Life Insurance: Comdex's Comprehensive List

Comdex is a composite index that averages the financial ratings of various insurance companies and produces an average score based on how multiple financial agencies rate each company. It is put together by Ebix, which operates more than 50 offices worldwide. Comdex scores are assigned on a 1 to 100 basis, with those at the top being the strongest financially. To receive a Comdex ranking, an insurance company needs ratings from at least two of the following four agencies: Moody's Investors Service, A.M. Best, Standard & Poor's, and Fitch.

How is the Comdex calculated?

The Comdex score is a composite index that averages the financial ratings of various insurance companies and produces an average score based on how multiple financial agencies rate each company. It is put together by Ebix, which is traded on the NASDAQ Global Market under the EBIX symbol.

Ebix builds software infrastructure for the healthcare, financial, and insurance industries. Through the EbixExchange, insurance agents and other service providers can access everything from CRM software to order-entry platforms to risk assessment solutions.

The Comdex score is calculated by taking the average percentile ranking for all of the ratings received by an insurance carrier. It is not a rating in and of itself, but rather an objective scale to compare different companies. The Comdex score is based on the ratings issued by the following rating services:

• Moody's Investors Services
• A.M. Best
• Standard & Poor's
• Fitch
• Weiss

To calculate the Comdex, the percentiles for each rating service are determined. This is done by counting the total number of companies rated by the service and then counting the number of companies in each rating category. For example, let's take a sample rating service and calculate the percentiles. If the rating service assigns ratings in five categories (A, B, C, D, and E) and has rated a total of 50 companies, the percentiles would be calculated as follows:

• A: 20% (10/50)
• B: 40% (20/50)
• C: 60% (30/50)
• D: 80% (40/50)
• E: 100% (50/50)

This process is repeated to construct a table of percentiles for each of the rating services. Using these tables, the Comdex for a given company can be calculated. Each rating that the company has received is looked up in the table for that rating service, and then the percentiles are averaged to give the Comdex. A company must have at least two ratings for the Comdex to be calculated.

For example, suppose an insurance company has an AA rating from Agency 1 and an A+ rating from Agency 2. If the AA rating corresponds to the 90th percentile of the companies rated by Agency 1 and the A+ rating corresponds to the 80th percentile of the companies rated by Agency 2, the Comdex would be 85 (the average of 90 and 80).

It is important to note that the Comdex score can be based on ratings that are up to two weeks old, and it does not take into account recent upgrades or downgrades. Additionally, the Comdex score ignores the dispersion of the ratings, treating a company with a consensus of ratings at the same percentile as a company with varying assessments at different percentiles.

What is the Comdex scale?

The Comdex scale is a composite score that averages the ratings of the major insurance rating organisations, including AM Best, Fitch, Moody's, and S&P. It is not a rating in itself, but a ranking based on the average of all the ratings given to an insurance company. The Comdex scale ranges from 1 to 100, with higher scores indicating better financial strength.

The Comdex scale is useful for insurance customers and companies as it measures an insurance company's financial strength and overall financial performance. It is calculated by taking the average of the percentiles for each rating agency, and then placing the insurance company on a single, 100-point scale. This percentile ranking indicates how the company's overall ranking compares to other private insurance rating companies. For example, a Comdex score of 85 means the insurer is in the top 15th percentile and is rated superior to 84% of insurance companies.

The Comdex scale is calculated by EbixExchange and is available to subscribers of their VitalSigns service. It is designed to address the difficulty of interpreting the ratings issued by the major agencies, which use different scales. For instance, an insurance company with an AA rating from one agency and an A+ rating from another agency may be difficult to compare. By averaging the ratings and placing them on a single scale, the Comdex scale provides a simpler way to compare insurance companies.

However, it is important to note that the Comdex scale is based on ratings that may be up to two weeks old, and it does not take into account recent upgrades or downgrades. Additionally, it treats a consensus of four ratings at the 80th percentile the same as four wildly different assessments at varying percentiles. Therefore, while the Comdex scale offers a snapshot of an insurance company's financial strength, it should not be the only factor considered when evaluating insurance companies.

How do credit ratings work?

Credit ratings are an independent assessment of a corporation or government's ability to repay a debt. Credit scores, on the other hand, are assigned to individuals based on their personal history of acquiring and repaying debt.

Credit scores are calculated by credit scoring models, which analyse a consumer's credit report from one of the three major consumer credit bureaus: Experian, TransUnion, or Equifax. These scoring models are designed to predict the likelihood that someone will miss a payment within the next 24 months.

Credit scores typically range from 300 to 850, with a higher score indicating that a person is less likely to fall behind on bill payments. The score does not correlate with a specific likelihood of missing a payment but instead acts as a ranking system to list consumers from most to least risky.

• Payment history (35% of the score): This includes whether an individual has made payments on time and how many bills have been paid late or sent out for collection.
• Amounts owed (30%): This takes into account the relative scale of current debt, including credit card debt and loans. Lenders prefer to see a debt-to-credit ratio below 30%.
• Length of credit history (15%): The longer an individual has had established credit, the better it is for their credit score. This includes the age of the oldest and newest accounts and the average age of all credit accounts.
• New credit (10%): Opening too many accounts within a short time frame can negatively impact the score as it may indicate financial distress.
• Credit mix (10%): This refers to the different types of credit accounts an individual has, such as mortgages, car loans, credit loans, and store charge cards.

While the exact formula for calculating a credit score is proprietary information, the above factors are used to determine an individual's creditworthiness and ability to repay debts.

It is important to note that credit scores can impact various aspects of an individual's life, including loan approvals, interest rates, housing applications, and even insurance rates. Therefore, understanding how credit scores work and taking steps to improve one's credit score can be beneficial.

What are the benefits of the Comdex?

The Comdex rating is a composite index that averages the financial ratings of various insurance companies, producing a score based on how multiple financial agencies rate each company. It is put together by Ebix, which is traded on the NASDAQ Global Market under the EBIX symbol. The Comdex score combines all of an insurance company's ratings into a single numerical score, making it easier to compare insurance companies' financial strength.

The Comdex score is calculated by taking the average of the ratings from four major credit rating agencies: A.M. Best, Moody's, Fitch, and Standard & Poor's. These agencies assess a company's financial performance, management, business portfolio, and claims-paying ability. The Comdex score then puts each company on a single 100-point scale, with the higher the score, the stronger the company's financial position.

The benefits of the Comdex rating are that it provides a simple and comparable score for consumers to evaluate insurance companies' financial strength. It saves time and provides a snapshot of a company's financial position without having to review and compare multiple ratings from different agencies. The Comdex score also helps to standardise the ratings, as an "A" rating from one agency may not be equivalent to an "A" from another.

The Comdex score is a useful tool for consumers to assess and compare insurance companies' financial strength and make more informed decisions when purchasing insurance products. However, it is important to also consider other factors such as customer satisfaction, products offered, and cost when choosing an insurance provider.

What are the limitations of the Comdex?

The Comdex rating system is a useful tool for those looking to purchase life insurance, as it allows consumers to compare insurance companies by taking the average of their ratings from four major credit rating agencies: A.M. Best, Moody's, Fitch, and Standard & Poor's. However, there are some limitations to the Comdex rating system that consumers should be aware of.

Firstly, it is important to note that not all insurance companies have ratings from all four agencies. A company needs at least two ratings from the major agencies to receive a Comdex score. This means that the Comdex score may be based on incomplete data, as it is possible that a company has chosen not to seek ratings from certain agencies. This could impact the accuracy of the Comdex score and ranking.

Secondly, the Comdex score is based on a simple average of the ratings from the four agencies. However, as each agency uses its own rating scale and criteria, the Comdex score may not always provide a true picture of a company's financial health and stability. For example, an "A" rating from one agency may not be equivalent to an "A" rating from another agency. Therefore, consumers should also consider the individual ratings from each agency and not rely solely on the Comdex score.

Thirdly, the Comdex score is updated frequently, especially for larger and more popular insurance companies. However, there may be a time lag between changes in a company's financial health and the Comdex score being updated to reflect those changes. Consumers should, therefore, check that the Comdex score is based on the most recent data available.

Finally, the Comdex score is just one factor to consider when choosing a life insurance company. Consumers should also look at the company's history, customer reviews, products offered, and other factors to make an informed decision. It is important to remember that the Comdex score is not a guarantee of a company's ability to meet its financial obligations or pay out claims.

Frequently asked questions