Life Insurance Vs Annuities: Why Underwriters Prefer Insurance

Life insurance and annuities are both financial products offered by life insurance companies, but they are very different in how they are taxed and how they pay policyholders. Life insurance policies protect your family's financial well-being in the event of your death, while annuities provide a pension-like stream of income to fund your retirement. Life insurance policies require a rigorous underwriting process that involves medical testing and a review of your medical history, while annuities do not. This means that not everyone can qualify for life insurance, but almost anyone can buy an annuity.

Life insurance requires underwriting and medical testing, annuities don't

Life insurance and annuities are two different financial products offered by life insurance companies. While they are both based on and priced according to your life expectancy, they are designed to meet different needs. Life insurance policies protect your family's financial well-being in the event of your death, whereas annuities provide a pension-like stream of income to fund your retirement.

Life insurance policies require underwriting and medical testing, whereas annuities do not. Underwriting is the process of evaluating the risk that the insurance company would take on by approving an applicant for a particular policy. It helps the insurer determine if the risk of the insured needing to make a claim soon after the policy is issued is low enough not to adversely affect their risk pool. The underwriting process for life insurance involves a wide range of data points, including personal information such as gender, age, occupation, lifestyle, hobbies, and motor vehicle reports, as well as individual and family medical history, current health conditions, smoking habits, and financial information. The underwriting process can take anywhere from 24 hours to 4-6 weeks, depending on the complexity of the policy.

The purpose of the underwriting and medical testing in life insurance is to assess the risk associated with insuring the applicant and to determine the terms of the policy, including the amount of coverage and the monthly premium. The insurance company will consider the applicant's health history and lifestyle information to establish their life expectancy and insurance risk class. For example, applicants with excellent health, an ideal height-to-weight ratio, and a clean family history may qualify for the most favourable policy terms, known as "Preferred Plus".

In contrast, annuities do not require health underwriting, and anyone with the financial means can purchase one. Annuities are considered ""guaranteed issue", meaning that no underwriting is involved, and they are available to almost anyone. While there is a type of annuity called a "Rated Single Premium Immediate Annuity" that requires underwriting and carrier approval for a higher payout, it represents a very small portion of the annuity market.

Life insurance offers a tax-free death benefit, annuities don't

Life insurance and annuities are two different financial products, and it is important to understand their differences to make an informed decision. While both are offered by life insurance companies, they address unique needs and goals. Life insurance policies protect your family or loved ones' financial well-being in the event of your death, whereas annuities provide a pension-like stream of income to fund your retirement.

Life insurance policies offer a death benefit, which is a payout to the beneficiary/beneficiaries listed on the policy when the insured person dies. This death benefit is typically not subject to income tax, and the beneficiaries receive the benefit as a lump-sum payment. The amount of the death benefit is chosen by the policyholder, who makes regular premium payments. The younger and healthier the insured person is, the lower the premium payments will be.

On the other hand, annuities do not offer the same tax benefit on death benefits. Annuity death benefits are included as part of the estate from a taxation standpoint and are not passed on to beneficiaries tax-free. The beneficiaries of an annuity with a death benefit may have to pay income tax on the payments received. The tax treatment of annuity death benefits depends on the type of annuity, the age of the annuitant at the time of death, and other factors. For example, with "non-qualified annuities" (those purchased with after-tax dollars), beneficiaries only pay taxes on the annuity earnings, while with "qualified annuities" (purchased with pre-tax dollars), the death benefit is typically taxed as ordinary income or via inheritance taxes.

The difference in tax treatment of death benefits is a significant distinction between life insurance and annuities. Life insurance provides peace of mind that your loved ones will receive financial support after your death without the burden of additional taxes. This makes life insurance an attractive option for those who want to ensure their loved ones are financially protected.

Life insurance protects your family after you die, annuities provide retirement income

Life insurance and annuities are both financial products offered by life insurance companies. However, they are designed for different purposes and operate differently.

Life insurance is designed to protect your family or loved ones financially after you die. It provides a death benefit that is paid out to your beneficiaries, which can be received as a lump sum or as regular payments. This death benefit is typically tax-free, meaning your beneficiaries receive the full amount. To obtain life insurance, you usually need to go through an underwriting process that involves medical testing and a review of your medical history. This means not everyone qualifies for life insurance.

On the other hand, annuities are designed to provide a retirement income. They are a type of contract between you and an insurance company, where you pay a lump sum or make regular payments over time. The insurance company then invests this money, and you receive payouts based on the performance of the investments. Annuities can provide a steady stream of income for a set period or your entire lifetime, helping you avoid the risk of outliving your money. Annuities are typically tax-deferred, meaning you only pay taxes when you start receiving payouts. This provides opportunities for higher gains and is similar to how a 401(k) works. While annuities can also pay money to your beneficiaries when you die, it is not tax-free.

In summary, the key difference is that life insurance protects your family after your death, while annuities provide income during your retirement. Life insurance is, therefore, more focused on providing financial security for your loved ones, whereas annuities are more focused on ensuring you have a stable income stream during your retirement years.

Life insurance offers early access to your money, annuities have withdrawal penalties

Life insurance and annuities are two different financial products that are often confused with each other. They are both issued by life insurance companies and are based on your life expectancy, but they serve different purposes. Life insurance policies protect your family's financial well-being in the event of your death, while annuities provide a pension-like stream of income to fund your retirement.

Life insurance policies offer early access to your money without withdrawal penalties. This means that the beneficiaries listed on the policy can receive the death benefit without any restrictions. The death benefit from life insurance is also tax-free, which is a significant advantage over annuities.

On the other hand, annuities come with withdrawal penalties if you access your money early. Annuities are designed to provide long-term retirement income, and both the government and insurance companies encourage keeping funds in annuities for the long term by imposing high costs for early or frequent withdrawals. These withdrawal penalties can vary depending on the contract and the specific circumstances of the withdrawal.

The insurance company issuing the annuity typically assesses surrender charges or stiff penalties for withdrawing money before the surrender period ends. These surrender fees can be as high as 7% of the withdrawal amount, but they decrease the longer you hold the annuity. Additionally, if you are under the age of 59 ½, the federal government imposes a 10% penalty tax on early withdrawals, along with income tax on the earnings. However, it's important to note that some annuities offer penalty-free withdrawal provisions, and certain contracts include crisis waivers for special situations, such as nursing home confinement or terminal illness.

Life insurance is better for creating an inheritance, annuities offer better investment returns

Life insurance and annuities are two different financial products that are often confused with one another. While both are offered by life insurance companies, they address unique needs and operate differently.

Life insurance is primarily used to protect your family's financial well-being in the event of your death. It is an effective estate planning tool, as it offers a substantial death benefit that is paid to your loved ones when you pass away. This death benefit is typically tax-free, providing an income-tax-free source of protection for your family's financial well-being. Life insurance also offers living benefits, such as the ability to withdraw premiums tax-free and borrow against the cash value of the policy. Additionally, permanent life insurance policies provide lifelong coverage and enable policyholders to build a cash reserve.

On the other hand, annuities are designed to provide a steady stream of income during your retirement or at any other specified time. They are a form of "longevity insurance," helping to protect your financial well-being by providing pension-like payments. Annuities offer better investment returns than life insurance, as all the money is put toward an investment. They also offer more income options, such as guaranteed income for life. However, early withdrawals from annuities may be restricted and can incur surrender fees and tax implications.

In summary, life insurance is better for creating an inheritance, as it provides a substantial and tax-free death benefit for your heirs. Annuities, on the other hand, offer better investment returns and income options during your lifetime, making them a good choice for retirement planning. When deciding between life insurance and annuities, it is important to consider your specific financial goals and consult with a financial professional.

Frequently asked questions