Insurers' Insolvency: What Happens When They Go Bankrupt?

When an insurance company becomes insolvent, it can be a challenging situation for policyholders. While insurance company bankruptcies are rare, they can happen, and it's important to know what protections are in place. In the event of an insurer's insolvency, state insurance regulators step in to protect policyholders and ensure they receive their rightfully entitled settlements or benefits. These protections include statutory reserves, reinsurance requirements, and guaranty associations. Guaranty associations, such as the National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations (NOLHGA), are funded by a portion of insurers' profits and are mandated to protect policyholders by managing liquidated assets and transferring coverage to another insurer.

State insurance regulators monitor the financial health of insurance companies

State insurance departments, or regulators, are responsible for monitoring and regulating insurance activity within their state. This includes overseeing insurer solvency, market conduct, and requests for rate increases for coverage. State regulators monitor the financial health of insurance companies licensed to provide insurance in their state through the analysis of detailed annual financial statements and periodic onsite examinations. This is to protect policyholders from the risk of a company in financial distress.

When an insurance company enters a period of financial difficulty and is unable to meet its obligations, the state insurance commissioner initiates a process to help the company regain its financial footing. This period is known as rehabilitation. The commissioner may appoint a special deputy receiver, an employee of the state insurance department or an independent professional, to supervise the company's activities and oversee an accounting of its assets and liabilities. The receiver's role is to seek to maximize the company's assets, transfer them to cash, and then distribute that cash to creditors with valid claims.

If the company cannot be rehabilitated, the commissioner will declare it insolvent and seek authority from the state court to seize its assets and operate the company pending liquidation. The court will then order the liquidation of the company, and its remaining assets will be divided among creditors and stakeholders. While this process is ongoing, policyholders may find themselves in a challenging situation, unable to collect their rightfully entitled settlement from a company that has no money.

To protect policyholders, all states have guaranty funds or associations that provide coverage for claims against insolvent insurers. These associations work with the insurance commissioner and the receiver to plan for liquidation and provide coverage to policyholders up to certain levels specified by state laws. While the specific benefits covered and the maximum limits vary from state to state, most states provide coverage for life insurance death benefits, cash surrender or withdrawal values for life insurance, annuity benefits, medical insurance policy benefits, long-term care insurance policy benefits, disability insurance policy benefits, and other health insurance benefits.

The insurance commissioner determines when an insurer should be declared insolvent

When an insurance company becomes insolvent, policyholders can find themselves in a challenging situation. While it is rare, it is an issue that needs to be considered, especially when entering into litigation against an insurer, as legal cases can be lengthy.

In the US, insurance is monitored and regulated by state insurance departments, and one of their primary objectives is to protect policyholders from the risk of a company in financial distress. When an insurance company enters a period of financial difficulty and is unable to meet its obligations, the insurance commissioner in the company's home state initiates a process—dictated by the laws of the state—whereby efforts are made to help the company regain its financial footing. This period is known as rehabilitation.

The insurance commissioner, either appointed by the governor or elected, heads the state insurance department and monitors and regulates insurance activity within the state. The commissioner has the responsibility to determine when an insurance company domiciled in the state should be declared insolvent and to seek authority from the state court to seize its assets and operate the company pending rehabilitation or liquidation. If it is determined that the company cannot be rehabilitated, the company is declared insolvent, and the commissioner will ask the state court to order the liquidation of the company.

By obtaining control of a company, the commissioner (or the insurance department) is, by law, the rehabilitator or liquidator of the company. The commissioner may choose to retain a special deputy receiver to supervise the company's activities. The receiver oversees an accounting of the company's assets and liabilities and administers the estate of the company, seeking to maximize the company's assets, transfer them to cash, and then distribute that cash to creditors with valid claims.

State guaranty associations are also in place to protect policyholders of an insolvent insurance company. All insurance companies (with limited exceptions) licensed to sell life or health insurance or annuities in a state must be members of that state's guaranty association. Guaranty associations have subrogation rights to a proportionate share of the assets remaining in a failed insurer, and these assets can be used to pay covered claims.

The commissioner seeks authority from the state court to seize assets and operate the company

When an insurance company becomes insolvent, the state's insurance commissioner, either appointed by the governor or elected, will head the state insurance department and monitor and regulate insurance activity within the state. The insurance commissioner is responsible for determining when an insurance company should be declared insolvent and will seek authority from the state court to seize its assets and operate the company pending rehabilitation or liquidation.

The insurance commissioner's role is to protect policyholders from the risk of financial distress. When an insurance company enters a period of financial difficulty and is unable to meet its obligations, the insurance commissioner in the company's home state initiates a process dictated by the laws of the state, whereby efforts are made to help the company regain its financial footing. This period is known as rehabilitation. If it is determined that the company cannot be rehabilitated, the company is declared insolvent, and the commissioner will ask the state court for permission to liquidate the company.

By obtaining control of the company, the commissioner (or the insurance department) becomes, by law, the rehabilitator or liquidator of the company. The commissioner or department takes control of the company's operations, although they may appoint a special deputy receiver to supervise the company's activities. The receiver oversees an accounting of the company's assets and liabilities and administers the company's estate, seeking to maximize the company's assets, transfer them to cash, and then distribute that cash to creditors with valid claims. Policyholders are priority claimants whose claims are paid before those of general creditors.

State guaranty associations also provide protection for policyholders of an insolvent insurance company. All insurance companies licensed to sell life or health insurance or annuities in a state must be members of that state's guaranty association. The guaranty association cooperates with the commissioner and the receiver in pre-liquidation planning and provides coverage to the company's policyholders who are state residents, up to the levels specified by state laws. Guaranty associations are funded by a portion of insurers' profits and are regulated by state governments to ensure legal compliance and consumer protection.

The receiver oversees an accounting of the company's assets and liabilities

When an insurance company becomes insolvent, the insurance commissioner in the company's home state will ask the state court to order the liquidation of the company. The commissioner may appoint a special deputy receiver to supervise the company's activities. This receiver will be an employee of the state insurance department or an independent professional with experience in legal, accounting, and actuarial issues.

The receiver's role is critical in the process of addressing insurer insolvency. They are responsible for overseeing an accounting of the company's assets and liabilities, as well as administering the company's estate. This involves maximising the company's assets, converting them into cash, and then distributing that cash to creditors with valid claims against the insurer. Policyholders are given priority, and their claims are paid before those of general creditors.

The receiver's work in accounting for the company's assets and liabilities is a crucial step in the insolvency process. It ensures that the company's resources are properly identified, valued, and organised for distribution to the appropriate parties. This process helps to safeguard the interests of policyholders and other creditors by ensuring a fair and transparent assessment of the company's financial position.

The receiver will identify and evaluate all of the company's assets, including any property, investments, and outstanding payments owed to the company. They will also assess the company's liabilities, which are the debts and obligations that the company owes to creditors, policyholders, and other parties. This comprehensive review enables the receiver to develop an accurate picture of the company's financial situation and determine the best course of action for liquidation and distribution of assets.

The receiver plays a vital role in ensuring a fair and equitable outcome for all stakeholders. Their expertise in accounting and financial matters helps to maximise the value of the company's assets and facilitates a transparent distribution process. By overseeing the accounting of assets and liabilities, the receiver acts as a neutral party, protecting the rights and interests of all involved.

Guaranty associations protect policyholders of an insolvent insurance company

Guaranty associations are state-sanctioned organizations that protect policyholders and claimants in the event of an insurance company's impairment or insolvency. They are legal entities whose members make guarantees and provide a mechanism to resolve claims. All US states have a guaranty association, and they are created to protect policyholders of an insolvent insurance company.

State insurance commissioners are tasked with reviewing the financial health of insurance companies operating in their state. If one becomes insolvent, the commissioner must act as the estate administrator. The commissioner has the responsibility to determine when an insurance company should be declared insolvent and to seek authority from the state court to seize its assets and operate the company pending rehabilitation or liquidation.

When an insurance company is deemed insolvent, the guaranty association provides coverage to the company's policyholders who are state residents, up to levels specified by state laws. While laws governing maximum limits and types of policies covered vary from state to state, most states follow the NAIC Model Act and provide coverage in specified amounts. For example, most states offer at least the following amounts of coverage:

• $300,000 in life insurance death benefits
• $100,000 in net cash surrender or withdrawal values for life insurance
• $250,000 in the present value of annuity benefits, including cash surrender and withdrawal values
• $500,000 in medical, hospital, and surgical policy benefits
• $300,000 in long-term care insurance benefits
• $300,000 in disability income insurance benefits
• $100,000 for coverages not defined as DI insurance, health benefit plans, or LTC insurance

The guaranty association's coverage of insurance company insolvencies is funded by post-insolvency assessments of the other guaranty association member companies. These assessments are typically based on each member's share of premiums during the prior three years. In some states, the assessed insurers are granted an offset on state premium taxes to recover a portion of the assessment over time.

In the event of an insolvent insurance company, guaranty associations play a crucial role in protecting policyholders by ensuring their claims are covered and providing continued protection for policyholders affected by insurance company insolvency.

Frequently asked questions