Men's Insurance Premiums: Unfairly Priced Or Justified?

Men statistically pose a higher risk to insurance providers, which is why they have higher insurance premiums. Factors such as age, occupation, and health are considered when determining insurance rates. For example, young male drivers are more likely to be involved in accidents and risky driving behaviors, resulting in higher insurance premiums. Additionally, men are more likely to be arrested for driving under the influence (DUI) and are more likely to die in traffic accidents. While gender-based pricing is prohibited in some places, such as the European Union and a few US states, it is still prevalent in most parts of the United States.

Men are more likely to be involved in accidents and risky driving behaviours

The discrepancy in insurance rates between men and women is not limited to a specific age group or region. In the United States, men in all age groups are more likely to be arrested for driving under the influence (DUI) than women, with a 341% higher likelihood for men aged 65 and older. Additionally, men made up 71% of all traffic fatalities in 2019, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. This trend is also observed in Canada, where, in 2013, 69% of traffic fatalities were men, and 80% of drivers charged with impaired driving were male.

While the impact of gender on insurance rates is notable, it is essential to acknowledge that other factors also contribute to insurance pricing. These factors include an individual's driving record, age, vehicle make and model, and location. Furthermore, insurance companies must get their rates approved by the state they operate in and back up their pricing with actuarial data.

The higher insurance rates for men have sparked debates about discrimination. Some argue that using gender as a factor in insurance pricing is discriminatory, especially considering that it is illegal to discriminate based on gender in other contexts. However, insurance companies defend their practices by pointing to the statistical differences in risk factors between men and women. This debate has led to changes in some jurisdictions, such as California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania, and Germany, where it is no longer permitted to use gender as a factor in car insurance rates.

Men are more likely to be arrested for driving under the influence (DUI) across all age groups

The 2000 National Household Survey on Drug Abuse (NHSDA) also revealed that self-reported rates of DUI were highest among White men (22%), followed by Native American/Native Alaskan men (20.8%) and men of Mixed race (22.5%). The 12-month arrest rates for DUI were highest among men of Mixed race (5%) and Native American/Native Alaskan men (3.2%).

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, men made up 71% of all traffic fatalities in 2019, indicating that they are 145% more likely to die in traffic accidents than women. This data, along with the higher likelihood of men being arrested for DUIs, contributes to men being considered a higher risk to insurance providers. As a result, men often pay more for insurance than women.

While factors such as gender and age are beyond one's control, it is worth noting that insurance companies base their rates on population statistics. This means that even if an individual man has a good driving record, he may still pay more for auto insurance than a woman with a similar record due to the overall statistical differences between genders.

The disparity in insurance rates based on gender has sparked debates about discrimination. Some argue that insurance companies engage in legal discrimination by charging different rates based on gender. However, insurance companies in the US must get their rates approved by the state and back up their claims with actuarial data to justify charging different rates to specific groups. In states like California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania, it is illegal to determine car insurance rates based on gender.

Men are more careless when it comes to seatbelt use

Men typically pay more for car insurance than women due to a variety of statistical factors and risk assessments made by insurance companies. One of the key reasons for this disparity is that men are considered to be more careless when it comes to seatbelt use. According to data from the Ontario Provincial Police, men are less likely to wear seatbelts, which increases their risk of injury or death in the event of a car accident. This behaviour contributes to insurance companies' determination that men are a higher risk to insure, resulting in higher insurance premiums.

The discrepancy in insurance rates between men and women is influenced by various factors, including driving behaviour, accident history, and vehicle choice. Young male drivers, in particular, tend to exhibit riskier driving behaviours, such as speeding, reckless activities, and drunk driving. As a result, they are more likely to be involved in accidents, which leads to higher insurance claims. For example, drunk driving accidents are the leading cause of teenage deaths, and the statistics double for young men compared to women in the same age group.

While it may seem unfair that gender plays a role in insurance premiums, insurance companies base their rates on risk assessments. Statistics consistently show that men, especially those under the age of 25, are more likely to be involved in accidents and exhibit riskier driving behaviours. This increases the likelihood of insurance claims, resulting in higher insurance premiums for men. It is important to note that the discrepancy in insurance rates between genders tends to decrease as individuals age, with rates becoming more equal after the age of 25 or 30.

In some jurisdictions, such as California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania, and Germany, it is illegal to charge different insurance rates based on gender. However, in most places, insurance companies are allowed to use gender as a factor in determining insurance premiums, as long as they can provide actuarial data to support their claims. By charging higher rates to groups with a higher risk profile, insurance companies can recover the cost of claims while maintaining a reasonable profit margin.

While men may be subject to higher insurance rates due to factors beyond their control, such as gender, there are still ways to reduce insurance premiums. Male drivers can practice safe driving habits, obey traffic rules, maintain a good driving record, and shop around for the best rates. By taking these proactive measures, men can mitigate the impact of gender-based pricing and secure more affordable car insurance.

Men are more likely to drive high-performance vehicles

Men are more likely to pay higher insurance premiums than women due to several statistical factors and risk assessments made by insurance companies. One of the factors that contribute to this disparity is the type of vehicles men tend to choose. Men are more likely to drive high-performance vehicles, such as sports cars and specialty vehicles, which are considered more risky to insure. These types of cars generally cost more to insure, regardless of the driver's age or gender.

The preference for high-performance vehicles among men contributes to the perception of men as riskier drivers. According to data from the Ontario Provincial Police, men tend to be more careless when it comes to seatbelt use, which increases the risk of injury in the event of an accident. Additionally, men are more likely to be arrested for driving under the influence (DUI) across all age groups, with a 341% higher likelihood for men aged 65 and older compared to their female counterparts.

The higher incidence of drunk driving among men leads to more frequent and severe accidents. This behaviour not only puts themselves but also other road users at risk. As a result, insurance companies view men as a higher risk to insure, and this is reflected in the higher insurance premiums they charge. The discrepancy in insurance rates between genders tends to decrease around the age of 25 or 30, when rates generally drop for both men and women.

While the type of vehicle is a significant factor in insurance rates, other considerations also come into play. For example, the number of kilometres driven annually differs between men and women, with men driving an average of 26,634 km per year compared to 16,321 km for women, according to US data. This higher mileage for men may also contribute to the perception of increased risk and, consequently, higher insurance rates.

In conclusion, men's preference for high-performance vehicles is a contributing factor to their higher insurance premiums. However, it is essential to acknowledge that insurance companies consider various factors when setting rates, including driving behaviour, accident statistics, and demographic information. While it may seem unfair that men pay more for car insurance, insurance companies base their rates on risk assessments and population statistics to ensure they can cover the cost of potential claims.

Men are more likely to be charged with impaired driving

Men are statistically more likely to be charged with impaired driving than women. This is true across all age groups, with the disparity being most prevalent in the 65 and older age group, where men are 341% more likely to be arrested for impaired driving than women in the same age group. The highest percentage of drunk drivers are in the 21-24 age group, with four male drunk drivers for every female drunk driver. The impaired driving charge rate peaks at age 24 for women and 25 for men.

There are several physiological reasons why men are more likely to be charged with impaired driving. Firstly, women generally have less water and more body fat per pound of body weight than men. Since alcohol does not go into fat cells as easily as other cells, more alcohol remains in the blood of women, leading to a higher blood alcohol concentration (BAC). Additionally, weight is a factor, as the more an individual weighs, the more water is present in their body to dilute the alcohol and lower the BAC.

The higher rate of impaired driving charges among men also has behavioral and cultural causes. For example, men are more likely to engage in risk-taking behaviors, such as driving after consuming alcohol. Social norms and peer pressure may also play a role, with men feeling pressured to drink and drive to fit in with their peers. Furthermore, men are overrepresented in professions that require shift work or long hours, which can increase the risk of impaired driving.

The consequences of impaired driving can be severe and costly. Charges can range from misdemeanors to felony offenses, and penalties can include driver's license revocation, fines, and jail time. A first-time offense can cost the driver upwards of $10,000 in fines and legal fees, and many states require offenders to install ignition interlock devices at their own expense. Impaired driving not only poses a risk to the driver but also to other road users, with about 32% of all traffic crash fatalities in the United States involving drunk drivers.

Frequently asked questions