Best Auto Insurer Ads: Creative Strategies To Win Customers

Auto insurance companies are investing record-high amounts in attention-grabbing and humorous advertising campaigns. With the average American watching nearly three hours of television daily, television is still considered the most effective form of advertising. The number of drivers purchasing personal car insurance is on the rise, particularly among Millennials and Generation Z consumers.

GEICO and Progressive are the top two auto insurers with the highest advertising spending. In 2022, GEICO ranked as the most-advertised insurance brand in the United States, with a measured media ad spend of over $1.5 billion. Progressive ranked second, with nearly $1.4 billion invested in measured media spending.

Other auto insurance companies with notable advertising campaigns include State Farm, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, Farmers, and Esurance. These companies have created memorable commercials that range from light-hearted and quirky to educational and informative.

The success of these advertising campaigns can be attributed to their ability to strike a chord with their target audience, leveraging humour, creativity, and effective branding to leave a lasting impression on viewers.

GEICO's Gecko

The GEICO Gecko, or Martin as he is also known, is the primary mascot of GEICO and its commercials. He is an animated anthropomorphic gold dust day gecko with large black eyes and a Cockney accent. Over the years, he has been brought to life by various voice actors.

The Gecko first appeared on the GEICO website in 2002, and has since become a beloved character, famous for telling people how GEICO could help them save on insurance. His popularity has led to him becoming a sought-after costume for fans, and he even has his own line of phone wallpapers.

The Gecko is a unique and memorable mascot, with his distinctive appearance and accent, and has become an iconic part of GEICO's advertising campaigns. He is a powerful tool for GEICO, as he is instantly recognisable and helps to differentiate the brand from its competitors.

GEICO has successfully utilised the Gecko to create a fun and engaging brand image, and he has become an integral part of their marketing strategy. With his likeable personality and ability to connect with audiences, the Gecko is an effective spokesperson for the company, and a clever advertising tool.

Progressive's Flo

Progressive Insurance's fictional saleswoman, Flo, has been a prominent figure in the company's advertising campaigns since 2008. Played by actress and comedian Stephanie Courtney, Flo has appeared in more than 100 television, radio, print, and web banner advertisements for the company. With her upbeat personality, distinctive white uniform, heavy makeup, and retro hairstyle, Flo has become an iconic advertising mascot, helping to establish Progressive as a well-known brand.

The character of Flo was created by copywriter John Park and art director Steve Reepmeyer at the Boston-based agency Arnold Worldwide. The idea of a superstore, with neatly ordered shelves representing different types of insurance, was conceived to make the insurance sales process more tangible and appealing to customers. In the first ad of the campaign, which aired on January 14, 2008, Flo, as a cashier, enthusiastically echoes a customer's enthusiasm for the savings they achieved with Progressive. This unscripted moment helped Flo stand out, and she quickly became the centre of the ad campaign.

Flo's character is known for her bubbly and upbeat personality. Courtney has shared that she based Flo's personality on her mother, Jane Courtney, aiming to capture her mom's super-friendly and nice demeanour. Flo's distinct look, with her white uniform, heavy makeup, and retro hairstyle, also contributes to her iconic status. Courtney has shared that it takes a significant amount of time to prepare Flo's hair and makeup, reflecting the dedication to crafting this beloved character.

The success of Flo has been attributed to her relatability and ability to humanise the insurance industry. VCU Brandcenter professor Caley Caldwell noted that Flo "humanizes insurance, something that can feel pretty impersonal... Flo seems like the kind of person we would hope to get on the other end of the line to help us through an unpleasant situation." This connection with the audience has helped Flo and, by extension, Progressive, achieve a strong presence in popular culture.

While Progressive has introduced additional characters to their ad campaigns, such as Flo's Australian counterpart, Kitty, and her sidekick, Jamie, Flo remains a key branding element for the company. Her enduring popularity has contributed to her longevity in Progressive's advertising, with the company recognising her value in connecting with their target audience.

Allstate's Mayhem

The Mayhem character is a study in contrasts, with staged accidents and an endearing aura of malevolence. The campaign translates the intangible dread of everyday mishaps into a watchable and oddly likable villain. From 'blind spot' to 'teenage texter', each commercial captures different insurance selling points while also telling a story. This approach adds an element of freshness and keeps the audience engaged.

The success of the Mayhem campaign can be attributed to its ability to subvert the typical 'good hands' trope in insurance advertising. By introducing a bad apple character, Allstate created a cultural touchstone that altered viewer expectations. The use of humour in a domain often associated with dread also helped to make the campaign more relatable and enjoyable for the audience.

The portrayal of Mayhem has evolved over the years, adapting to mirror societal shifts and consumer attitudes. Initially, the character depicted specific risks, but the portrayal broadened to include more relatable scenarios that transcended demographics. This evolution demonstrates the campaign's ability to stay relevant and resonate with a wide audience.

The enduring legacy of the Mayhem character and the cultural cachet he has attained are testaments to the campaign's impact. The narrative of Mayhem and Dean Winters is one of twists and turns, mirroring the very notion of uncertainty that the campaign sought to sell. Through creating chaos on screen, the advertisers found clarity, and their work stands as a roadmap for future campaigns that aim to venture beyond the predictable.

State Farm's Jake

State Farm is one of the best auto insurance companies in the United States, ranking fourth in a US News rating of the best car insurance companies. State Farm's reach and reputation make it one of the best auto insurance companies for drivers in most states. It has a vast network of local agents, superior financial strength, and a customer-first approach.

State Farm's advertising campaigns have also contributed to its success and brand recognition. In 2020, the company revived its popular "Jake from State Farm" character, introducing Kevin Miles as the new face of Jake. Miles has since become an internet sensation, starring in multiple ads and growing his social media following. The original "Jake from State Farm" ad from 2011 featured Jake Stone and has become iconic, with Stone's response of "Uhhh... khakis?" to the question of what he was wearing becoming a well-known catchphrase.

State Farm's advertising strategy of using a relatable character like Jake has clearly resonated with audiences and helped to strengthen the company's brand and reputation. The company's focus on creating memorable and entertaining ads has likely contributed to its success and recognition as one of the top auto insurance companies in the United States.

Liberty Mutual's LiMu Emu and Doug

The stars of the campaign are a giant Australian ratite emu, LiMu, and his human partner, Doug, played by actor David Hoffman. Hoffman is a classically trained actor, having studied at the University of North Carolina School of the Arts and Boston University. He is no stranger to the Super Bowl commercial scene, having appeared in ads for Bud Light and Doritos during previous NFL championship games.

The CGI emu, LiMu, steals the show, as one would expect from a giant flightless bird. However, Doug and his distinct look, complete with aviator sunglasses and a moustache, have also left an impression on viewers. In one ad, Doug meets his doppelgänger son, who has the same moustache and sunglasses, and is starting out as the next generation of Liberty Mutual agents.

The campaign was developed by Goodby Silverstein & Partners (GS&P), Liberty Mutual's creative agency of record. The ads were directed by Craig Gillespie, an Australian feature film, television, and commercial director known for his offbeat comedy. Gillespie and GS&P collaborated with The Mill, a visual effects studio, to bring LiMu Emu to life with cutting-edge CGI technology.

Frequently asked questions