Private Insurance Market: Myths And Reality

The private insurance market is a complex and multifaceted sector, with a range of companies offering risk management solutions in the form of insurance contracts. While the basic concept of insurance remains consistent, the specific products and services offered can vary significantly. Here's an overview of the private insurance market and some key points to consider:

- The private insurance market is primarily focused on risk management, where insurers guarantee payment for uncertain future events in exchange for premiums from policyholders.

- The industry is generally considered slow-growing but stable compared to other financial sectors, providing a relatively safe investment option.

- The market can be segmented into different types of insurance companies, including accident and health insurers, property and casualty insurers, and financial guarantors.

- Life insurance companies, a significant segment of the market, offer policies that provide a lump-sum death benefit to beneficiaries upon the insured's death.

- Health insurance companies cover medical costs, while property and casualty insurance aim to replace the value of homes, cars, or other valuables.

- Insurance companies can be structured as stock companies with outside investors or mutual companies where policyholders are the owners.

- Investing in insurance companies may offer stable and predictable earnings, dividend income, and protection against inflation.

- However, the highly regulated nature of the industry can create compliance challenges and limit growth opportunities.

- The private insurance market is influenced by factors such as population growth, economic expansion, and the introduction of new risks, such as those associated with emerging technologies.

Private insurance companies are fundamentally rooted in risk management

One of the key features of private insurance companies is their ability to invest their customers' money for themselves, a practice known as "the float." This mechanism gives insurance companies a positive cost of capital, setting them apart from other financial institutions. It also allows them to generate stable and predictable earnings through long-term, fixed contracts.

In recent years, the relationship between private insurance companies and private-capital firms has strengthened. Private-capital firms have raised money from institutional investors, such as pension funds and sovereign wealth funds, and formed symbiotic relationships with insurers. This has allowed private-capital firms to expand their supply of permanent capital and accelerated earnings growth for insurers.

Additionally, private insurance companies have been actively managing their capital to ensure they can cover policyholder claims. They bring in third-party capital to boost growth and decide on the best jurisdictions for holding certain assets. This complexity in capital management is a critical component of the "flywheel" strategy, which aims to accelerate premium and earnings growth and increase ROE.

Furthermore, private insurance companies engage in reinsurance to reduce their risk. They buy insurance from other companies to protect themselves from excessive losses due to high exposure. Reinsurance is an integral component of their efforts to maintain solvency and avoid default due to large payouts.

Overall, private insurance companies are inherently focused on risk management, and this shapes their various strategies, partnerships, and day-to-day operations.

Private insurance companies are allowed to use their customers' money to invest for themselves

Insurance companies make money by charging their customers premiums in exchange for insurance coverage. They then reinvest these premiums into interest-generating assets. This is a common practice among insurance companies, who put some of the money aside as reserves to ensure they can pay out future claims, while investing the rest.

The investments made by insurance companies tend to be relatively conservative, with investments in bonds or stable blue-chip stocks. However, these investments can still significantly boost their profits.

The other main way insurance companies generate revenue is through underwriting. Underwriting involves actuaries assessing risks and setting premium rates. Actuaries use statistics and mathematical models to evaluate the financial risks involved in insuring different scenarios. Once the risks are assessed, specific insurance plans can be created and premiums set for each type of insurance plan.

In summary, private insurance companies use the money generated from customer premiums to invest in interest-bearing assets, which is a key part of their business model and helps them increase their profits.

Private insurance companies are in direct competition with other financial asset providers

The float occurs when one party extends money to another party and does not expect repayment until after a circumstantial event. This means that insurance companies have a positive cost of capital, which distinguishes them from other financial institutions. As a result, investing happens to an even greater extent at insurance companies than at banks.

Insurance companies' investment activities can provide stable and predictable earnings due to long-term, fixed contracts. They may also be more resilient to market cycles and result in dividend income for shareholders. Additionally, insurance companies can change the cost of their premiums to reflect inflation, helping to safeguard the value of investments.

On the other hand, insurance companies may be vulnerable to unpredictable, catastrophic events, such as natural disasters or large-scale accidents. They also face regulatory and compliance risks, which can result in financial penalties and reputational damage. Furthermore, fluctuations in interest rates or poor investment performance can affect their profitability.

Private insurance companies now have their own broker-dealer

Private insurance companies have historically dominated broker-dealer acquisitions to gain greater control over insurance product distribution. However, in recent years, there has been a shift, with many insurance companies choosing to exit the broker-dealer business and focus on their core insurance products. This is due to a combination of factors, including conflicts of interest, the increasing cost of broker-dealer acquisitions, and regulatory changes that have made it more challenging for insurance companies to own broker-dealers.

As a result, private equity firms have emerged as the dominant players in broker-dealer acquisitions. The previous pricing model, where insurance companies paid 30% to 40% of revenue, has shifted, and now 50% is becoming the norm. This change in pricing has made broker-dealers less attractive to insurance companies.

Another factor contributing to the decline of insurance-owned broker-dealers is the reduction in their ability to directly manipulate their representatives into selling proprietary insurance products. Regulatory changes, such as FINRA's edict that broker-dealers not have product mandates or pricing advantages that favor particular products, have levelled the playing field and made it more difficult for insurance companies to influence their representatives' product choices.

Additionally, insurance-owned independent broker-dealers have faced increased litigation and arbitrations, which have impacted their bottom lines. Issues such as client market loss, inappropriate investment sales, lack of supervision fines, and problematic alternative investments have led insurance companies to reconsider their ownership of broker-dealers.

The financial upheaval caused by the 2008 economic crisis also played a role in insurance companies' decisions to exit the broker-dealer business. During challenging economic times, insurance companies tend to focus on their core profit centers and divest non-core businesses.

Despite the changes in ownership, the success of broker-dealers, whether insurance-owned or privately owned, will depend on their ability to provide world-class service to their clients and adapt to the evolving regulatory environment.

Private insurance companies are highly regulated

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) of 2010 brought in many new requirements for the federal regulation of private health coverage. The ACA established core market rules designed to expand coverage to most people in the US. These include requirements for premium stabilisation and other efforts to protect the risk pool. The ACA also requires all private, non-grandfathered health plans to cover preventive services with no cost-sharing for enrollees.

The federal government also regulates private insurance companies through the Employer Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which has, for over 50 years, regulated employer-sponsored coverage – the most predominant form of health coverage for people under the age of 65.

At the state level, the regulation of insurance companies varies but commonly includes requirements for specific data to be provided for state all-payer claims databases. Some states are also developing additional regulations related to health plan network adequacy, health plan price transparency, public option plans, and reinsurance programs.

Private insurance companies are also subject to licensing requirements, with states licensing entities that offer private health coverage. This process involves reviewing the insurer's finances, management, and business practices to ensure it can provide the promised coverage to enrollees.

In summary, private insurance companies are highly regulated at both the federal and state levels, with a complex interplay between different regulatory requirements. These regulations aim to protect consumers, promote equity, and contain costs.

Frequently asked questions