Rainwater: Surface Water Insurance Claims

Whether rainwater is considered surface water by insurance companies is a complex issue. While rainwater itself is not typically covered by standard homeowners insurance policies, which include a water exclusion clause, rainwater-related damage may be covered if it enters a home due to a covered peril, like a windstorm, or if it results from a sudden or accidental event, like a burst pipe. However, if rainwater results in flooding, most standard policies won't cover the damage. The legal definition of surface water and the applicability of exclusions vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.

Rainwater that results in flooding is not covered by standard insurance policies

In the US, a water exclusion clause is a standard feature of property insurance contracts. This is because only specific areas are prone to water-related natural disaster events, such as floods, tidal waves, or tsunamis. While water-related perils are not totally excluded by homeowners insurance, most policies cover water damage that occurs due to specific reasons, usually a sudden or accidental event that occurs within the structure, such as a burst pipe or malfunctioning dishwasher. Gradual damage or wear and tear that happens over time is generally not covered.

Damage from wind-driven rain that travels into your home through high winds during a storm or tornado is typically covered by home insurance. However, if your home floods due to a night of heavy rain, you would not be covered by your standard homeowners insurance policy. In this case, you would need a separate flood insurance policy to pay for any damage from flooding.

The legal definitions of "surface water" and "flood" vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. For example, in Union Street Furniture and Carpet, Inc. v. Peerless Indemnity Insurance Company, the court, citing cases and authority from other jurisdictions, indicated that water from precipitation (rain or snow) flowing on the ground outside of any defined channel does not qualify as "surface water", but water that accumulates on a roof from rain does.

Rain that enters through a corroded structure is not covered by insurance

Rainwater is generally considered surface water by insurance companies, and whether or not damage caused by rainwater is covered by insurance depends on the specific circumstances and the source of the water. While homeowners insurance typically covers water damage from rain if it enters your home due to a covered peril, such as windstorm damage, it is important to note that standard policies do not cover flooding.

Rain that enters through a corroded structure, such as a leaky or damaged roof, is typically not covered by insurance. This is because insurance policies usually require that structures be in good condition prior to the event to be eligible for coverage. In other words, if the rain enters through a poorly maintained structure, the resulting water damage is considered the consequence of neglect and is, therefore, not covered.

For example, if rainwater has been leaking through a hole in your roof over time and causing gradual damage, your insurance company will likely hold you responsible for the repairs. This is because the damage is not considered sudden or accidental, and the initial cause of the rain entering the structure is neglect. On the other hand, if a tree branch cracks your window during a storm, allowing rain to enter and cause water damage, your insurance will likely cover the repairs since the initial damage was sudden and caused by a covered peril.

It is important to carefully review your insurance policy to understand what types of water damage are covered and excluded. While flooding is typically not covered by standard homeowners insurance, you can purchase separate flood insurance to protect your home against floods and storm surges. Additionally, optional coverage, such as "water back-up and sump overflow," can be added to your policy for an additional fee to protect against sump pump failure or clogged sewers.

Rain damage that occurs over time is not covered by insurance

Rainwater is considered surface water by insurance companies, and damage caused by it is usually excluded from standard homeowners insurance policies. This includes rain damage that occurs over time, which is typically not covered by insurance. Here are some scenarios to illustrate this:

Scenario 1: Gradual Water Damage

If rainwater seeps into your basement through small cracks in the foundation over time, this type of gradual damage is generally not covered by standard homeowners insurance policies. Most insurance policies will only provide coverage if the water damage is sudden and accidental. For example, if a pipe bursts due to freezing temperatures, causing water damage to your home, this would typically be covered as it is considered sudden and accidental.

Scenario 2: Poor Maintenance

If rainwater leaks into your home through a hole in your roof that has developed over time due to poor maintenance, this damage is also unlikely to be covered by insurance. Insurance companies usually require homeowners to maintain their properties in good condition to be eligible for coverage. In this case, the neglect would be considered the initial cause of the rain entering the home and, therefore, wouldn't be covered.

Scenario 3: Unaddressed Rainwater Damage

If rainwater enters your home through a leaky skylight and you fail to address the issue for weeks or months, allowing the damage to worsen, your insurance company will likely hold you responsible. In this case, the damage has developed over time and is neither sudden nor accidental, so it wouldn't be covered by standard homeowners insurance.

Understanding Surface Water Exclusions

It's important to understand that insurance policies often contain specific exclusions for losses caused by surface water runoff. While not all damage from running water is excluded, the term "surface water" generally refers to water that accumulates from natural causes, such as rainfall or snowmelt, and follows no defined course or channel. However, courts in different jurisdictions may interpret these exclusions differently, so it's always a good idea to consult with an attorney if you have specific concerns or questions about your policy.

Options for Additional Protection

While standard homeowners insurance policies typically exclude coverage for surface water and flood damage, you have options to protect your home against these risks. You can purchase additional coverage for floods through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). This can provide valuable protection if you live in an area prone to flooding or heavy rainfall. Additionally, you may want to consider adding water backup coverage to your policy, which can protect you from certain types of water damage, such as sump pump failures or sewer backups.

Rain damage caused by neglect is not covered by insurance

Rainwater is generally considered surface water by insurance companies, and damage caused by rainwater is covered by insurance only under certain conditions. For instance, if the rain enters your home due to a covered peril, like a windstorm, or if it causes damage that is sudden and accidental, such as a tree falling on your home and rainwater entering through the hole created.

However, it is important to note that rain damage caused by neglect is typically not covered by insurance. This includes situations where the rain enters your home through a poorly maintained structure or a pre-existing hole, or if the damage is a result of gradual wear and tear rather than a sudden accident. Insurance companies usually deny claims where the damage could have been prevented with proper maintenance. For example, if you have a leaky roof that you failed to repair, and rainwater enters your home and causes damage, your insurance company is unlikely to cover the repairs.

In addition, standard home insurance policies do not cover flooding caused by heavy rain. If you live in an area prone to flooding, you will need to purchase separate flood insurance to protect your home against water damage from floods or storm surges.

To ensure that you are adequately covered in the event of rain damage, it is important to carefully review your insurance policy and understand the exclusions and limitations. Taking preventative measures and maintaining your property can also help reduce the risk of rain damage and increase the likelihood of a successful insurance claim.

In summary, while rainwater is typically considered surface water by insurance companies, the coverage for rain damage is limited and depends on the specific circumstances and the source of the damage. Neglect or failure to maintain your property can result in denied insurance claims, so it is important to be proactive in preventing and addressing any potential issues.

Rainwater that enters the home and causes mould may be covered by insurance

Whether rainwater is considered surface water by insurance depends on the jurisdiction. However, generally, surface water is not covered by insurance due to policy flood exclusions.

In the case of rainwater entering the home and causing mould, coverage will depend on the source and nature of the rainwater. If the rainwater is considered surface water, the insurance company may deny the claim, citing the "Water" exclusion, which includes "flood" and "surface water". On the other hand, if the rainwater leak is sudden and accidental, such as a burst pipe or a broken washer hose, and it results in mould, this may be covered by standard homeowners insurance.

It is important to note that most policies won't cover gradual damage or wear and tear. For example, if a bathroom sink has been leaking for several months and mould develops, homeowners insurance may not cover the damage. Additionally, insurance companies may deny claims if proper maintenance was not performed, such as failing to heat the home, resulting in frozen and burst pipes.

Frequently asked questions