Sedan Insurance: Costlier Than Crossovers, But Why?

When it comes to car insurance, there are several factors that determine the cost, and these vary depending on the vehicle type. Sedans and SUVs have different characteristics that influence their insurance rates. While sedans are generally more affordable to purchase, their insurance premiums tend to be higher compared to SUVs. This is partly due to the safety features and crash performance of SUVs, which are often perceived as safer due to their size and height, resulting in lower insurance costs. On the other hand, sedans may suffer higher damage and repair costs in collisions due to their lower bumpers and ride height. Additionally, the popularity of SUVs among certain demographics and their appeal to car thieves can also impact insurance rates.

SUVs are more popular, so they are more attractive to car thieves

SUVs are more popular than sedans, and their higher sales figures may make them more attractive to car thieves. In 2019, SUVs dominated the top 10 list of best-selling vehicles in the United States, with a sedan only appearing in 8th place. This trend has continued, with SUVs outselling sedans by 2-to-1 in the USA in 2022. The Porsche Macan SUV, for example, outsells all other Porsche models combined.

SUVs are popular for many reasons. They are often considered safer, more comfortable, and more spacious than sedans. They also come in a variety of sizes, from small crossovers to larger, truck-like models, appealing to a wide range of drivers. The increased demand for SUVs has made them more common on the road, which may make them a more appealing target for theft.

Insurance rates are influenced by the likelihood of vehicle theft. The Insurance Bureau of Canada, for example, publishes an annual list of the top 10 most stolen vehicles in Canada and specific regions, which can impact insurance rates for those vehicles. As SUVs become more prevalent and desirable, they may be at a higher risk of theft, contributing to higher insurance rates.

It is important to note that insurance costs are determined by a combination of personal and vehicle-related factors. While the popularity of SUVs may be a consideration, other aspects such as safety features, market value, and repair costs also play a significant role in determining insurance premiums.

SUVs are heavier, so they are less likely to be damaged in an accident

While it is generally observed that SUVs are cheaper to insure than sedans, it is not always the case. The insurance rates vary depending on the make and model of the vehicle, with some SUVs being more expensive to insure than sedans. However, one of the reasons that SUVs are often cheaper to insure than sedans is because they are heavier and thus less likely to be damaged in an accident.

The weight of a vehicle is an important factor in determining the cost of insurance. Heavier vehicles, such as SUVs, typically have a lower insurance cost compared to lighter vehicles like sedans. This is because, in the event of a collision, a heavier vehicle is more likely to sustain less damage than a lighter one. The logic here is that the force of impact is distributed over a larger mass, resulting in reduced damage to the vehicle.

In contrast, sedans tend to have lower bumpers and ride height, which makes them more susceptible to damage in an accident. The lower ride height can also increase the risk of undercarriage damage, which can be costly to repair. Additionally, sedans may suffer higher losses in average collisions due to their smaller size and lighter weight.

It is important to note that while weight is a contributing factor to insurance rates, it is not the sole determinant. Other factors such as the safety features of the vehicle, its market value, the cost of repairs, and the likelihood of theft also play a significant role in determining insurance premiums.

Furthermore, the popularity of SUVs cannot be understated. Their increased presence on the road has made them a common target for car thieves, which in turn has contributed to higher insurance rates for some models. Nevertheless, the weight of an SUV remains a key factor in its insurance costs, with heavier vehicles often benefiting from lower premiums due to their ability to withstand accidents with lesser damage.

Sedans are often bought by younger drivers who are more likely to crash

Sedans are often chosen by younger, less experienced drivers, who are statistically more likely to be involved in road accidents. This is a key factor in determining insurance costs, as the number of claims and the cost of those claims will be higher for sedans. Insurance companies are aware that younger drivers often opt for small, cheap sedans, and the data shows that these drivers are more likely to crash them. This is a significant contributor to higher insurance premiums for sedans.

The choice of vehicle for younger drivers often comes down to affordability, and sedans are typically cheaper to purchase than SUVs. The lower price point attracts less experienced drivers, who may be buying their first car. This demographic factor plays a role in the insurance rates for sedans, as younger drivers are considered higher-risk by insurance companies due to their lack of driving history.

Additionally, sedans may suffer higher losses in average collisions due to their lower bumpers and ride height. The repair costs for sedans can be significant, especially when compared to SUVs, which tend to be heavier and thus less likely to sustain extensive damage in a wreck. The cost to repair a vehicle is a critical factor in determining insurance rates, and the higher repair costs for sedans contribute to higher insurance premiums.

It is worth noting that insurance rates are also influenced by the popularity of certain vehicles. SUVs have become increasingly popular, and as a result, they are more attractive to car thieves, which can lead to higher insurance rates. In contrast, sedans may be less sought-after by thieves, which could be a factor in keeping their insurance costs relatively lower than some SUV models.

While the higher insurance rates for sedans can be partially attributed to the demographics of their owners, it is important to consider the mechanical and design aspects of these vehicles as well. The lower ride height and bumper position of sedans can result in more severe damage in collisions, driving up repair costs and insurance claims. These structural factors contribute to the higher insurance premiums associated with sedans.

SUVs have a higher risk of rollover accidents due to their height and width

The cost of insuring a vehicle is influenced by a variety of factors, including the cost of repairs, the number of claims, and the cost of those claims. Typically, the higher the market value of a vehicle, the more expensive its insurance will be. However, it is interesting to note that SUVs are generally cheaper to insure than sedans, with an average annual premium of $1,762 compared to $2,131 for sedans. This is despite the fact that SUVs are often more expensive to purchase than sedans.

One factor that may contribute to the higher insurance costs for sedans is the increased risk of rollover accidents due to their height and width. SUVs are typically taller and wider than sedans, which makes them more stable and less likely to roll over in certain situations. This is a significant consideration for insurance companies when assessing the risk associated with each type of vehicle.

The height and width of SUVs give them a higher center of gravity, which improves their stability and reduces the likelihood of a rollover accident. While sedans have lower bumpers and a lower ride height, which can result in more severe damage in the event of a collision. The structural design of SUVs may also provide greater protection for occupants in the event of a rollover, further reducing the potential for injuries and costly insurance claims.

Additionally, the weight of an SUV can be a contributing factor to its stability and resistance to rolling over. Heavier vehicles, such as SUVs, often have a lower center of gravity, which can improve their stability and make them less prone to rollover accidents. This is in contrast to lighter vehicles, such as sedans, which may have a higher center of gravity and be more susceptible to rolling over in certain conditions.

It is important to note that other factors, such as safety features, theft rates, and driver demographics, can also influence insurance rates. However, the height and width of SUVs, coupled with their weight, play a significant role in their reduced risk of rollover accidents and, consequently, their lower insurance costs when compared to sedans.

SUVs are safer, so insurers are more confident offering lower premiums

SUVs are generally considered safer than sedans, and this has a significant impact on insurance premiums. Insurers are more confident when offering lower premiums for vehicles with impressive safety records and features.

SUVs are often perceived as safer due to their size and weight, which can provide a sense of security on the road. Their height and bulk suggest a lower risk of severe damage in an accident, especially when compared to smaller sedans. This perception of robustness influences insurance rates, as insurers factor in the potential cost of repairs and total losses.

Additionally, some SUVs are equipped with advanced safety features that reduce the risk of accidents. These features can include collision avoidance systems, lane departure warning systems, and improved braking mechanisms. Insurers consider the presence of such features when calculating premiums, as they can significantly decrease the likelihood and severity of claims.

While it's important to note that other factors, such as driver demographics and theft rates, also play a role in determining insurance rates, the safety advantages of SUVs contribute to their lower premiums. Insurers base their calculations on statistical analysis, and if SUVs consistently demonstrate lower accident rates and repair costs, this will be reflected in the premiums offered.

Furthermore, the popularity of SUVs among certain demographics, such as older drivers and families, can also influence insurance rates. These demographics often have lower at-fault rates and are considered lower-risk drivers, which can contribute to the overall perception of SUVs as a safer option.

In summary, the safety advantages of SUVs, both in terms of their physical characteristics and advanced safety features, give insurers the confidence to offer lower premiums. This, combined with other factors, results in SUVs often being more affordable to insure than sedans.

Frequently asked questions