The Compensation Conundrum: Unraveling The Truth About Insurance Adjuster Commissions

The pay structure of insurance adjusters varies widely depending on the company and the type of claim settlement. Most inside adjusters, who work for insurance companies, are salaried and do not earn commissions. However, independent claims adjusters are usually paid on a per-claim basis and may earn a percentage of the claims settled.

The average salary for an insurance claims adjuster is around $60,000 to $73,000 per year, but this can range from $46,000 to over $100,000. Independent adjusters typically earn between 50% and 70% of the fee bill, with the rest going to the IA firm. During catastrophes, adjusters may be paid according to a fee schedule, which can result in higher earnings. For example, during the 2017 hurricane season, adjusters made $65,000 to $100,000 in a month.

While the job can be lucrative, it is also demanding and stressful, with a high workload and pressure to handle claims quickly.

Insurance adjusters' salaries vary, from $46k to $84k per year

Insurance adjusters' salaries vary depending on factors such as location, job description, experience, and type of employment. The average base salary for an insurance claims adjuster in the United States is around $60,000 per year, but salaries can range from $46,000 to $84,000 or more.

The type of adjuster also affects earnings. Staff adjusters, who are employees of an insurance carrier, typically earn less than independent claims adjusters, who are independent contractors working for adjusting firms. Staff adjusters' salaries usually range from $40,000 to $70,000, while independent adjusters can earn over $100,000 in a good year, especially when handling catastrophe claims.

Independent adjusters are usually paid according to a fee schedule, which is a commission-based payment system where they receive a percentage of the total dollar amount of a claim settled. They may also be paid by the hour or on a daily rate. During catastrophes, when adjusters are deployed to major disasters and work long hours, their income can exceed $100,000 per year.

While insurance adjusting can be lucrative, it is important to note that salaries can vary widely, and work can be scarce during "dry" spells for independent adjusters. Additionally, the workload and stress levels can be high, and salary may not always compensate for this.

Staff adjusters are salaried employees, independent adjusters are contractors

Staff adjusters are typically salaried employees of an insurance carrier. They are permanent employees of an insurance company, handling claims exclusively for that company. They are full-time employees who investigate, evaluate, and settle claims. Staff adjusters are generally paid a fixed compensation, irrespective of the number of cases they handle. They often receive standard employment benefits like insurance, vacation and sick leave, and company equipment.

Independent adjusters, on the other hand, are independent contractors who work for adjusting firms. They are hired on a contract basis by an insurance company and often work for multiple insurance providers. They are typically paid on a per-claim basis, receiving compensation through a set daily rate or a percentage of the claim settlement amount. During catastrophes, they are usually paid according to a fee schedule, which is a commission-based payment system. Independent adjusters have the freedom to work when and where they choose and are responsible for their own expenses.

Staff adjusters earn less, but get benefits like insurance and vacation

Staff adjusters are salaried employees of insurance companies. They are typically not licensed but are registered by the insurance company. They are typically paid a fixed compensation, irrespective of the number of cases they handle. Staff adjusters earn less than independent adjusters, with salaries ranging from $40,000 to $70,000. However, they enjoy benefits such as insurance, vacation and sick leave, and company equipment.

Staff adjusters are responsible for investigating, evaluating, and settling insurance claims. They are evaluated based on the number of claims settled within a given period, usually monthly. While they have a financial limit on the amount they can award to the insured, this limit is often undisclosed and increases with experience. Staff adjusters play a crucial role in the claims negotiation process, working to find a fair settlement for both the insured and the insurance company.

While staff adjusters earn less than independent adjusters, their salaries can still vary depending on experience and the company they work for. For example, some companies offer salaries starting at $25,000, while others offer starting salaries of around $50,000. Additionally, staff adjusters may have the opportunity to advance within the company and take on managerial roles, which can lead to higher salaries.

Overall, while staff adjusters may not have the same earning potential as independent adjusters, they benefit from job security, stable salaries, and comprehensive benefits packages that provide valuable support and peace of mind.

Independent adjusters can make over $100k in a good year, working catastrophes

Independent insurance adjusters are paid in a few different ways but almost always split the fee bill with the IA Firm. This means they split the money made from handling the claim with the IA firm, with the adjuster usually making between 50% and 70% of the amount billed to the insurance company. During catastrophes, adjusters are usually paid according to a fee schedule basis.

During the peak of the 2017 hurricane season, independent adjusters were making $65,000 to $100,000 in one month. A good adjuster should be closing 2 to 4 claims per day, and a superb adjuster closes 4 to 7. With $400 earned per claim, and up to 7 claims settled per day, independent adjusters working catastrophe claims commonly earn more than $1,000 per day, and sometimes a lot more.

Hurricane adjusters can easily average a $10,000 settlement per claim, which would put between $400 and $500 in the adjuster's pocket per claim. An independent adjuster handling hurricane claims may receive a fee schedule that pays $500 for claims between $3,000 to $5,000, $650 for claims between $5,000 and $7,500, and $750 for claims between $7,500 and $10,000.

The bottom line is that a good independent adjuster can reach a six-figure income in less than six months. However, it takes a lot of hard work. During catastrophes, adjusters are deployed to hard-hit areas and can often be there for months working 7 days a week, 10 to 14 hours a day.

Independent adjusters working catastrophe claims have the potential to earn over $100,000 in a year. If the adjuster is licensed to operate in multiple states and multiple natural disasters occur within their domain, the independent adjuster could earn well over $100,000 annually.

Independent adjusters are paid by claim, staff adjusters are not

There are two types of insurance adjusters: staff adjusters and independent adjusters. Staff adjusters are typically salaried employees of an insurance carrier, whereas independent adjusters are independent contractors working for adjusting firms. This fundamental difference affects both pay structure and the type of claims handled.

Staff adjusters are usually paid a fixed salary, irrespective of the number of cases they handle. They are also often provided with standard employment benefits like insurance, vacation and sick leave, and company equipment. Their work is steadier, but the income may be lower than that of an independent adjuster.

Independent adjusters, on the other hand, are typically paid by the claim. They may earn a percentage of the claims settled, depending on the nature of the claim. During catastrophes, independent adjusters are usually paid according to a fee schedule, which varies widely between insurance companies and adjusting firms. The fee schedule is essentially a commission-based payment system, where the adjuster's earnings increase with the total dollar amount of a claim.

For example, an independent adjuster handling hurricane claims may receive a fee schedule that pays $500 for claims between $3,000 to $5,000, $650 for claims between $5,000 and $7,500, and $750 for claims between $7,500 and $10,000. The adjuster will receive between 50-70% of the fee, with the rest going to the adjusting firm.

In addition to the fee schedule, independent adjusters may also be paid on a "time and expense" basis for large losses or complex claims. They keep track of the time spent on the claims process and submit their hours and expenses to the adjusting firm. The hourly rate can vary from $65 to $95 per hour.

While staff adjusters have more stable and predictable income, independent adjusters have the potential to earn much higher incomes, especially during catastrophes or when handling a high volume of claims. However, independent adjusters also have more unpredictable work schedules and may have to work long hours during deployments to handle the influx of claims.

Frequently asked questions