Private Insurance: Who's Keeping It And Why?

The topic of private insurance has been a divisive issue among Democratic candidates in the 2020 presidential race. Candidates such as Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren support Medicare for All, which would essentially eliminate private insurance in favour of a single government-run plan. On the other hand, candidates like Joe Biden, Pete Buttigieg, and Andrew Yang want to preserve private insurance while also providing a public option. This mixed approach aims to cater to two audiences: Democratic primary voters who support Medicare for All, and the general electorate, who are less supportive of eliminating private insurance. Some candidates, like Kamala Harris and Cory Booker, have taken a middle ground, co-sponsoring the Medicare for All bill while also wanting to preserve private insurance in some form.

Joe Biden opposes eliminating the private insurance industry

Joe Biden has stated his opposition to eliminating the private insurance industry. Instead, he wants to expand Obamacare by adding a government-run public option. Biden's stance on this issue is in contrast with that of Bernie Sanders, who has proposed a "Medicare for All" bill that would create a government-run program and end private insurance.

Biden's healthcare plan involves adding a "public option" to the 2010 healthcare overhaul, with expanded coverage paid for by tax increases on the wealthiest Americans. He has described this proposal as the “quickest, most rational way to get universal coverage,” expressing skepticism about a sudden transition to "Medicare for All." Biden's plan would make existing premium subsidies more generous and expand eligibility for middle-income households, lowering their out-of-pocket costs. It also aims to extend premium-free coverage to lower-income Americans who have been denied access to Medicaid in states that refused to participate in the Affordable Care Act.

Biden's position on healthcare is influenced by his work alongside former President Barack Obama, who remains popular among Democrats. By defending and seeking to expand upon Obamacare, Biden presents himself as a sensible centrist, promising to rise above the more liberal positions of single-payer advocates. This stance has drawn criticism from progressive rivals, who argue that his plan falls short of achieving universal healthcare coverage.

Biden's approach to healthcare has been a key point of differentiation from his competitors in the 2020 Democratic presidential race. During the campaign, he emphasized his support for the Affordable Care Act, challenging not just President Donald Trump but also some of his Democratic rivals who favored a fully government-run model. Biden's defense of Obamacare and his proposal to build upon it with a public option helped reinforce his position as a centrist candidate.

In summary, Joe Biden opposes eliminating the private insurance industry and instead favors expanding the existing Affordable Care Act by adding a public option. This stance sets him apart from progressive candidates who support a single-payer system and has been a significant factor in shaping the 2020 Democratic presidential race dynamics.

Bernie Sanders' Medicare for All bill would end private insurance

Bernie Sanders Medicare for All bill would end private insurance

Senator Bernie Sanders' "Medicare for All" bill would create a government-run health program, providing universal health coverage to all Americans, regardless of their legal status. This would essentially end private health insurance, as it would replace it with a single-payer system.

The bill would expand Medicare coverage to include dental, hearing, vision, and home and community-based long-term care, as well as inpatient and outpatient services, mental health and substance abuse treatment, reproductive and maternity care, and prescription drugs, among other benefits. It would also eliminate cost-sharing, with no networks, premiums, deductibles, copays, or surprise bills.

Sanders acknowledges that taxes would need to be raised to fund the program, but argues that middle-class families would save overall by eliminating health expenses. He proposes a mix of financing options, including income-based premiums, higher marginal tax rates for high earners, and taxes on large financial institutions and the wealthy.

Supporters of the bill argue that it would reduce overall health spending and improve health outcomes, guaranteeing healthcare as a right for all Americans. However, critics argue that it would lead to longer waiting lists, reduced access to specialized services, and a decline in medical reimbursement, with a negative impact on patient access and quality of care.

Some Democratic candidates, such as Joe Biden, have taken a more moderate approach, favouring a public option that preserves the private insurance system while expanding access to a government-run plan. Other candidates, including Cory Booker, Kamala Harris, and Kirsten Gillibrand, have co-sponsored Sanders' bill while also calling for the preservation of private insurance, taking a middle ground position.

Candidates such as Cory Booker and Andrew Yang want to preserve private insurance

Andrew Yang, a tech entrepreneur, has also said that he supports a "Medicare for All" system that preserves private insurance. Yang is a former candidate for the Democratic nomination for president of the United States. He ran in the 2020 election, suspending his campaign in February 2020.

Other candidates who want to preserve private insurance include Joe Biden, Michael Bennet, Steve Bullock, Julian Castro, John Delaney, Tulsi Gabbard, John Hickenlooper, Jay Inslee, Amy Klobuchar, Wayne Messam, Seth Moulton, Beto O'Rourke, Tim Ryan, Pete Buttigieg, Kirsten Gillibrand, and Marianne Williamson.

Some candidates want to keep private insurance for now, including Pete Buttigieg and Kirsten Gillibrand

Gillibrand has said that she believes that every person should have access to high-quality, affordable healthcare because healthcare is a human right, not a privilege. She has worked to lower prescription drug prices, protect reproductive healthcare access, and strengthen and expand the healthcare workforce. Gillibrand has also passed legislation to support veterans' healthcare and benefits.

Buttigieg and Gillibrand are not alone in their stance on private insurance. They are joined by two other candidates, author Marianne Williamson and tech entrepreneur Andrew Yang. Additionally, several other candidates have staked out a middle ground, calling for Medicare for All while also looking to preserve private insurance. These candidates include senators Cory Booker, Kamala Harris, and Elizabeth Warren.

Some candidates want to keep private insurance but are vague about their plans, including Kamala Harris and Elizabeth Warren

In the 2020 Democratic primary race, several candidates expressed a desire to keep private insurance while also implementing a Medicare-for-All system. This position was seen as an attempt to appeal to both Democratic primary voters, who tended to support a single-payer system, and the general electorate, who were more likely to want to keep their private insurance. Among these candidates were Kamala Harris and Elizabeth Warren, who were vague about their plans for private insurance.

Harris initially indicated support for eliminating private health insurance during a 2019 presidential campaign debate. However, she later walked back her support, saying she had misinterpreted the question, and unveiled her own healthcare plan. This plan called for a transition to a single-payer system while preserving a role for private insurance companies. Under her plan, Americans could obtain health insurance through the public Medicare plan or through a Medicare plan offered by a private insurer. Harris also stated that she would allow private insurers to "cover what is not otherwise covered" by Medicare, which she predicted would be "very little".

Warren, meanwhile, co-sponsored Bernie Sanders' Medicare-for-All bill, which would have abolished private health insurance. However, she did not explicitly state her own position on eliminating private insurance. Instead, she focused on her support for Medicare-for-All as a way to guarantee high-quality healthcare for all Americans and reduce the financial burden of medical bills.

Both Harris and Warren have emphasised the need to reduce healthcare costs and improve access, but their specific plans for the role of private insurance in their proposed systems remain unclear.

Frequently asked questions