Insurance Rates: Higher Premiums, What Changed?

Insurance rates are on the rise, with car insurance up by more than 11% in the last year, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. There are several reasons for this increase, including the rising cost of car repairs, an increase in natural disasters, and higher-than-average labour and construction costs. Inflation is also a factor, with insurance companies facing higher costs that are passed on to consumers. In addition, factors specific to individuals, such as age, location, and driving record, can also contribute to higher insurance rates.

Inflation and rising costs of repairs and parts replacements

Inflation and the rising costs of repairs and parts replacements are significant factors in the increase in insurance premiums. Inflation affects the cost of goods and services, including materials and labour for repairs and replacements covered by insurance. As these costs rise, insurance companies adjust premiums to ensure they can cover the increasing cost of claims.

The rise in insurance premiums is closely linked to the cost of repairs and full vehicle replacement. With the rising cost of both parts and labour, vehicle owners can expect to pay more for repairs after a car accident, which means higher insurance claims and settlements when accidents occur. Insurance companies must make sure they have enough money to pay for the statistical number and severity of accidents for policyholders, which means increasing premiums on auto insurance.

The cost of auto parts has increased for manufacturers, and this has resulted in a rise in the cost of a new car. No matter what brand or model, car prices are rising. The rise in car prices is a lagged response to the inflation surge that affected car prices and repair costs.

Inflation and the rising costs of repairs and parts replacements are not the only factors contributing to the increase in insurance premiums. The transition from internal combustion engine cars to electric vehicles (EVs) has also played a role. EVs have higher accident probabilities due to their acceleration speed, and they also have higher average repair costs due to different manufacturing processes. EVs can be harder to repair since they are highly integrated.

Natural disasters and severe weather

As climate change continues to alter weather patterns, certain areas that were previously considered low risk by insurers are now viewed as high risk. For example, states in the middle of the country have experienced a higher incidence of hail and wind damage claims, leading to steep premium hikes for homeowners in these regions. Similarly, states prone to hurricanes or wildfires, such as Florida and California, have also seen significant increases in insurance rates.

The increase in natural disasters has led to a rise in the cost of repairs and parts replacements, further contributing to higher insurance premiums. Snarled supply chains, parts shortages, and a tight labor market have all contributed to the increasing costs of repairing or replacing damaged vehicles and homes.

In addition, insurance companies have experienced historic losses due to severe weather events, with State Farm, one of the largest insurers in the US, incurring extraordinary losses in 2023. As a result, they have been forced to institute rate hikes across multiple states to offset these losses.

The impact of natural disasters and severe weather on insurance rates is not limited to areas directly affected by these events. As the frequency and severity of claims increase, insurance companies may implement stricter underwriting criteria and raise costs across the board to reflect higher demand and exposure. This can result in higher premiums for homeowners and drivers even in areas not typically associated with high-risk weather events.

Vehicle theft

The make and model of a vehicle play a crucial role in determining insurance rates. Certain vehicles are more prone to theft than others, and this is reflected in the insurance rates. For instance, the Honda Accord, Honda Civic, Chevrolet Silverado pickup, Ford F-series pickup, and Toyota Camry are among the most stolen vehicles, with many of them being older models from the late 1990s and early 2000s. As a result, the insurance rates for these vehicles tend to be higher.

Additionally, the location of the vehicle is also a contributing factor. If the area where the vehicle is parked or frequently driven has a high number of vehicle theft claims, the insurance rates are likely to be higher. This is because the risk of theft is greater in these areas, and insurers take this into account when calculating premiums.

Comprehensive coverage is essential in protecting against vehicle theft. While it may not be mandatory, it is highly recommended as it is the only type of coverage that protects against car theft or damage caused by theft or break-ins. In the event of a stolen vehicle, comprehensive coverage can provide compensation for the current value of the car, minus the deductible. It is worth noting that comprehensive coverage is generally more affordable than collision coverage and can be purchased separately, providing valuable peace of mind.

To mitigate the risk of vehicle theft and potentially lower insurance rates, it is advisable to take preventive measures. This includes installing anti-theft devices, parking in well-lit areas, using immobilizers to prevent hot-wiring, and investing in location trackers. Taking these precautions can not only reduce the likelihood of theft but may also be eligible for insurance discounts offered by some providers.

Traffic violations

There could be numerous reasons why your insurance is higher than last year, and traffic violations are one of the key factors that can significantly impact your premiums. Here's how:

Your location

Insurance rates are also calculated by ZIP code and neighbourhood. Rural drivers generally pay less for car insurance than those in urban areas, where vandalism, theft, and accidents are more prevalent. Within cities, insurance rates can vary significantly from one neighbourhood to another.

Additionally, if you live in an area prone to natural disasters, such as coastal regions, Tornado Alley, or flood plains, your home insurance premiums will likely reflect that increased risk. Similarly, if your location has a high rate of theft, accidents, or weather-related claims, insurance companies may consider it riskier to provide coverage for that area, resulting in higher premiums.

Frequently asked questions