Insurances: Hurting Or Helping?

Insurance is supposed to provide peace of mind and financial protection, but for many people, it has become a source of frustration and financial strain. The rising costs of insurance premiums and claims are hurting both consumers and the insurance industry itself. People are facing obstacles to coverage, including denied medical care, higher bills, and a lack of in-network doctors. The complexity of insurance policies makes it difficult for individuals to understand their coverage and benefits, leading to unexpected out-of-pocket expenses. Additionally, social inflation, driven by factors such as anti-corporate sentiment and litigation funding, is contributing to the increasing costs of insurance claims. Climate change is also impacting the insurance industry, with insured losses from natural catastrophes increasing by 250% in the last 30 years. As a result, insurance rates are soaring, and people are struggling to keep up with the rising costs, often sacrificing other expenses to maintain their coverage.

High health insurance costs

Health insurance costs are rising in the US, with the average annual premium for health insurance in 2022 being $7,911 for single people and $22,463 for family coverage. This is a 43% increase in family coverage since 2012. These high costs are having a negative impact on both employers and employees.

Impact on Employers

Employers are facing rising health insurance costs as premiums rise faster than wages. This is causing financial strain and many are concerned about the long-term sustainability of employer-sponsored health insurance. In response, some employers are shifting costs to employees through plan design changes and increasing deductibles. Additionally, employers are attempting to contain health care costs by increasing the share of employee premium contributions, using high-deductible health plans, and offering narrower networks of providers. However, these strategies have limited impact on a key underlying cause of rising health insurance costs: high prices for care.

Impact on Employees

Employees are also feeling the strain of rising health insurance costs, with many facing greater cost-sharing and becoming underinsured. Lower-income workers are disproportionately affected, as they often pay a higher portion of their wages towards coverage. This can result in employees postponing or avoiding needed medical care due to concerns about unpredictable costs. High health insurance costs can also lead to financial difficulties, with about half of US adults finding it difficult to afford health care costs and one in four reporting problems paying for health care in the past year. Furthermore, health insurance costs can affect employees' take-home pay, as employers may offer lower wages to compensate for the cost of providing health insurance benefits.

Solutions

To address the issue of high health insurance costs, several states have established cost commissions to monitor and regulate the cost of care. Federal lawmakers have also considered legislation to eliminate provider-insurer contract clauses that contribute to high prices for care. Employers can gain greater control over health insurance costs by self-funding their insurance plans or collaborating with other purchasers to improve their bargaining position with providers.

Insurers not covering climate change-related damage

In the United States, some of the largest insurance companies have excluded protections from various weather events and raised monthly premiums and deductibles. For example, companies like Allstate, American Family, and Nationwide have stopped writing coverages in certain regions and excluded damage caused by hurricanes, wind, and hail from policies in coastal areas and wildfire-prone regions. This leaves individuals and families in these areas without crucial insurance protections, as their exposure to natural disasters increases with rising global temperatures.

The insurance industry's response to climate change has caught the attention of regulators and lawmakers, who are concerned about the impact on coverage availability and underwriting assumptions. Insurers are facing the dual challenge of addressing escalating climate risks and adapting to shifting industry regulations. As the frequency and severity of extreme weather events continue to increase, insurers must adapt their business models and develop innovative solutions to maintain the availability and affordability of insurance products.

The growing physical risk exposures and insurance claims due to climate change will likely lead to higher premium levels over time, further impacting the affordability of insurance for many people. Additionally, the increased frequency and severity of natural disasters associated with climate change can make it challenging for insurers to accurately predict future losses and price their products appropriately. This uncertainty may lead to insurers declining coverage in certain areas or increasing premiums to unaffordable levels.

To address these challenges, insurers can take proactive steps such as partnering with government agencies and policyholders to invest in residential dwelling resiliency measures, educating policyholders on risk prevention and mitigation, offering incentives for hazard-resistant structural improvements, and deploying new technologies to map out high-risk areas. By working together, insurers and public entities can promote a more sustainable and resilient future while ensuring that society is protected from the financial and economic losses associated with climate change.

Lack of transparency in insurance coverage

A lack of transparency in insurance coverage is a significant issue that can hurt people in several ways. Firstly, it undermines consumers' ability to make informed decisions about their healthcare purchases. Without transparent and accessible pricing information, consumers are unable to accurately compare and choose the most cost-effective care and coverage options. This lack of transparency leads to higher costs for consumers and reduces their ability to make cost-conscious choices.

The Departments of Labor, HHS, and the Treasury acknowledge that transparency in health coverage requirements is essential to strengthening the healthcare system. By providing clear information, stakeholders, including healthcare consumers, researchers, and regulators, can make informed decisions. This includes uninsured individuals who finance their healthcare needs through insurance purchases or pay out-of-pocket. However, despite ongoing federal efforts, there is still a lack of standardized pricing information in the private market, making it challenging for consumers to access the information they need.

The impact of this lack of transparency is far-reaching. Consumers are demanding more transparent pricing information, as evidenced by a May 2019 poll where 88% of US registered voters supported an initiative for mandatory disclosure of pricing and negotiated rates. The lack of transparency also affects sponsors of self-insured and fully-insured group health plans, contributing to rising healthcare costs. Without transparency, market efficiency suffers, and it becomes difficult to establish the level of competition necessary to ensure rational and reasonable healthcare costs.

To address this issue, the Departments have proposed revisions to the definition of "negotiated rate" in the final rules. However, some commenters have raised concerns about potential legal conflicts with state laws, common law, and tort laws protecting trade secrets and proprietary business information. Others argue that public disclosure of negotiated prices could have anticompetitive effects and harm consumers. Despite these concerns, improved access to pricing information has the potential to increase health insurance literacy, consumerism, and competition, ultimately driving down healthcare costs.

Delayed or denied medical care

Health insurance should act as a bridge to medical care, but unfortunately, it often acts as a barrier. Many commercial health insurance policies delay, disrupt, and deny patients the medically necessary care they require. This is a result of insurance companies' cost-saving practices, which can lead to instances of bad faith.

The Impact of Delayed or Denied Medical Care

According to a Morning Consult poll, 62% of the 1,500-plus patients surveyed say treatment has been delayed because of their insurance provider. This trend has caused many patients to become sicker. In addition, nearly half of those who encountered a problem with their insurance said they could not satisfactorily resolve it. Some could not obtain the care they had sought, while others said they paid more than expected.

The Extent of the Problem

A survey by the nonprofit health research group KFF revealed that nearly 60% of Americans with health insurance had a problem with their coverage over the past year. Furthermore, those who were most likely to need medical care—people who described themselves as in fair or poor health—reported more trouble; three-fourths of those receiving mental health treatment experienced problems.

The Effects of Delayed or Denied Medical Care

The consequences of delayed or denied medical care can be significant, especially for sick people. Delayed care can endanger health and, in the worst-case scenarios, patients may suffer a worsened condition, permanent disability, or death because they do not receive the right course of treatment in a timely manner.

The Reasons for Delayed or Denied Medical Care

There are hundreds of reasons a health plan might deny payment for a healthcare service. Some common reasons include:

• Paperwork errors or mix-ups
• Questions about medical necessity
• Cost control
• The service isn't covered by the patient's plan
• Provider network issues
• Missing details
• Failure to follow the health plan's rules, such as not obtaining prior authorization

What to Do About Delayed or Denied Medical Care

If you’re willing to pay for the treatment yourself, out-of-pocket, you’ll probably be able to have the healthcare service without further delay. However, if you can’t afford to pay out-of-pocket, or if you’d rather not, you may want to look into the cause of the denial to see if you can get it overturned. This process is called appealing a denial, and it can be done in response to a prior authorization denial or the denial of a post-service claim.

Insurance companies' monopoly power

In the United States, the issue of insurance monopolies is particularly prominent in the health insurance sector. Studies have shown that health insurance premiums are significantly higher in areas with fewer insurance companies. For instance, in 2018, premiums were 50% higher in regions with a monopolist insurer compared to areas with more than two insurers. This trend is not limited to a specific type of insurance plan, as monopolization extends to policies purchased by individuals, group plans, and Medicare Advantage plans.

The lack of competition in these markets allows insurers to raise prices without fear of losing customers to competitors. Additionally, insurers can exert their market power by negotiating lower prices with local healthcare providers, but there is little incentive for them to pass on these savings to their customers. As a result, insurance companies' profits increase while consumers bear the burden of higher premiums.

The consolidation of insurance companies also creates barriers to entry for new insurers, further entrenching their market power. This concentration of power enables insurers to demand concessions from healthcare providers, such as including "most-favored nation" clauses in contracts, which prevent hospitals from offering more favourable prices to other insurers. As a result, hospitals are pressured to charge higher prices to other insurers, reducing overall competition in the market.

To address these issues, some have proposed stronger antitrust enforcement and government intervention. However, it is important to note that the dynamics of the healthcare industry, such as patients' inability to choose based on price, especially in emergency care, also contribute to rising costs. Therefore, a comprehensive approach that considers both market power and the unique characteristics of the healthcare sector is necessary to protect consumers from the negative impacts of insurance monopolies.

Frequently asked questions