allowing consumers and businesses to transact directly with producers and wholesalers. However, new intermediaries like Amazon, Etsy, and eBay have emerged as electronic middlemen.

The role of disintermediation in lowering costs

Disintermediation is a process that cuts out the middleman in a transaction, which is usually a financial intermediary such as a broker, bank, or other third party. In the context of life insurance, disintermediation risk refers to the possibility that policyholders may give up their policies due to rising interest rates. This can happen when policyholders choose to surrender their cash-value life insurance policies and reinvest the proceeds at a higher interest rate outside of the policy.

However, it is important to note that disintermediation is not always a successful strategy. The removal of intermediaries may require additional resources to duplicate the services they previously provided, such as shipping and handling. These additional costs may offset some of the savings gained through disintermediation.

In the case of life insurance, disintermediation can lead to increased costs for insurance companies. If policyholders surrender their policies en masse, the insurance company may be forced to sell fixed-income securities at a loss to meet the increased demand for cash payouts. This can negatively impact the company's liquidity and financial position.

Overall, disintermediation has the potential to lower costs for consumers by removing intermediaries and their associated markups. However, it is important to carefully consider the potential drawbacks and increased burdens on the company employing the strategy. In the case of life insurance, disintermediation can be a double-edged sword, as it may provide short-term gains for policyholders while potentially destabilizing the financial position of the insurance company.

The use of disintermediation to speed up transactions

Disintermediation is the process of removing intermediaries from a transaction, and it is particularly common in the financial industry. The primary objective of disintermediation is to allow consumers or businesses to interact directly with manufacturers, wholesalers, or service providers, cutting out the middleman. This can lead to significant benefits, including cost savings and quicker transactions.

The process of disintermediation can speed up transactions by making them more direct. By removing the middleman, there are fewer parties involved in the transaction, reducing the time needed to reach an agreement or complete the transaction. This increased speed can be beneficial for both the buyer and the seller. For example, in the financial industry, disintermediation can involve buying stock directly rather than via a broker or financial institution. This direct approach streamlines the investment process and can lead to faster execution of trades.

Additionally, disintermediation can speed up transactions by reducing the complexity and number of steps involved. With fewer parties involved, there are fewer negotiations, approvals, or bureaucratic processes required. This simplification of the transaction process can lead to faster decision-making and execution.

In the context of life insurance, disintermediation could involve policyholders purchasing insurance directly from the insurance company instead of going through an agent or broker. This direct approach can speed up the process of obtaining life insurance by eliminating the time needed to consult and coordinate with an intermediary. Policyholders can access information, compare policies, and make decisions more quickly when dealing directly with the insurance provider.

However, it is important to note that disintermediation may not always result in faster transactions. In some cases, intermediaries provide valuable services that facilitate efficient transactions. For example, they may have established systems, networks, and expertise that streamline the process. As such, when considering disintermediation, it is essential to evaluate the potential impact on transaction speed and ensure that any necessary tasks can be effectively managed without intermediaries.

Overall, disintermediation has the potential to speed up transactions by reducing the number of parties involved and streamlining the process. It empowers consumers and businesses to engage more directly with suppliers, manufacturers, and service providers. However, it is important to carefully consider the potential challenges and ensure that the necessary resources are in place to maintain efficiency.

Frequently asked questions