Understanding Life Insurance: Surrender Charges Explained

A surrender charge is a fee that you pay to terminate an insurance or annuity product early. This fee is higher if you withdraw funds within the first few years of an annuity contract, but it drops gradually each year. Surrender charges are intended to give the insurer enough time to recover its expenses, largely commissions, in setting up the annuity contract. They also serve to discourage annuity buyers from using deferred annuities as short-term investments for quick cash. Surrender charges typically apply for six to eight years after purchasing an annuity, but with insurance policies, the timing is much more variable.

Surrender charge vs surrender fee

Surrender charges and surrender fees are the same thing. They are fees levied on a life insurance policyholder upon cancellation of their life insurance policy. These fees are used to cover the costs of keeping the policy on the provider's books.

Surrender charges can apply for time periods as little as 30 days or as much as 15 years on some annuity and insurance products. For annuities and life insurance, the surrender fee often starts at 10% if you cash in your investment in the first year. It then decreases by 1% each year until it reaches 0% in the tenth year and beyond.

The purpose of the fee is to allow the insurer enough time to recover its expenses, largely commissions, in setting up the annuity contract. It also serves to discourage annuity buyers from using deferred annuities as short-term investments for quick cash.

Most investments that carry a surrender charge pay an upfront commission to the salespeople who sell them. The issuing company then recoups the commission through internal fees charged in the investment. However, if an investment is sold before enough years have passed, the internal fees will not be enough to cover the commission costs, resulting in the issuing company losing money. Surrender charges protect against these types of losses.

While surrender charges and surrender fees are the same, there is a difference between cash value and cash surrender value. Cash value is the current balance of your life insurance policy's cash value account based on the amount of premium you've paid. Cash surrender value is the amount of money you receive from the policy if you decide to surrender it. Generally, the cash surrender value equals the cash value balance minus any surrender fees on the policy.

Surrender value

Surrender fees are penalties charged for withdrawing funds from an annuity or insurance policy early. They are typically applied to investments intended for long-term use and help the issuer offset the cost of selling and managing the investment. Surrender fees can be avoided by waiting out the surrender charge period, which can last for many years or even a decade in some cases. The length of the surrender charge period depends on the type of investment and the terms of the policy. During this period, the surrender fee will decrease over time.

In most cases, to access the surrender value, the policy must be cancelled. Surrender fees are no longer in effect after 10 to 15 years for a universal life insurance policy.

Cash value

When you pay your premiums, your insurance provider allocates some of the money towards the cost of insurance and some towards your cash value account. The cash value money is then invested, for example, in a bond portfolio. Your policy is credited based on the performance of those investments, as well as any dividends the policy earns.

The cash value is not the same as the policy's face value, which is the death benefit. However, outstanding loans against the policy's cash value can reduce the total death benefit.

In the US, it is technically illegal for a life insurance policy to market itself as an investment vehicle. However, many policyholders use their whole life, universal life, or variable universal life insurance policies to grow tax-advantaged retirement assets. They do this by using their cash value funds for so-called living benefits, such as low-interest loans against the cash value in the policy or partial withdrawals. As you make withdrawals or fail to repay loans, the death benefit also reduces. If you withdraw all of the cash value, you surrender it and the policy is cancelled.

In most whole life insurance plans, the cash value is guaranteed, but it can only be surrendered when the policy is cancelled. Policyholders may borrow or withdraw a portion of their cash value for current use. In universal life insurance plans, the cash value isn't guaranteed. However, after the first year or two, it may have enough cash value built up to be partially surrendered (withdrawn).

Your insurance company may charge a penalty for withdrawing all of the cash value from a policy before a specified amount of time has passed. Surrender fees will reduce your surrender value. These costs and the policy's surrender value can fluctuate over the life of a policy. After a certain time period, the surrender costs will no longer be in effect, and your cash value and surrender value will be the same.

Surrender period

Surrendering a life insurance policy involves cancelling your coverage in exchange for a lump sum value. Surrender charges, also known as surrender fees, are fees levied on a life insurance policyholder upon cancellation of their life insurance policy. The fee is used to cover the costs of keeping the insurance policy on the insurance provider's books.

The surrender period is the length of time during which surrender charges apply. This period varies by policy and can be anywhere from a couple of years to over 15 years. After the surrender period, there are generally no restrictions on when you can surrender a life insurance policy.

Surrender charges are typically applied to investments intended for long-term use and help the issuer offset the cost of selling and managing the investment. They are designed to discourage people from using an investment as a short-term trade. For example, a cash-value life insurance policy is likely to have a surrender charge, as do most types of annuities and some mutual funds.

During the surrender period, surrender charges tend to decrease over time. For instance, a typical surrender fee schedule for annuities might start at 7% in the first year and decrease by 1% each year until it reaches 0% in the eighth year and beyond. Surrender charges can also be waived in certain circumstances, such as in the case of the death of the policyholder or if the policyholder becomes disabled or seriously ill.

It is important to carefully review the documents and understand the surrender period and associated fees before investing in a life insurance policy.

Avoiding surrender charges

Surrender charges are fees levied on a life insurance policyholder upon cancellation of their life insurance policy. These fees are intended to cover the costs of keeping the insurance policy on the provider's books. They are also known as surrender fees.

Surrender charges can be avoided by:

• Taking out a small amount each year: Many annuities allow you to withdraw a small amount of the investment each year without having to pay an additional surrender fee. This is known as the "free withdrawal provision".
• Waiting out the surrender charge: Surrender charges tend to decrease over time, so simply waiting until they are lower or no longer in effect can help you avoid these fees.
• Death of the policyholder: Surrender charges are typically waived for the beneficiary of a life insurance policy with cash value.
• Disability or serious illness: In some cases, surrender charges may be waived if the owner of an annuity becomes disabled, is diagnosed with a terminal illness, enters long-term care, or needs financial assistance to pay for home health care.

It is important to carefully review the terms of your life insurance policy to understand the specific surrender charges that may apply and how to avoid them. Additionally, consider the long-term nature of life insurance policies and the need to continue paying premiums even in the event of a job loss.

Frequently asked questions