Unraveling The Insurance Billing Conundrum: Composite Vs. Age-Based Methods

There are two methods for determining insurance premiums: age-based rating and composite rating. Age-based rating calculates premiums based on each member's individual risk level, factoring in variables such as age, zip code, and smoking status. On the other hand, composite rating sets premiums based on the average risk profile of a group, resulting in all members of the group paying the same insurance premium. This approach is often used in employer-sponsored plans, where it offers insurance tax benefits and saves employees the time and effort of researching individual policies. While composite rates may benefit older or less healthy individuals, younger and healthier individuals might find more affordable options through individual policies.

Composite vs Age-Based Billing for Insurance

Composite rates are based on the average risk profile of a group

When determining an individual rate, an insurance company will examine the individual's risk profile, including factors such as age, smoking status, and place of residence. The insurer will then use actuarial tables to determine the likelihood of the policyholder making a claim and set the premium accordingly.

On the other hand, when determining a composite rate, the insurer looks at the risk profile of the entire group. They combine the risk profiles of all individuals and arrive at an average risk profile, which is then used to set the premium. Each member of the group will pay the same premium, regardless of individual differences.

Composite rates are calculated by first determining the annual premium in the normal manner. Then, the insurer selects a convenient exposure base, which is the basis on which the rate is set. For example, for health insurance, the exposure base would be the number of members in the group. The insurer then calculates an average rate by dividing the premium by the number of exposures or individuals in the group.

Composite rates offer several advantages, including simplifying the process of calculating premiums, facilitating the audit process, and making it easier to predict insurance costs. They are often used in group health insurance and some commercial insurance policies.

Composite rates are used in insurance underwriting for group coverage policies

In other words, composite rates are insurance premiums established by reviewing the average risk profile for a group. This is in contrast to an individual rate, which generates risk premia that correspond to an individual's demographic and behavioural factors.

For example, in the case of health insurance, an individual's risk profile includes their age, smoking status, and where they live. For a composite rate, the insurer looks at the risk profile for the entire group and arrives at an average risk profile. They then use this average profile to set the premium, which is the same for each member of the group.

Composite rates are often used in group health insurance and on some commercial insurance policies. They can be beneficial for both the insurer and the policyholder, as they simplify the process of calculating premiums and make it easier to predict insurance costs. They are also convenient for employers, as they save time and offer tax benefits.

However, it is worth noting that composite rates may not be the most cost-effective option for younger, healthier individuals, who may be able to find less expensive individual policies.

Age-rated rating determines premiums based on individual risk level

Age-rated rating, also known as member-level rating, determines insurance premiums based on each member's individual risk level. This includes factors such as age, zip code, and in some states, the smoking status of the employees and their dependents. For example, in the context of health insurance, an individual's risk profile may include their age, smoking status, and place of residence.

The age-rated rating method allows insurance companies to tailor premiums to the specific characteristics of each member of a group. This is in contrast to the composite rating method, which determines premiums based on the overall risk profile of the entire group. With age-rated rating, each member's premium is calculated individually, taking into account their unique set of factors. This means that two people of different ages, living in different areas, and with different smoking statuses could have very different premiums, even if they are part of the same group.

The advantage of age-rated rating is that it provides a more personalised premium for each member. It takes into account individual factors that can significantly impact the likelihood of making an insurance claim. For example, age is a critical factor in determining health insurance premiums, as older individuals generally have higher health risks and are more likely to require medical care. Similarly, smoking status can influence health insurance premiums, as smokers may have higher premiums due to the increased risk of smoking-related illnesses.

However, one potential drawback of age-rated rating is that it may result in higher premiums for individuals with higher-risk profiles. For example, older or less healthy individuals may find that their premiums are significantly higher than those of younger, healthier individuals. Additionally, age-rated rating can create complexity in managing insurance policies, especially for employers or organisations offering group insurance to their workers or members.

Age-rated rating is particularly relevant for small group insurance, where the rates are public, allowing individuals to know their exact premium when they enrol. This transparency can be beneficial for individuals who want to understand their financial obligations clearly. Overall, age-rated rating provides a personalised approach to determining insurance premiums, taking into account each member's unique risk factors.

Composite rating is used for employer-sponsored insurance plans

Composite rating is a common method used by insurance companies to determine the cost of coverage for employer-sponsored insurance plans. It involves calculating a single premium rate for all members of a group, regardless of individual factors such as age, gender, or lifestyle choices, which may otherwise indicate a higher or lower insurance risk.

In employer-sponsored insurance plans, composite rating is used to determine the cost of coverage for all eligible employees. This means that all employees will pay the same premium for health insurance, regardless of their age, smoking status, or other factors that may influence their individual risk profile.

The composite premium rate is calculated by assessing the overall risk profile of the group. Insurance companies will consider the number of group members and the individual risk profiles of each member. By combining these risk profiles, they can determine an average risk profile for the group and set a corresponding premium. This premium is then divided by the number of group members to arrive at the composite premium rate.

For example, consider a company with 150 employees who receive a composite rate on their health insurance. The insurance company will assess the risk profile of each employee, including factors such as age, health status, and behavioural factors. They will then calculate an average risk profile for the group and determine the total premium for the group, let's say $750,000. To find the composite premium rate, they will divide the total premium by the number of employees: $750,000/150 = $5,000. So, each employee will pay a premium of $5,000, regardless of their individual risk factors.

Composite rating offers several advantages for employer-sponsored insurance plans. It simplifies the process of determining premiums, making it easier for employers to calculate and budget for insurance costs. It also facilitates the audit process and provides tax benefits for employees. Additionally, it saves employees time and effort in researching individual insurance options.

Composite rates are beneficial for older, less healthy individuals

For example, in the case of health insurance, an insurance company will typically examine an individual's risk profile, including their age, smoking status and where they live. The insurer will then use actuarial tables to determine the likelihood of the policyholder making a claim and set the premium accordingly. However, with composite rates, the insurer looks at the risk profile for the entire group and calculates an average composite rate, which is applied to all individuals in the group.

As a result, older and less healthy individuals may benefit from lower insurance premiums than they would under an individual policy. Younger and healthier individuals, on the other hand, may be able to find less expensive individual policies. Nevertheless, employer-sponsored plans that use composite rates can offer tax benefits and save employees time and effort in researching alternative options.

Composite rates are particularly relevant for group benefits, such as insurance offered by an employer or organisation to its workers or members. For instance, group life insurance typically uses composite rates, and does not require a medical exam for coverage. Composite rates can also apply to small and large group health insurance plans.

Frequently asked questions