Insurance Misrepresentation: When Does It Become Fraud?

Misrepresentation on an insurance application can have serious consequences, including the voiding of the entire policy and resulting claim. A material misrepresentation occurs when an application contains false information or omits certain details. This can impact insurers and other insureds financially. For example, a business that purchases a liability or property casualty policy to protect against customer lawsuits and damage to customer property may find that their insurance claim is denied and their policy rescinded if they made a material misrepresentation on their application.

In most states, intent to deceive does not need to be proven for a claim to be voided. However, under Illinois law, an insurance policy may be revoked if there is clear and convincing evidence of fraud.

Misrepresentation before or after a loss

Misrepresentation in insurance refers to the provision of false or inaccurate information, which can influence the insurance company's decision-making process. There are two types of misrepresentation: negligent misrepresentation and fraudulent or intentional misrepresentation. Negligent misrepresentation occurs when incorrect information is provided without malicious intent. For example, a policyholder might mistakenly report the age of their home's roof, resulting in a higher premium.

Fraudulent misrepresentation, on the other hand, involves knowingly providing false information or concealing relevant information to deceive an insurance provider. For example, if a policyholder falsely denies prior insurance claims on their application. Fraudulent misrepresentation can lead to harsh consequences, including denied claims, policy cancellation, and legal repercussions such as insurance fraud charges.

When it comes to misrepresentation before a loss, insurance companies often allege that the insured made misrepresentations to obtain the policy. This is typically described as "post-loss underwriting", and it is a growing practice used by insurance companies to deny claims. For example, a life insurance company might argue that the insured failed to disclose a medical condition when applying for the policy. In such cases, the insurer can choose to rescind the policy.

On the other hand, misrepresentation after a loss occurs when an insured individual makes false statements or misrepresents facts when presenting a claim. This can also lead to the denial of the claim or even criminal charges for insurance fraud. For instance, an individual might exaggerate a legitimate claim or provide false information about the cause of loss.

To summarise, misrepresentation before or after a loss can have serious consequences, including policy cancellation, denied claims, and legal repercussions. It is important for individuals to provide accurate and honest information to avoid these negative outcomes.

Intentional vs unintentional

Insurance fraud occurs when an insurance company, agent, adjuster, or consumer commits a deliberate deception to obtain an illegitimate gain. Fraud can occur during the process of buying, using, selling, or underwriting insurance. It can be classified into two types: hard fraud and soft fraud. Hard fraud involves the intentional destruction of property to collect on an insurance policy, while soft fraud, which is more common, occurs when a policyholder exaggerates a legitimate claim or lies on an application to obtain a lower premium. Soft fraud is often considered a crime of opportunity.

The distinction between intentional and unintentional misrepresentation in insurance fraud is crucial. Intentional misrepresentation, or hard fraud, involves a deliberate act of deception with the specific intent to obtain illegitimate gains from an insurance policy. This can include staging accidents, lying about the cause of loss, or providing false information to obtain a lower premium. On the other hand, unintentional misrepresentation, or soft fraud, may involve exaggerating a legitimate claim or omitting information without the explicit intention to deceive. While soft fraud is not necessarily intentional, it can still be considered fraudulent and have legal consequences.

In the context of insurance applications, a misrepresentation made by the insured before a loss, or in the application itself, is typically grounds for the insurer to rescind the policy. Conversely, a misrepresentation made after a loss will generally give the insurer the right to deny coverage for the submitted claim. To establish fraud, insurers must prove either an intent to deceive or a material misrepresentation. The specific intent to deceive refers to the insured's motive to be accepted as an insurance risk by making false statements. On the other hand, a material misrepresentation refers to an untrue fact that significantly affects the risk undertaken by the insurer.

While most insurance customers are honest, fraud can still occur unintentionally. Some consumers may not realize that their actions constitute fraud, such as exaggerating a legitimate claim or providing inaccurate information. However, it is important to note that insurance companies have Special Investigation Units (SIUs) or trained fraud investigators who work closely with law enforcement to detect, investigate, and pursue action against fraudulent activities. These investigators are trained to recognize unusual behavior and use specialized data analytics techniques to identify fraud.

Material misrepresentation

A material misrepresentation on an insurance application can have major ramifications. It can be considered a fraudulent or criminal act in certain states. A material misrepresentation is a lie of commission or omission, or the withholding of information. It occurs when an application contains false information.

A material misrepresentation means that the insurance company would not have issued the policy, or they would have issued a different kind of policy if the facts had been presented accurately. In most states, including New York, any material misrepresentation gives the insurance company a legal basis to deny the claim and rescind the policy. The insurance company does not have to prove that the policyholder intended to deceive it or obtain a policy by fraudulent means.

For example, a business purchases a "liability" or "property casualty" policy to protect liability for customers' damaged property and potential lawsuits. Under most states' laws, if the policyholder made a material or false representation on its application, the entire policy and resulting claim will be voided.

Insurance fraud is a felony. It occurs when an insurance company, agent, adjuster, or consumer commits a deliberate deception to obtain an illegitimate gain. It can occur during the process of buying, using, selling, or underwriting insurance. Fraud inflicts extra costs on insurance companies and financially impacts consumers and businesses.

Fraudulent intent

In the context of insurance applications, a misrepresentation refers to providing incorrect or false information or withholding material information. A misrepresentation is considered material if disclosing the true and complete information would have led the insurer to deny the policy, offer a different type of policy, or set different terms and premiums.

To establish fraudulent intent, courts will typically examine a range of circumstantial evidence. This includes considering similar fraudulent acts committed by the insured in the past, especially if they are sufficiently recent to infer a similar motive. Additionally, courts may analyse the language used by the insured, as deceptive individuals often try to avoid direct answers, minimise self-references, shift blame, or provide vague responses.

The intent to deceive is an important factor in proving fraud. However, it is not always necessary for an insurer to prove fraudulent intent to void a claim or rescind a policy. In most states, including New York, a material misrepresentation alone gives the insurer a legal basis to take such actions. Nevertheless, establishing fraudulent intent can strengthen the case for fraud.

It is worth noting that insurance fraud can be committed by both consumers and insurance companies. Consumers may commit fraud by providing false statements, exaggerating claims, or staging accidents. On the other hand, illegitimate insurance companies or dishonest agents may defraud consumers by offering bogus policies at attractive prices, with no intention of paying out claims. Therefore, fraudulent intent can be attributed to both parties involved in the insurance process.

Right to rescind

In contract law, rescission is the right of a contractual party to cancel the contract. This is done to bring the parties back to the position they were in before they entered into the contract. In the context of insurance, rescission refers to the termination of a contract from the beginning, rendering it void from the outset. It is typically viewed as an extreme remedy and is rarely granted.

Insurers have the right to rescind an insurance policy due to concealment, material misrepresentation, or material breach of warranty. This means that if an insured person intentionally conceals or misrepresents material facts concerning the insurance, the insurer may rescind the policy. The insurer must be able to prove an "intent to deceive" or a material misrepresentation to exercise this right.

Rescission is different from policy cancellation. When a policy is rescinded, it is as if the contract never existed, and all premiums must be refunded to the insured. In contrast, when a policy is cancelled, coverage ends at a certain date, and only the unused portion of the premiums is refunded.

Rescission decisions must be material to the risk. This means that the information alleged to be inaccurate by the insurance company must be substantial enough to affect their decision to issue the policy or set the premium amount. For example, if an insured person misrepresents their smoking status, the insurer may have issued the coverage but at a higher premium. In this case, the insurer has the right to rescind because the premium would have been higher.

Rescission must also occur within specific time frames. For life insurance, disability insurance, and long-term care insurance, rescission must take place within two years of the issuance of the policy unless fraud is alleged, in which case there is no time limit.

If you receive a rescission notice, it is important to understand the reasons for revoking your insurance policy. Your insurance policy cannot be rescinded if the alleged false statement, error, or omission is of minimal significance, if you were unaware of a medical condition at the time of the application, or if the question posed by the insurance company was vague or overly complex. If you believe the grounds for rescission are inaccurate or irrelevant, you should promptly reach out to your insurance company in writing. If the issue cannot be resolved, you may need to seek legal assistance.

Frequently asked questions