Cash Value Life Insurance: A Bad Bet For Your Money

Cash value life insurance is a type of permanent life insurance that lasts for the insured's entire life, provided that the premiums are paid. It includes a savings component that allows the policyholder to build up cash value on top of the insurance protection. While this may seem like a good idea, there are several reasons why cash value life insurance is considered a bad choice. Firstly, it is much more expensive than term life insurance, with premiums that are substantially higher. Secondly, the cash value component often takes a long time to accumulate any significant value, and even then, accessing this money can be complicated and come with additional costs and tax implications. Thirdly, the returns on cash value life insurance are generally low due to high fees charged by insurance companies. Finally, in most cases, the cash value is not paid out to beneficiaries upon the policyholder's death but reverts to the insurance company. For these reasons, cash value life insurance is generally not recommended as a good financial product or investment vehicle.

High fees and charges

Cash value life insurance policies are notorious for their high fees and charges. When you buy a cash value life insurance policy, the premium you pay is split between the cost of the insurance itself, fees associated with holding the policy, and the cash balance. These fees are charged by the insurer for providing coverage and maintaining the policy.

Sales charges, including the selling agent's commissions, are also included in the fees. On top of that, there are administration fees for record-keeping and accounting, as well as mortality and expense risk charges, which compensate the insurance company in case the insured person doesn't live as long as assumed. Finally, there's the actual cost of insurance, which is based on age, gender, health, and benefit amount.

All these fees eat into the cash value of the policy, resulting in a slow accumulation of cash value. In the early years of the policy, most of the money contributed is used to pay these various charges and costs, and you may even have negative cash value at the beginning. This makes the overall rate of return on the policy much lower than a traditional investment account.

For example, if you make an initial premium payment of $10,000 for a cash value insurance policy, most of that money goes towards paying the fees and charges, and you don't actually have $10,000 in cash value. In contrast, if you invest $10,000 in stocks, bonds, or mutual funds, you have that full amount to start growing or falling in value.

The high fees and charges associated with cash value life insurance policies are a significant drawback, making it a less attractive option for those looking for life insurance or investment opportunities.

Slow to accumulate cash value

One of the main arguments against cash value life insurance is that it is slow to accumulate cash value. This is because, in the early years of the policy, most of the money you contribute is used to pay for the cost of coverage, and only a small portion goes into the cash value account. This means that it can take many years to build up any significant cash value, and the overall rate of return can be much lower than a traditional account. For example, you might pay an initial premium of $10,000 for a cash value insurance policy, but most of that money will go towards the cost of the coverage, and you may even have negative cash value early on. In contrast, investing $10,000 in stocks, bonds or mutual funds will give you $10,000 to start, which can then grow or fall in value.

The slow accumulation of cash value in these policies can be problematic if you are looking for quick access to cash or a high rate of return on your investment. It can take between two and five years to start building cash value and a decade or longer to earn substantial growth, depending on your payment schedule, the fees associated with the policy, and the performance of your investments. This slow accumulation of cash value also means that the policy is less flexible, as you must continue paying the necessary premiums to keep the policy intact. If you withdraw too much cash value, the policy may lapse, and you may have to pay taxes on the overdrawn amount.

While cash value life insurance policies offer the benefit of lifelong coverage and a death benefit for your beneficiaries, the slow accumulation of cash value means that this type of policy may not be the best option if you are looking for quick access to cash or a high rate of return on your investment.

Lapse risk

Cash value life insurance premiums are typically higher than those of regular life insurance policies because a portion of each payment goes towards the savings component. This makes it crucial for policyholders to continue paying the necessary premiums to maintain their coverage. Failure to do so could result in a lapse of the policy, leading to a loss of coverage and accumulated cash value.

The risk of lapse is particularly relevant for older individuals. As people age, their financial obligations may decrease, and the need for life insurance may diminish. At this stage, the cost of premiums may outweigh the benefits of the policy, leading to a potential lapse.

Additionally, the cash value component of the policy may not accumulate significantly in the early years, as a large portion of the premiums is allocated to the cost of insurance and fees. This slow accumulation could lead to disappointment and contribute to the decision to lapse the policy.

Furthermore, withdrawing too much of the cash value could also result in a lapse. Policyholders need to be mindful of maintaining a minimum cash value level to avoid this outcome. If the cash value is depleted, the policy may lapse, and the coverage will be cancelled.

In summary, the high cost of premiums, slow accumulation of cash value, and the possibility of withdrawing too much are factors that contribute to the lapse risk associated with cash value life insurance. Policyholders need to carefully consider their long-term financial commitments and ensure they can sustain the payments to avoid losing their coverage and accumulated benefits.

Illiquid asset

Cash value life insurance is considered an illiquid asset. This is because the cash value of the policy is not easily accessible. While the policyholder can borrow against the cash value or withdraw it, this will usually result in a reduction in the death benefit. Additionally, there may be fees or penalties associated with accessing the cash value, such as surrender charges or taxes on the portion of the withdrawal that comes from interest or investment gains.

The illiquidity of cash value life insurance means that it may not be a suitable option for those who are looking for a quick or easy source of cash. It is important for potential policyholders to carefully consider their financial goals and needs before deciding whether to purchase a cash value life insurance policy.

Furthermore, the accumulation of cash value in a life insurance policy can take a significant amount of time. This is because, in the early years of the policy, a large portion of the premiums is used to cover the cost of insurance and fees. As a result, the cash value accumulates slowly, and it may take decades to build up a substantial amount. Therefore, cash value life insurance may not be a good option for those who are seeking immediate access to cash or short-term financial protection.

In summary, the illiquidity of cash value life insurance is an important factor to consider when evaluating this type of policy as an asset. The cash value may be difficult or costly to access, and it can take a long time to accumulate. Therefore, it is crucial to weigh the benefits of cash value life insurance against the potential drawbacks before making a decision.

Poor investment returns

Cash value life insurance is a form of permanent life insurance that features a cash value savings component. The policyholder can use the cash value for many purposes, including borrowing or withdrawing cash from it, or using it to pay policy premiums. However, the returns on cash value life insurance are low due to the high fees charged by insurance companies.

Whole life insurance is the least flexible option, with a fixed premium and a low rate of return, typically around 2%. Variable life insurance is also risky as it allows policyholders to decide how their cash value is invested, which can be in stocks or bonds. Universal life insurance is different as it offers flexible premiums and payouts, allowing policyholders to control how much they pay.

The cash value component of life insurance policies earns interest over time, but the rates are generally low. For example, whole life insurance policies offer a fixed rate of return, while indexed universal life insurance ties the investment or cash value account to an index fund, meaning that if the market performs poorly, the cash value won't grow. Variable universal life insurance offers the greatest potential returns but comes with the risk of losing cash value if investments perform badly.

The heavy fees involved with cash value life insurance can significantly reduce returns. These include the cost of insurance protection, marketing and sales commissions, surrender charges, and annual investment fees. In comparison, index mutual funds often have annual expenses under 0.5%, while actively managed mutual funds typically charge around 1%. Therefore, the fees associated with cash value life insurance can be much higher than those of alternative investment options.

Frequently asked questions