Insurance Churning: Why Do People Do It?

Insurance churning is a term used to refer to the rate at which customers stop doing business with an insurance company, either by switching to a competitor or by dropping their insurance altogether. Churning can occur for a variety of reasons, such as changes in job status, family composition, or income. It can also happen when customers sell assets, or when insurance companies charge uncompetitive rates. Another form of churning is when insurance agents replace a policyholder's insurance policy with a new one, often without consulting the customer and with no changes to the coverage, in order to secure an additional commission for themselves. This type of churning is illegal in most states and is considered a form of misconduct.

Insurance agents churn to secure additional commissions

Churning in the insurance industry is a practice where insurance agents replace a policyholder's insurance policy with another, usually without consulting the policyholder and with no changes to the coverage. Insurance agents who churn are motivated by the desire to secure additional commissions for the new policy they swap in. This is often done without the customer's consent and brings no benefit to the insured, making it an illegal and unethical practice.

The commission on insurance policies varies depending on the type of insurance and the structure set by the carrier. Life insurance policies, for example, typically offer a high commission upfront, with the commission on renewals being significantly lower. Health insurance producers follow a similar structure, with higher commissions in the early years that generally expire after about three years. On the other hand, property and casualty insurance policies have shorter lifespans, resulting in lower commissions on both new business and renewals.

The commission structure for insurance agents can be complex, with multiple carriers and products, each with its own commission rates and structures. Additionally, agencies vary in size and structure, which can further influence the commission an agent receives. For example, smaller agencies tend to have more complex commission calculations, allowing for informal partnerships and adjustments that result in varying commission percentages. In contrast, larger agencies usually maintain a more consistent commission structure.

The practice of churning allows insurance agents to take advantage of the high upfront commissions offered by certain insurance products, particularly those with long-term policies such as life insurance. By replacing an existing policy with a new one, the agent can earn a substantial commission on the new policy, even if there are no significant changes to the coverage. This additional commission serves as a financial incentive for agents to engage in churning, despite it being an unethical and illegal practice in most states.

To prevent churning, insurance companies have implemented measures such as requiring agents to inform policyholders of any policy changes and providing clear and official documentation of modifications. By ensuring that policyholders are aware of any changes to their insurance coverage, insurance companies aim to deter agents from engaging in churning practices that are solely for the agent's financial gain.

Churning is illegal when done without customer consent and no benefit to the insured

Churning in the insurance industry is a broad term that can refer to the rate of customers leaving an insurance company, or it can describe a form of misconduct by insurance agents. In the context of misconduct, churning occurs when an insurance agent replaces a policyholder's insurance policy with another, usually without consulting the policyholder, and with no changes to the coverage.

Churning is illegal and unethical when done without the customer's consent and no benefit to the insured. Insurance agents are fiduciaries, meaning they are responsible for acting on behalf of their clients and placing their interests above their own. Churning is considered misconduct when the sole purpose of replacing the policy is to enrich the agent by securing an additional commission. This practice is often difficult to spot and prove, but it can result in substantial losses for the client.

To prevent churning, insurance companies require agents to inform the insured of any policy changes and provide clear and official documentation of modifications. Additionally, most states have laws that punish agents who engage in churning. Investors can also play an active role in decision-making regarding their portfolios to avoid churning.

Churning can also occur in the form of fee churning, where a series of intermediaries take commissions through reinsurance agreements, reducing the initial premium until there is no money left to pay claims. This type of churning is a form of insurance fraud, which costs the average U.S. family between $400 and $700 per year in increased premiums.

Fee churning involves intermediaries taking commissions through reinsurance agreements

Fee churning is a type of insurance fraud that involves intermediaries taking multiple commissions through reinsurance agreements. This is a complex scam that can be difficult for prosecutors to prove. It involves a series of intermediaries taking commissions each time a new policy is purchased for a client, reducing the premium until there is no money left to pay claims. The company left to pay the claims is often a business set up by the conspirators to fail.

In a simple churning scam, an insurer will periodically re-buy a new insurance policy for a client, without the client's knowledge or consent. The agent will be authorised to purchase coverage for the client and will do so repeatedly to earn a commission. The new policy may have higher premiums and less coverage or benefits than the previous policy, and the agent will be enriched at the policyholder's expense.

Churning is illegal in most states and is considered unethical. It is also hard to spot, as an investor may only realise they are a victim when they receive notifications of transactions on a daily or weekly basis. To prevent churning, investors should keep an eye on their account, read transaction notices, and review monthly statements to check how much they are paying in commissions.

Churning can be prevented by requiring agents to inform the insured of any policy changes

Churning is an illegal and unethical practice in the insurance industry. It involves an insurance agent replacing a policyholder's insurance policy with another, usually without consulting the policyholder and with no changes to the coverage. Agents who engage in churning do so to secure an additional commission for the new policy. This practice is illegal when conducted without the customer's consent and when it brings no benefit to the insured.

In addition to requiring agent disclosure, insurance companies can implement exchange and replacement rules that allow policyholders to compare new policies with their current coverage. These rules highlight surrender penalties, fees, and other relevant information. Policyholders can then make informed decisions about whether to switch policies, reducing the likelihood of churning.

Furthermore, policyholders can play an active role in preventing churning by maintaining full control over their accounts. They can require their permission to be obtained for any changes to their policies. This ensures that agents cannot make unilateral decisions that may be motivated by personal gain rather than the client's best interests.

Another way to prevent churning is to use a fee-based account, also known as a wrap account. In this type of account, a quarterly or annual fee is charged, typically ranging from 1% to 3% of the assets under management. This eliminates the incentive for churning, as the focus shifts from generating commissions through excessive trading to providing value-added services that justify the flat fee.

By implementing these measures, such as requiring agent disclosure, instituting exchange and replacement rules, encouraging policyholder involvement, and offering fee-based accounts, insurance companies can effectively deter churning and protect the interests of their clients.

Churning can affect the quality, cost, and continuity of care

Churning in the insurance industry is when an insurance agent replaces a policyholder's insurance policy with another, usually without consulting the policyholder and with no changes to the coverage. This is done to secure an additional commission for the new policy. Churning can affect the quality, cost, and continuity of care in several ways.

Firstly, individuals may avoid seeking necessary healthcare during gaps in insurance coverage caused by churning. Even if consumers maintain continuous coverage while transitioning between plans, their regular healthcare providers may not accept the new insurance plan. This can lead to disruptions in accessing care and force individuals to seek alternative providers, potentially affecting the quality of care they receive.

Secondly, research shows that medication compliance is often disrupted when individuals change health plans due to churning. This can have negative consequences for individuals' health, particularly if they are unable to afford the new copays or deductibles associated with their medication.

Thirdly, churning can lead to increased costs for individuals. Uncertainty about new copays, deductibles, and known increased costs associated with new insurance plans can create financial barriers to accessing healthcare. Additionally, churning may result in higher out-of-pocket expenses for individuals, impacting their ability to afford necessary treatments or medications.

Finally, churning can disrupt the continuity of care by interrupting the relationship between patients and their healthcare providers. This can be especially detrimental for individuals with complex or chronic health conditions who require ongoing care and treatment.

Overall, churning can have significant negative consequences on the quality, cost, and continuity of care for individuals, highlighting the importance of stable insurance coverage and ethical practices in the insurance industry.

Frequently asked questions