When Does Insurance Total A Car?

Getting into a car accident is traumatic, and the aftermath can be overwhelming. You have to deal with insurance claims, temporary transportation, and the possibility of your car being written off. When a vehicle is written off, it is deemed a total loss by the insurance company, meaning the cost of repairing the vehicle is greater than the value of the vehicle overall. This usually happens when the damage is substantial, but sometimes a vehicle can be written off after a minor collision due to high inflation, the cost and availability of parts, and the cost of shipping parts from abroad. Insurance companies will also take into account the cost of providing a courtesy or rental car while repairs are made. If the cost of repairs reaches 50% or more of the vehicle's value, it will likely be written off.

The vehicle is deemed a total loss

When a vehicle is involved in an accident, it may be deemed a total loss if the cost of repairing it is greater than the value of the vehicle itself. This is often referred to as a "write-off".

In the event of serious damage, insurance appraisers will assess the value of your vehicle prior to the accident to establish its actual cash value (ACV). Factors such as the vehicle's make, model, year, customisation, mileage, condition, and sale price of similar vehicles are taken into account. Once the ACV is established, the damage is assessed, and the cost of repairs is compared to the value of the vehicle. If the cost of repairs reaches or exceeds 50% of the vehicle's value, the insurance provider will likely write off the vehicle.

In some cases, even if the repairs cost less than the value of the vehicle, other factors such as high inflation, car part prices, difficulty in obtaining parts, or dealing with older model cars may lead to a write-off. Additionally, the deployment of airbags during an accident can add significantly to the repair cost and indicate greater structural damage.

When a vehicle is written off, the insurer will usually pay out a sum equivalent to the vehicle's estimated value, minus any deductible, and the vehicle will be sent for disposal, salvage, or sale. The owner may have the option to keep the vehicle, but this depends on the specifics of the insurance policy and the state of the vehicle. In some cases, the vehicle may be required to be crushed by a licensed professional and cannot be re-registered for on-road use.

Repair costs exceed the car's value

When the cost of repairing a vehicle exceeds its value, it is often considered a "total loss" or a "write-off". This typically happens when the repair costs reach 50% or more of the vehicle's value. In this case, the insurance provider will likely write off the vehicle and offer a cash settlement to the owner.

However, it is important to note that insurance companies are for-profit businesses and will aim to minimise their losses. Therefore, they may try to reduce the settlement amount by arguing that the repairs have enhanced the car's value, especially if new parts were used. It is crucial for vehicle owners to keep records of improvements made to the car, as this can help prove its worth.

In some cases, it may be more cost-effective to repair an older vehicle with high mileage rather than purchasing a newer model. This is because newer vehicles often come with expensive electronics that require specialised tools and time to calibrate, increasing repair costs. Additionally, due to today's insane car market, it might be a better option to repair an older vehicle if the electrical, suspension, and frame are in good condition.

When dealing with insurance companies, vehicle owners have the right to challenge the assessment and negotiate for a higher settlement. It is recommended to present evidence, such as mileage records, service history, and affidavits from mechanics, to show that the vehicle was worth more than its book value. Furthermore, insurance companies have arbitration processes that allow for the challenging of decisions. However, it is important to note that insurers are not required to pay for repairs if the vehicle is deemed a total loss.

In summary, when repair costs exceed the car's value, it is essential to consider the vehicle's age, mileage, and the potential enhancement in value due to repairs. It is also crucial to understand the insurance company's processes and the owner's rights to ensure a fair settlement is reached.

The insurer calculates the car's Actual Cash Value (ACV)

The Actual Cash Value (ACV) of a car is how much it is worth at the time of a write-off, factoring in depreciation. It is the amount the owner could reasonably expect to get for it if they sold it on that day. The ACV is calculated by the insurance company and is used to determine whether a vehicle is a write-off, and how much the insurance company will pay out.

The ACV is calculated by assessing the vehicle's depreciation and its pre-collision value. This is done by taking into account the vehicle's age, purchase price, condition, and mileage at the time of the accident. The insurer will also consider the vehicle's make, model, and year, as well as any customisations or extras. The insurer will then compare the vehicle to similar cars in the market to determine its fair market value.

The insurer will use a variety of tools to determine the ACV, including proprietary models and third-party vendors. They will also refer to used car valuation databases such as the Canadian Automobile Red Book or Kelley Blue Book. The insurer will also take into account independent market survey reports and sales of similar vehicles of the same year, make and model.

Once the ACV has been established, the insurer will compare it to the cost of repairs. If the cost of repairs is higher than the ACV, the vehicle will likely be written off. Typically, if the cost of repairs reaches 50% or more of the vehicle's value, the insurer will write it off.

The insurer decides if the car is repairable

After a car accident, your insurance provider will decide whether your vehicle is repairable or should be written off. A car is written off when it is deemed a "total loss", meaning the cost of repairing the vehicle is greater than its pre-accident value. This usually happens when the vehicle has sustained substantial damage, but it can also occur after a relatively minor collision due to factors such as high inflation, the need for specialised parts, or the cost and complexity of recalibrating modern vehicle technology.

To determine whether your car is a write-off, your insurance provider will send an appraiser to assess the vehicle's value prior to the accident. Factors such as the vehicle's make, model, year, mileage, condition, and current market value will be considered. The appraiser will then compare the cost of repairs to the vehicle's pre-accident value to determine if it is economically viable to repair. If the cost of repairs exceeds 50% of the vehicle's value, it will likely be written off.

If your vehicle is deemed repairable, your insurance policy will cover the cost of repairs. However, if it is considered a total loss, your insurance provider will offer a settlement to replace the vehicle. This settlement is typically based on the vehicle's pre-accident value, taking into account depreciation. In some cases, you may be able to keep your damaged vehicle as part of the settlement if it has no structural or safety issues.

It is important to note that insurance companies are for-profit and aim to minimise their losses. Therefore, if you disagree with the assessment or settlement offer, you have the right to challenge it. You can present your own evidence of comparable vehicles and their values or provide a lower estimate for repairs. Additionally, you have the option to buy back your written-off vehicle from the insurance company and attempt to repair it yourself.

The car is irreparable or salvage

If your car is deemed a write-off, it will be branded as either "irreparable" or "salvage". An "irreparable" car cannot be repaired or driven on the road. It can only be used for parts. If your car is branded as "salvage", you will need to have it repaired and inspected before you can drive it legally.

Each province has its own Salvage Branding Legislation to govern how damaged vehicles can be used in the future. In Australia, vehicles declared as statutory write-offs cannot be re-registered for use on the road, but many parts can still be salvaged.

If your car is deemed a write-off, your car insurance company will offer you a settlement cheque equivalent to the car's value at the time of the collision. This value may have decreased due to depreciation. You can use this settlement cheque to purchase a new car, but it will likely not be enough to buy a similar, brand-new vehicle. If your car was brand-new and covered by a depreciation waiver, your settlement will be equivalent to your car's original purchase price.

If you disagree with the settlement amount, you can present your own list of similar vehicles and their values to your car insurer.

Frequently asked questions