The Fuzzy Line Between Employee And Contractor: Insurance Adjusters And Their Independence

Are insurance adjusters independent contractors? Well, it's complicated.

The term independent adjuster is something of a misnomer, as these professionals are not truly independent. They are required to comply with state licensing requirements and can work as either 1099 independent contractors or W-2 employees. Historically, they have tended to work as independent contractors, but in recent years, they are more commonly hired as W-2 employees for legal and liability reasons.

Independent adjusters are hired by insurance companies to assess and negotiate insurance claims on their behalf. They differ from staff adjusters, who are direct, salaried employees of an insurance company.

So, while independent adjusters are typically contracted through third-party claims-handling companies, they ultimately work for and represent the insurance company.

Insurance adjusters can be independent contractors or W-2 employees

On the other hand, independent adjusters (IAs) have a broader definition. They are not directly employed by an insurance company but are hired by an insurer when a claim is made, thus providing third-party objectivity and greater perceived fairness to those filing a claim. They are typically contracted by a third-party claims-handling company or "Independent Adjusting Firm" (IAF) and are employed by the IAF but operate as representatives of the insurance company.

In the past, independent adjusters usually worked as 1099 independent contractors. However, in recent years, due to legal and liability reasons, the trend has shifted towards hiring IAs as W-2 employees, even for short-term or catastrophe-related deployments. This shift ensures better control and management of the claims process by the insurance company.

It is worth noting that independent adjusters are usually on multiple rosters and can find work with different firms, providing flexibility and a large pool of adjusters for insurance companies to draw from during spikes in claims, such as after natural disasters.

Independent adjusters are hired by insurers when a claim is made

Independent adjusters are hired by insurance companies when there is a high volume of claims, often following a natural disaster, and the workload is too much for staff adjusters to handle. They are also hired for their specific expertise in certain situations.

Independent adjusters are not directly employed by an insurance company but are hired by an insurer when a claim is made. They are considered independent because they are often employed by a third-party company that specialises in insurance claims. This means the insurer is outsourcing the claim and the adjustment process to a third party, who then turns it over to one of their adjusters.

Independent adjusters are typically contracted through a third-party claims-handling company, or "IA firm". The insurance company outsources the claim to one of these third-party claims-handling companies, which then assigns it to an independent adjuster.

Independent adjusters are required to comply with the license requirements of the state in which they perform their work. They can work as independent contractors or employees.

There are two types of insurance adjusters: company adjusters, who are employed by insurance companies, and public adjusters, who work as independent contractors.

They are typically hired due to a high volume of claims

Insurance adjusters are typically hired due to a high volume of claims, which can be caused by natural disasters such as hurricanes or storms. In these situations, insurance companies may not have the human resources to handle the influx of claims and will, therefore, hire independent adjusters to ease their workload.

During times of natural disasters, the number of homeowner claims increases substantially. For example, in 2012, Hurricane Sandy destroyed large portions of the New Jersey coastline and New York, severely damaging more than 340,000 homes. As a result, homeowners' insurance companies saw a spike in claims.

In addition to natural disasters, high volumes of claims can also be caused by seasonal changes, especially in the hospitality industry, where demand for new workers can fluctuate depending on the time of year.

When there is a high volume of claims, insurance companies will often outsource these claims to independent adjusting firms, which then contract independent adjusters to handle the claims on their behalf. These independent adjusters are typically hired as W-2 employees, even for short-term deployments.

By hiring independent adjusters, insurance companies can ensure that claims are handled in a timely and efficient manner, providing customers with the support they need during difficult times.

Independent adjusters are paid on a fee schedule, a percentage of the total claim

Independent adjusters are typically employed and paid as independent contractors. They are paid based on a fee schedule, which is a document that outlines the fees they will be paid for different types of claims handled. The fee schedule is an accounting method where the insurance company reimburses the independent adjuster firm for each settled claim. The fee is calculated as a percentage of the overall claim settlement amount or on a graded scale. The fee schedule is then split between the firm and the individual adjuster.

The percentage of the fee schedule that an adjuster earns varies depending on the company, location, experience, and demand for adjusters. During catastrophes, such as Hurricane Harvey and Irma, the fee schedules were changed, with fees increased and some adjusters earning higher percentages due to the high demand for adjusters. Typically, independent adjusters earn between 55% to 70% of the fee schedule, with the remaining 30% to 40% going to the adjusting firm.

For example, an adjuster handling a $10,000 claim should expect to take home between $600 and $700. In the case of individual auto claims, independent adjusters are usually paid a set fee, which is often around $500 per day for catastrophic auto insurance.

Independent adjusters are paid on a fee schedule because they work on a contract basis. This allows them to choose when and where they work, providing flexibility and the potential for above-average earnings. However, it is important to note that independent adjusters are responsible for their taxes, insurance, vacation, and other standard employment benefits.

They can be self-appointed and handle claims for any company

Insurance adjusters play a crucial role in the insurance claims process, and they can be either employees of an insurance company or independent contractors. When it comes to the latter, it's important to understand that independent insurance adjusters are self-employed professionals who may be hired by insurance companies to handle claims on their behalf. One of the unique aspects of independent insurance adjusters is that they can indeed be self-appointed. This means they have the flexibility to work independently and are not bound to a single insurance company. They may choose to handle claims for any insurance company that requires their services. This independence allows them to take on a diverse range of claims and work with multiple clients, providing a more flexible and dynamic career path.

Self-appointed insurance adjusters, often referred to as independent adjusters, have the freedom to contract their services to different insurance companies or even to policyholders directly. They are typically licensed professionals with a deep understanding of the claims process and the necessary expertise to handle a wide range of insurance-related tasks. By being self-appointed, they can offer their services on a more flexible and individualized basis, catering to the specific needs of each client or claim. This flexibility benefits both the adjuster and the insurance companies, as it provides a scalable and efficient way to manage claims, especially during times of high claim volume or in regions where additional support is needed.

The work of an independent insurance adjuster involves directly handling insurance claims from start to finish. This includes investigating and assessing the validity of a claim, evaluating and documenting the extent of the damage, reviewing policy coverage, and ultimately determining the appropriate compensation for the claimant. By handling claims for any company, independent adjusters gain a broad perspective on the industry and develop a comprehensive understanding of different insurance policies and procedures. This diverse experience can enhance their problem-solving skills and enable them to provide valuable insights and efficient claim resolutions.

It is worth noting that while independent insurance adjusters have the freedom to work with any company, they must still adhere to the regulations and guidelines set by the state or province in which they operate. Licensing requirements and industry standards ensure that these professionals maintain a certain level of expertise, ethics, and integrity in their work. By staying up to date with industry changes and adhering to regulatory frameworks, independent adjusters can effectively navigate the complexities of different insurance scenarios and provide valuable services to insurance companies and claimants alike.

Frequently asked questions