Unmarried Females: Auto Insurance's Dark Secret

Auto insurance companies charge unmarried females more money because they consider unmarried drivers to be statistically riskier. According to a study by the Consumer Federation of America, a change in marital status from married to unmarried can cause a woman's auto insurance premiums to rise as much as 226%. This is because insurance companies view unmarried individuals as less financially stable and more likely to get into accidents or file claims. Additionally, factors such as credit score, age, and gender are also taken into account when determining insurance rates. While men are generally considered higher-risk drivers and pay more for auto insurance, women may still pay more in certain states due to varying insurance company formulas.

Unmarried drivers are considered statistically riskier

Insurance companies consider married couples more financially stable and risk-averse. They are seen as less likely to get in an accident or file a claim, and are therefore offered cheaper rates. Conversely, unmarried drivers are seen as more likely to get in an accident or file a claim, and are charged more for insurance as a result.

There are several reasons why unmarried drivers are considered riskier. Firstly, unmarried people tend to be less well-off than married people. This means that insurance companies are less interested in selling liability coverage to unmarried people, as they are seen as less profitable.

Secondly, unmarried people are more likely to be young. Younger drivers have less experience behind the wheel, making them more likely to make mistakes and cause accidents. This is true regardless of gender.

Thirdly, unmarried people are more likely to be living with roommates or partners who use their vehicle. This increases the chance of the vehicle being involved in an accident, even if the unmarried owner of the vehicle is not driving it themselves.

Finally, unmarried people are more likely to have negative rating factors on their insurance profiles, such as a bad driving record or a low credit score. This can result in higher insurance premiums, even if the unmarried person is a safe driver.

In conclusion, unmarried drivers are considered statistically riskier by insurance companies due to a combination of factors, including age, financial stability, and the number of people with access to the vehicle. As a result, they are often charged higher insurance premiums.

Married couples are seen as more financially stable

Auto insurance companies consider married couples to be more financially stable and risk-averse. This perception of financial stability leads to the assumption that married individuals are less likely to get into accidents or file insurance claims. As a result, married couples often benefit from lower insurance rates compared to unmarried individuals. This pricing structure reflects the industry's view of unmarried individuals as statistically riskier drivers.

The financial stability attributed to married couples influences insurance rates beyond just car insurance. For example, married couples can also take advantage of multi-policy discounts by bundling their home or renters insurance with their auto insurance. By combining policies and leveraging their perceived financial stability, married couples can further reduce their overall insurance costs.

It is worth noting that the correlation between marital status and insurance rates is not universally accepted. Some critics argue that insurance companies base their risk assessments on questionable data, such as a 2004 New Zealand study that had too few instances of accidents involving divorced, separated, or widowed drivers to draw conclusive conclusions. Despite this, insurance companies continue to use complex pricing algorithms that include marital status as a significant factor in determining rates.

While the "widow penalty" and higher rates for unmarried individuals have sparked debates about fairness, insurance companies defend their practices as actuarially sound. The result is a pricing structure where marital status plays a significant role in determining auto insurance rates, with married couples often paying less than their unmarried counterparts due to their perceived financial stability and lower-risk profile.

To summarize, auto insurance companies view married couples as more financially stable, leading to lower insurance rates. This perception is based on the assumption that married individuals are less likely to get into accidents or file claims. Married couples can also take advantage of multi-policy discounts, further reducing their insurance costs. While the correlation between marital status and risk is disputed, insurance companies continue to use it as a significant factor in their pricing algorithms.

Gender-based pricing is banned in some states

While there is no federal law in the United States that prohibits gender-based pricing, some states have taken it upon themselves to ban the practice. California, for example, passed the Unruh Civil Rights Act in 1959, becoming the first state to enact legislation against gender-based price discrimination. The Gender Tax Repeal Act, which prohibits businesses from charging different prices for services based on a customer's gender, was later enacted to combat gender-based price discrimination in the pricing of services. However, this law did not prohibit price differentials with respect to products.

Recognising this gap, California State Senator Ben Hueso introduced Senate Bill 899 in 2016, which aimed to extend the prohibition of gender-based pricing from services to products. The bill proposed to prevent businesses from charging different prices for goods of "similar or like kind" based on the customer's gender. Amendments to the bill clarified that businesses could charge more for a product if there were legitimate differences in the costs of labour, materials, or tariffs.

In 1997, Miami-Dade County in Florida also passed an ordinance prohibiting businesses from charging different prices for products or services based solely on the customer's gender. However, businesses are permitted to charge varying prices if the product or service involves more time, difficulty, or cost.

In Washington state, a group of high school students has brought forward a new bill to ban gender-based pricing across the state. The bill is based on similar legislation previously passed in New York and California. If passed, it would prevent retailers from selling products or services at different prices based on gender.

Women are charged more in 25 states

The logic behind the "widow penalty" is that unmarried drivers are allegedly statistically riskier drivers. Insurance companies consider married couples more financially stable and risk-averse, meaning they are less likely to get in an accident or file a claim. As a result, insurance companies automatically factor in a person's marital status when calculating their rates.

While it is legal for insurance companies to charge unmarried women more for auto insurance in 25 states, there is controversy surrounding the practice. Some argue that it is immoral and should be stopped, while others defend it as a standard practice in the insurance industry.

Men are charged more in 21 states

While unmarried women are often charged more for car insurance than married women, men are charged more for car insurance than women in 21 states. This is because insurance companies consider married couples more financially stable and risk-averse, meaning they are less likely to get in an accident or file a claim.

Insurance companies do not like risk, and according to statistics, men present more of a risk to insure than women. Research from the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, which examines the behaviours of American drivers, shows that men are more likely to engage in aggressive driving behaviours, such as speeding through a red light. Men are also involved in more collisions overall than women. Data from Statistics Canada shows that of the 1,851 deaths reported in 2018, 1,313 involved male drivers, compared to 538 involving female drivers.

The Traffic Injury Research Foundation has found that in fatigue-related accidents, the driver is typically young, male, and alone. Men are also more likely than women to drink and drive. Research from Mothers Against Drunk Driving shows that males account for 87% of young, fatally injured drunk drivers and 89% of young, seriously injured drunk drivers. According to 2018-2019 data from StatCan, 17,696 males were found guilty of impaired driving in 2018, compared to 5,184 females.

Men are also more careless when it comes to seatbelt use, according to data from the Ontario Provincial Police. As a result of these behaviours, insurance companies have determined that men are more of a risk to insure and have set their premiums accordingly.

Male drivers tend to pay higher premiums until about the age of 40, after which premiums become more equal between the sexes. However, insurance rules vary by state, and in some states, companies are not allowed to take age and sex into consideration when pricing premiums. In these states, men still tend to pay more for insurance because they are involved in more at-fault collisions, which increases the premium.

Frequently asked questions