Auto Insurance: The Annual Creep Of Rising Premiums

Car insurance premiums have a tendency to increase annually, even if no claims have been filed. This is because car insurance companies compensate for the money they pay out in claims per year through rate revisions. If an insurance company's claim payout total exceeded its premium revenue, it will often pass on those costs to customers the following year. On average, car insurance premiums increased by 2% between 2018 and 2019.

There are a number of reasons why your car insurance premium may increase over time. These include personal factors, inflation, and broader variables like state insurance legislation changes and rising auto repair prices. For example, if you add another car or a teenage driver to your policy, your costs will increase. Your costs will decrease if you drop either a car or a driver from your policy.

Individual risk factors

Several individual risk factors can influence auto insurance rates. These factors are assessed by insurance companies to determine an individual's risk level and calculate their insurance premiums. While some factors, like age and location, are beyond one's control, others, such as driving record and credit score, can be actively managed to secure better rates. Here are some key individual risk factors:

Age and Driving Experience

Age is a significant factor in determining auto insurance rates, especially for young and inexperienced drivers. Teen drivers are considered high-risk and tend to pay substantially higher premiums than adult or senior drivers. According to data, teen drivers are involved in fatal crashes three times more frequently than drivers over 20 years old. Insurance rates gradually decrease as drivers mature, with rates typically dropping by up to 20% when they turn 25.

Driving Record

An individual's driving history, including moving traffic violations, accidents, and DUI/DWI convictions, heavily influences insurance rates. Insurance companies typically review an individual's driving record for the past three to five years. A history of accidents, traffic violations, or DUI convictions will result in higher premiums. Conversely, maintaining a clean driving record can help secure lower rates.

Credit Score

An individual's credit score is a significant but often overlooked rating factor. Data suggests that drivers with poor credit are more likely to file insurance claims, and these claims tend to be more expensive. As a result, individuals with low credit scores often face higher insurance premiums. In some states, the use of credit-based insurance scores for car insurance pricing is banned.

Location

Where an individual lives can significantly impact their auto insurance rates. Insurance rates vary by state due to differing regulations and coverage requirements. For example, Michigan, a no-fault state, mandates unlimited Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage, resulting in higher insurance costs. Additionally, insurance rates are priced by ZIP code, with higher rates in areas with more drivers, higher accident rates, and higher risks of crimes like vandalism or theft.

Gender

Gender primarily affects auto insurance rates for young drivers. On average, male teen drivers pay higher premiums than female teen drivers due to perceptions of risk-taking behaviour. However, this difference diminishes as drivers mature.

Insurance History

Insurance companies view continuous coverage as a positive indicator of lower risk. A lapse in coverage or a coverage gap may result in higher rates, as it suggests the individual may have been driving without insurance. Maintaining uninterrupted coverage can help secure more favourable rates.

Vehicle Type

The type of vehicle an individual drives also influences insurance rates. Insurance companies consider the repair costs, theft rates, and comprehensive claims associated with specific vehicle models. Brand-new sports cars or vehicles with expensive safety features may lead to higher premiums due to potential replacement costs.

Annual Mileage

The number of miles driven annually can impact insurance rates, especially in certain states like California. Individuals who drive fewer miles are generally considered lower-risk, as they have a reduced chance of being involved in accidents. Informing insurance companies of reduced annual mileage can lead to lower premiums.

Marital Status

Marital status has a minor effect on auto insurance rates. Married individuals are statistically less likely to be involved in accidents and tend to share driving duties, resulting in fewer individual claims. As a result, married drivers may benefit from slightly lower insurance rates compared to single, divorced, or widowed drivers.

Inflation

In addition to inflation, auto insurance rates are influenced by broader economic trends, such as increases in auto repair and healthcare costs. The cost of repairing vehicles and medical care for injured crash victims has been rising faster than inflation in recent years. As a result, insurance companies have been raising rates to cover these expenses.

Another factor contributing to rising insurance rates is the increase in the number of crashes and the cost of these crashes. The number of crashes is influenced by factors such as distracted driving, higher speed limits, and crowded roadways in large metropolitan areas. As the number and cost of crashes rise, insurance companies pass these expenses on to their customers, leading to higher insurance rates.

Furthermore, as the unemployment rate falls, more people are driving to work and have more disposable income for leisure driving. This leads to an increase in the number of cars on the road and a preference for more expensive vehicles with high-tech components. These factors contribute to rising insurance rates as the cost of repairing and replacing these vehicles is higher.

Cost of living increases

Auto insurance rates can increase annually due to several factors, including personal factors, inflation, and economic conditions. One significant reason for rising insurance costs is the increase in the cost of living, which affects various aspects of the economy.

Inflation and Cost of Living Increases

Inflation and rising costs of living are significant factors contributing to annual increases in auto insurance rates. Inflation impacts the price of commodities, especially energy, which, in turn, affects insurance companies' business expenses. As a result, insurance providers pass on these increased costs to their customers through higher premiums.

The rising costs of medical care, auto body repairs, and legal fees have outpaced inflation in recent years. These expenses are covered by auto insurance policies, and their increase directly affects insurance rates. For example, medical and auto body repair costs have increased faster than inflation, contributing to higher insurance rates.

Additionally, economic trends such as falling unemployment rates mean more people are driving to work and have more disposable income for leisure driving. This increased driving activity leads to a higher likelihood of accidents and insurance claims, which further drives up insurance costs.

Other Factors Affecting Insurance Rates

Other factors that influence auto insurance rates include individual driving records, claims history, and changes to insurance policies. For instance, adding a new vehicle or driver, especially a teenage driver, can increase insurance costs. Similarly, moving to a different address or a new ZIP code can impact insurance rates due to factors such as population density and accident rates in the area.

Furthermore, broader variables like state insurance legislation changes, the propensity for claims in particular regions, and rising auto repair prices also impact insurance rates. These factors are beyond an individual's control but contribute to the overall increase in insurance costs.

In summary, the rising costs of living, driven by inflation and economic trends, significantly contribute to annual increases in auto insurance rates. Additionally, personal factors and broader industry and economic conditions also play a role in determining insurance rates.

Company losses

Auto insurance companies need to collect as much in premiums as they pay out for losses and expenses. If their total claim payouts exceed their premium income, they will often pass these expenses on to customers the following year. This is a common reason for insurance rate increases, and since 2019, car insurance rates have climbed by an average of 2%.

The costs of paying claims have generally risen across the US, and insurance companies increase premiums to offset these higher expenses. This is especially true for healthcare and salary costs, which are rising across all sectors of the economy. Inflation is a significant factor in these rising costs, and insurance companies increase rates to balance out these higher costs.

Another reason for rate increases is the trend towards more expensive vehicle repairs and medical costs. Repair and medical costs are almost always on the rise, so overall rate decreases are rare.

Insurance companies also consider the number of crashes and the cost of these crashes when pricing their policies. For example, drivers in large metropolitan areas tend to pay more because there are more cars and, therefore, more crashes in those cities. Distracted driving is also a significant issue, with people texting, talking, or otherwise occupied while driving, leading to more crashes.

In addition, auto insurance covers more than just vehicle repairs. It also covers the cost of injured crash victims' medical care and lost wages, as well as the repair or replacement of any property damaged in a crash. In recent years, medical and auto body repair costs have increased at a rate much faster than inflation.

With the unemployment rate falling, more people are driving to and from work, and they are also driving more for leisure. People are also buying more expensive cars, which are often more costly to fix and replace once damaged.

Industry trends

Auto insurance rates have been increasing yearly, and this can be attributed to a variety of factors. One of the main reasons is inflation, which has reached a 40-year high, with an increase of 8.5% in the 12 months leading up to March. Inflation affects the cost of living, including salaries, healthcare, and other expenses, which in turn impacts insurance rates.

Another factor is the increase in the cost of cars, with the average used car selling for over $28,000 in January 2022, a 42% increase from pre-pandemic prices. This is due to high demand and a global shortage of semiconductor chips, which are now used in greater numbers in newer car models. The increased use of advanced technology in cars has also made them more expensive to repair, which in turn makes them more costly to insure.

The rise in the number of crashes and the cost of these crashes also contributes to the increase in insurance rates. More crashes occur in large metropolitan areas due to the higher volume of cars and crowded roadways. Additionally, speed limits are being raised, and distracted driving is a prevalent issue, with people texting, talking, or engaging in other activities while driving. These factors increase the likelihood and severity of crashes, impacting insurance pricing across all states.

The cost of medical care and auto body repairs has also been increasing at a rate faster than inflation. Legal costs have risen as well, adding to the overall expense of insurance claims. With more people returning to work and having disposable income, there are more cars on the road, and these cars tend to be more expensive models. While these newer cars often have advanced safety features, their high-tech components are costlier to fix or replace if damaged.

Insurers are investing in technology, such as telematics, to monitor driving behaviour and price policies more accurately. This technology tracks vehicle locations, speed, hard turns, and braking in real time, providing insurers with data to assess risk and set rates accordingly.

Overall, these industry trends, influenced by economic factors, technological advancements, and driving behaviour, have led to rising auto insurance premiums.

Frequently asked questions