Overpricing: Insurance Fraud Or Simple Mistake?

Insurance fraud is a deliberate deception by an insurance company, agent, adjuster, or consumer to obtain illegitimate financial gain. It can occur during the buying, using, selling, or underwriting of insurance. Overpricing falls under the category of soft fraud, which is a crime of opportunity and a common type of insurance fraud. Soft fraud occurs when a policyholder exaggerates an otherwise legitimate claim or intentionally lies or omits information on an application to obtain a lower premium. Soft fraud is a criminal offence and can result in fines, jail time, probation, or community service.

Overpricing as a form of premium fraud

Overpricing, or charging an excessive price for goods or services, can be considered a form of premium fraud when it involves the deliberate misrepresentation of costs or values to an insurance company. Premium fraud is a type of insurance fraud that occurs when individuals or entities provide false or misleading information to obtain lower insurance premiums. This can take several forms, including misrepresenting the number of drivers on a policy, vehicle usage, garaging location, moving to a higher-premium area, or misrepresenting the mileage on a vehicle.

One common example of overpricing as premium fraud is when individuals underreport the number of drivers on their auto insurance policy. By claiming that there are fewer drivers using the vehicle than there actually are, individuals can obtain lower premiums from insurance companies. This is because insurance rates are often based on the assumption that the more drivers there are, the higher the risk of an accident. As a result, individuals who engage in this form of overpricing fraud pay lower premiums than they should, effectively deceiving the insurance company.

Another example of overpricing as premium fraud is when individuals or businesses misrepresent the usage or purpose of a vehicle to obtain lower insurance rates. For instance, someone may claim that their vehicle is used solely for personal use when, in reality, it is also used for business purposes, such as delivering goods or transporting clients. By doing so, they can secure a lower premium, as insurance rates for vehicles used for commercial purposes are typically higher due to the increased risk associated with more frequent or extended usage.

In other cases, individuals may provide a false garaging location for their vehicle to benefit from lower insurance rates in that particular area. Insurance rates can vary significantly depending on the location where the vehicle is primarily parked or garaged. By providing a false address or location, individuals can manipulate the system and obtain a lower premium than they would be eligible for based on their actual residence or primary vehicle location.

Overpricing fraud can also occur when individuals or businesses underreport the mileage on their vehicles. Insurance companies often take into account the number of miles driven per year when calculating insurance rates, as higher mileage typically correlates with a higher risk of accidents or mechanical issues. By underreporting the annual mileage, individuals can present their vehicles as lower-risk, thereby securing lower insurance premiums than they would otherwise be entitled to.

In all these instances, overpricing as a form of premium fraud involves intentionally providing false or misleading information to an insurance company to obtain more favourable rates. This type of fraud not only results in financial losses for insurance companies but also contributes to increased costs for honest consumers, as the burden of covering these losses is often passed on through higher premiums.

Overpricing as a form of soft fraud

Overpricing, or inflating prices, is a form of soft fraud, which is a type of insurance fraud. Soft fraud is a criminal offence that occurs when a policyholder fabricates or inflates an otherwise legitimate claim, or intentionally misrepresents or omits information on an application, in the hopes of receiving a lower premium cost. Soft fraud is considered a crime of opportunity and is more common than hard fraud.

Soft fraud can take many forms, such as padding or inflating claims, misrepresenting facts on an insurance application, submitting claims for injuries or damage that never occurred, and staging accidents. For example, a repair shop might charge an insurer for extensive work but use cheap or fake replacement parts, or they might overcharge the insurer by overstating the extent of the necessary repairs. In the context of auto insurance, overpricing can involve a vehicle owner falsely reporting their car as stolen or not disclosing the presence of another person in the vehicle at the time of an accident, in order to receive funds from the insurance company.

The impact of soft fraud, including overpricing, is significant. It results in higher insurance premiums for consumers, as well as higher taxes and inflation on consumer goods. The FBI estimates that insurance fraud costs the average family between $400 and $700 per year in increased premiums. The total cost of non-health insurance fraud in the United States is estimated to be more than $40 billion per year.

To combat soft fraud, insurance companies are increasingly relying on anti-fraud technology, such as predictive modelling and link analysis, to detect fraudulent behaviours and claims. These technologies are particularly effective in detecting fraud in property claims and personal auto insurance. Additionally, special investigation units have been established to monitor and investigate suspicious claims, and civil lawsuits can be filed against individuals or organizations engaging in insurance fraud.

Overpricing as a form of asset diversion

Overpricing can be considered a form of asset diversion, which is a type of insurance fraud. Asset diversion occurs when the assets of an insurance company are improperly diverted, and it often happens during the acquisition of an insurer or the merger of two insurance companies.

In a typical asset diversion scheme, borrowed money is used to acquire a controlling interest in the insurance company. Once the acquisition is completed, the debt is paid off using the acquired company's assets. Any remaining assets can then be diverted to the purchasers. The insurer may continue to operate and generate additional premiums that are also later diverted. This type of fraud can affect all types of insurance companies, including health, life, home, and auto insurance providers.

Asset diversion can lead to serious criminal consequences as it can cost policyholders, shareholders, and the state. Those found guilty of this crime can expect aggressive prosecution and should work to defend themselves against the charges.

Overpricing as a form of worker's compensation fraud

Overpricing can be a form of workers' compensation fraud, and this can be committed by both employees and employers.

Overpricing by Employees

Employees can commit overpricing fraud by exaggerating the extent of an injury or illness. For example, an employee with a slightly sore arm that still functions may inflate their injury and pretend that they can't use their arm so they can go home and receive benefits. This is a form of "soft fraud", which is a crime of opportunity where a policyholder exaggerates an otherwise legitimate claim.

Overpricing by Employers

Employers can commit overpricing fraud by misrepresenting the safety of the work environment or misclassifying employees to get reduced workers' compensation premiums. Premiums are based on job responsibilities, so insurers can understand the risk of injury or illness. Employers may also commit fraud by not purchasing workers' compensation insurance when it's required.

Other Types of Workers' Compensation Fraud

Other types of workers' compensation fraud include employees filing a claim for an injury that never occurred, or filing a claim for an injury that is not work-related. Employers can also commit fraud by submitting erroneous payroll data or lying about the existence of a workplace safety program.

Overpricing as a form of disaster-related fraud

In the aftermath of a disaster, individuals are emotionally vulnerable and often desperate for assistance. Dishonest contractors and vendors exploit this vulnerability by offering their services or goods at inflated prices. They may pocket the payment without completing the job, use inferior materials, or perform shoddy work that does not meet the required standards or safety codes. This not only causes financial harm but also delays the recovery process for those affected by the disaster.

To address this issue, organizations such as the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) provide valuable resources and tips to help individuals avoid becoming victims of disaster-related fraud. These tips include being cautious of contractors who rush or pressure individuals, shopping around for recommendations, and obtaining multiple written estimates before agreeing to any services. It is also recommended to be wary of unsolicited offers and to always have a detailed written contract in place before proceeding with any work.

The financial impact of disaster-related fraud can be substantial. According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), insurance fraud costs the average U.S. family between $400 and $700 per year in increased premiums. Additionally, a study by the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud (CAIF) estimates that insurance fraud costs U.S. consumers a staggering $308.6 billion annually. This includes fraud across various sectors, such as life insurance, property and casualty insurance, workers' compensation, and auto theft.

To combat disaster-related fraud, including overpricing, individuals should be vigilant, cautious, and well-informed. Reporting suspected fraud to organizations such as the NICB or law enforcement agencies is crucial in deterring and prosecuting fraudulent activities. By staying informed, cautious, and proactive, individuals can protect themselves and their finances while also contributing to the collective effort to combat this form of fraud.

Frequently asked questions