The Legal Conundrum Of Insurance Balance Billing: Understanding The Fine Print

Balance billing is the process of a healthcare provider billing a patient for the difference between the provider's charge and the amount allowed by the insurance company. In some states, balance billing is illegal, and in others, it is not. It is generally illegal when the patient has Medicare or Medicaid and the healthcare provider accepts Medicare or Medicaid assignment. It is also illegal if the healthcare provider has a contract with the patient's health plan but bills the patient for more than the contract allows. Balance billing is usually legal when the patient chooses to use a healthcare provider that does not have a relationship with their insurer.

Balance billing is illegal when you have Medicare or Medicaid and your healthcare provider accepts this

Balance billing is when a healthcare provider bills a patient for the difference between the provider's charge and the amount allowed by the insurance company based on the patient's policy. In other words, it is the additional bill that an out-of-network medical provider can send to a patient, on top of their normal cost-sharing and the payments made by their health plan.

Balance billing is generally considered illegal in the following circumstances:

• When you have Medicare and your healthcare provider accepts Medicare assignment. In this case, the healthcare provider must agree to accept the Medicare-negotiated rate, including your deductible and/or coinsurance payment, as payment in full. This is called accepting Medicare assignment.
• When you have Medicaid and your healthcare provider has an agreement with Medicaid. Medicaid providers are not allowed to balance bill patients for any amount beyond what is covered by Medicaid.
• When your healthcare provider or hospital has a contract with your health plan but still bills you more than that contract allows. In this case, the provider is violating the terms of their contract with your insurer.

It is important to note that balance billing laws vary from state to state, and there may be additional protections in certain states or under specific health plans. However, the information provided above applies generally when you have Medicare or Medicaid and your healthcare provider accepts this insurance.

Balance billing is illegal if your healthcare provider has a contract with your health plan but bills you more than the contract allows

Balance billing is when a healthcare provider bills a patient for the difference between the provider's charge and the amount allowed by the insurance company based on the patient's policy. This is a common occurrence when visiting out-of-network providers, who are not subject to the terms and rates set by in-network providers. However, balance billing is illegal in certain situations.

Balance billing is generally illegal when:

• You have Medicare and your healthcare provider accepts Medicare assignment.
• You have Medicaid and your healthcare provider has an agreement with Medicaid.
• Your healthcare provider has a contract with your health plan but bills you more than the contract allows.
• You go to an in-network hospital but unknowingly receive services from an out-of-network provider in an emergency (with the exception of ground ambulance charges).

In the first three cases, the agreement between the healthcare provider and Medicare, Medicaid, or your insurance company includes a clause that prohibits balance billing. The provider has agreed to accept the negotiated rates as payment in full, including any applicable deductible, coinsurance, or copay.

For example, when a hospital signs up with Medicare to see Medicare patients, it must agree to accept the Medicare negotiated rate as payment in full. This is known as accepting Medicare assignment.

In the case of a healthcare provider having a contract with your health plan, balance billing is illegal if they bill you more than what the contract allows. This means that the provider is violating the terms of their contract and can face legal consequences.

To determine whether balance billing is legal in your specific situation, it is important to review the balance billing laws in your state of residence and understand the details of your insurance plan.

Balance billing is generally legal when you use an out-of-network provider

Balance billing is a practice where a healthcare provider bills a patient for the difference between their charge and the amount paid by the patient's insurer or applied to the patient's deductible, coinsurance, or copay.

In contrast, in-network providers have agreed to accept the insurance plan's negotiated fees as payment in full, plus any applicable deductible, coinsurance, or copay. Balance billing is not permitted under an in-network agreement, and the provider must adjust off the remaining balance.

It's important to note that "surprise" balance billing is a specific type of balance billing that occurs when patients seek care at an in-network facility but are unknowingly treated by one or more out-of-network providers. This can result in unexpected and costly bills for patients, especially if their insurance doesn't cover out-of-network care.

To address this issue, the No Surprises Act was implemented in 2022 to protect consumers from surprise balance billing in emergency situations and when receiving services from out-of-network providers at in-network facilities. However, ground ambulance charges are not included in this legislation.

Balance billing is usually legal when you get services not covered by your insurance policy

Balance billing is a practice where a healthcare provider bills a patient for the difference between their charge and the amount covered by the patient's insurance. This can occur when a patient's insurance company has paid everything it is obliged to pay, but there is still an outstanding balance on the bill.

For example, if you obtain cosmetic procedures that are not considered medically necessary, or fill a prescription for a drug that isn't on your health plan's formulary, you will be responsible for the entire bill. Your insurer will not require the medical provider to write off any portion of the bill—the claim would simply be rejected.

Balance billing is generally illegal in the following situations:

• When you have Medicare and you are using a healthcare provider that accepts Medicare assignment.
• When you have Medicaid and your healthcare provider has an agreement with Medicaid.
• When your healthcare provider or hospital has a contract with your health plan but is billing you more than that contract allows.
• In emergencies (with the exception of ground ambulance charges), or when you go to an in-network hospital but unknowingly receive services from an out-of-network provider.

The No Surprises Act, which took effect in 2022, protects consumers from surprise balance billing

The No Surprises Act, which came into effect in 2022, offers robust consumer protection against surprise balance billing. The Act, which was incorporated into the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, was passed with bipartisan support and signed into law by President Trump in December 2020. It protects consumers from surprise billing in private insurance for most emergency care and many instances of non-emergency care.

The No Surprises Act holds consumers harmless from the cost of unanticipated out-of-network medical bills. It applies to all emergency services, including those provided in hospital emergency rooms, freestanding emergency departments, and urgent care centres licensed to provide emergency care. It also covers air ambulance transportation (both emergency and non-emergency), but not ground ambulance services.

The Act also applies to non-emergency services provided at in-network facilities by out-of-network providers. This includes treatment, equipment, devices, telemedicine services, imaging and lab services, and preoperative and postoperative services.

Under the Act, out-of-network providers cannot send a patient a surprise balance bill for emergency treatment or for out-of-network care provided at an in-network hospital. Instead, the patient can only be charged their regular in-network cost-sharing amounts. Health plan ID cards must display the plan's in-network deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, making this information readily available.

The No Surprises Act establishes an independent dispute resolution (IDR) process for payment disputes between plans and providers. It also provides new dispute resolution opportunities for uninsured and self-pay individuals when they receive a medical bill that is significantly greater than the good faith estimate they were given.

The Act also requires that health care providers and facilities give patients an easy-to-understand notice explaining the applicable billing protections and who to contact if they believe their rights have been violated.

The No Surprises Act is a significant piece of legislation that provides much-needed protection for consumers from surprise balance billing. It is a complex law that sets coverage and billing standards for a specific subset of private insurance claims, estimated at around 10 million annually.

Frequently asked questions