Life Insurance Disintermediation Risk: A Cfa's Guide

Disintermediation risk is the risk that policyholders will surrender their life insurance policies due to rising interest rates. If interest rates rise too rapidly, policyholders may give up their policies faster than expected, which could result in cash flow obligations that exceed returns on investment assets. Insurers also face the risk that, during persistent periods of low interest rates, investment returns will decline to the point that they are unable to service ongoing liabilities. Insurance companies have introduced VUL, UL and variable annuities to combat disintermediation.

Disintermediation risk refers to the potential that policyholders may relinquish policies due to rising interest rates

Insurers face a different type of disintermediation risk during persistent periods of low interest rates. During these times, policy surrender rates tend to decrease, but insurers face the risk that investment returns will decline to the point that they are unable to service ongoing liabilities.

To combat disintermediation, insurance companies now offer VUL, UL and variable annuities.

Policyholders may surrender policies faster than expected, potentially resulting in cash flow obligations that exceed returns on investment assets

Disintermediation risk refers to the potential that policyholders may surrender their policies due to rising interest rates. If interest rates rise too rapidly, policyholders may be incentivised to cash out their policies and invest the proceeds in higher-yielding securities. This could result in cash flow obligations that exceed returns on investment assets.

In other words, if interest rates rise, policyholders may be tempted to cancel their policies and invest their money elsewhere, where they can benefit from higher interest rates. This could leave insurance companies with cash flow obligations that exceed their investment returns.

Insurance companies have developed products such as VUL, UL and variable annuities to combat disintermediation. These products may offer higher returns than traditional whole life insurance policies, making them more attractive to policyholders even when interest rates are high.

Disintermediation risk is particularly relevant in a rising interest rate environment. When interest rates are high, policyholders may be more likely to surrender their policies for their accumulated cash values, as they can reinvest the proceeds at a higher interest rate. This could result in a surge of policy surrenders, leading to significant cash flow obligations for insurance companies.

Insurers face the risk that investment returns will decline to the point that they are unable to service ongoing liabilities

Disintermediation risk refers to the potential that policyholders may relinquish policies due to rising interest rates. If interest rates rise too rapidly, policyholders may surrender policies faster than expected, resulting in cash flow obligations that exceed returns on investment assets. Insurers face the risk that investment returns will decline to the point that they are unable to service ongoing liabilities.

In a rising interest rate environment, policyholders may take the cash value of their policy and invest in higher-yielding securities. This is because when interest rates are high, the rate received at whole life is not as competitive as other investment opportunities. As a result, people may cancel their policies and invest their money elsewhere. This creates a risk for insurers, as they may be unable to meet their cash flow obligations.

To combat disintermediation, insurance companies have introduced variable products such as VUL, UL, and variable annuities. These products offer the potential for higher returns, which can help to retain policyholders. However, these products also come with additional risks, as the returns are not guaranteed.

In summary, disintermediation risk is a concern for insurers as it can lead to a decline in investment returns and an inability to service ongoing liabilities. To mitigate this risk, insurers have introduced variable products, but these come with their own set of challenges and risks.

Insurers face another type of disintermediation when interest rates are high

When interest rates are high, insurers face the risk of disintermediation, which is when policyholders may surrender their cash-value life insurance policies for their accumulated cash value. This is because they can then reinvest the proceeds at a higher interest rate. This can cause cash flow obligations that exceed returns on investment assets.

Insurers have developed products such as VUL, UL, and variable annuities to combat this risk. These products offer policyholders the potential for higher returns, even when interest rates are high.

Disintermediation risk is a concern for insurers as it can lead to a rapid increase in policy surrenders, which can be challenging to manage from a cash flow perspective. It can also impact the insurer's ability to service ongoing liabilities, as the cash flow from policy premiums may no longer be sufficient to cover these costs.

Additionally, when interest rates are high, policyholders may be more inclined to cancel their policies and invest their money elsewhere, seeking higher returns. This can further exacerbate the disintermediation risk faced by insurers.

Policyholders may surrender their cash value life insurance policies for their accumulated cash values, in order to reinvest the proceeds at a higher interest rate

Disintermediation risk refers to the potential that policyholders may surrender their cash value life insurance policies for their accumulated cash values, in order to reinvest the proceeds at a higher interest rate. This is because when interest rates rise, policyholders may be incentivised to cancel their policies and invest their money elsewhere. This can cause cash flow obligations that exceed returns on investment assets.

Insurance companies have introduced VUL, UL and variable annuities to combat disintermediation. However, if interest rates rise too rapidly, policyholders may surrender policies faster than expected, which can still result in cash flow obligations that exceed returns on investment assets.

On the other hand, during persistent periods of low interest rates when policy surrender rates tend to decrease, insurers face the risk that investment returns will decline to the point that they are unable to service ongoing liabilities. Therefore, disintermediation risk is a concern for insurers regardless of whether interest rates are high or low.

Frequently asked questions