Infertility Clinics And Insurance Billing: Unraveling The Ivf Financial Journey

Infertility treatments are often not covered by insurance, leaving many patients to pay out of pocket. In the US, only 15 states require insurance to cover in vitro fertilisation (IVF), and even then, patients can be left with huge bills. In addition, insurance coverage for IVF is often incomplete, with some plans covering the procedure but not the accompanying injections, for example. Furthermore, IVF is a complex procedure involving lab work, surgery, and anesthesia, and insurance companies do not always respect this.

Infertility treatments: These are often not covered by insurance plans, leaving patients to pay out-of-pocket

Infertility treatments are often not covered by insurance plans, leaving patients to pay out-of-pocket. This is because fertility treatments are expensive and are considered a social issue rather than a medical one by insurance carriers. As a result, most patients have to pay out of pocket for fertility treatment, which can amount to well over $10,000 depending on the services received. This makes fertility care inaccessible for many, especially those from low-income backgrounds.

Insurance Coverage for Infertility Treatments

Despite the high demand for fertility services, fertility treatments are often not covered by insurance plans. Only 15 states require some private insurers to cover some fertility treatment, and even then, significant gaps in coverage remain. For example, no Medicaid program covers artificial insemination or in-vitro fertilization.

In states without an infertility coverage mandate, most insurance plans do not help with payment for fertility and IVF services. IVF insurance coverage is less common than coverage for other fertility services because it is more expensive. However, some insurance plans do cover IVF treatments, but usually with a lifetime maximum benefit.

Factors Affecting Insurance Coverage for Infertility Treatments

Insurance coverage for infertility treatments varies according to several factors, including:

• State of residence: Only 15 states require some private insurers to cover some fertility treatment. As of September 2023, 21 states plus DC have passed fertility insurance coverage laws, 15 of which include IVF coverage.
• Insurance type: Insurance coverage also depends on whether an individual has public or private insurance. Very few states require private insurance plans to cover infertility services, and only one state requires coverage under Medicaid.
• Employer: Large employers are more likely than smaller employers to include fertility benefits in their health plans. However, self-funded coverage, where the employer pays for the health care services instead of an insurer, usually does not provide coverage for infertility treatments.

Infertility treatments are often not covered by insurance plans, and patients are left to pay out-of-pocket. This creates significant disparities in access to fertility services, especially for low-income individuals and those from marginalized communities.

In-network vs out-of-network: The cost of treatment varies depending on whether the clinic is in-network or out-of-network

The cost of treatment varies depending on whether the clinic is in-network or out-of-network. In-network providers have a contract with your insurance company, agreeing to accept a discounted, pre-negotiated rate for their services. This means that you, as the patient, will pay a lower cost when receiving treatment from an in-network doctor. Out-of-network providers, on the other hand, do not have a contract with your insurance company and can charge you the full price for their services, which is usually much higher than the in-network rate.

If your insurance plan includes out-of-network coverage, it will pay part of the bill, but your out-of-pocket costs will still be higher than they would be with an in-network provider. If your plan only covers in-network care, you will be responsible for paying the full amount charged by the out-of-network provider.

It is important to note that the type of insurance plan you have also affects your out-of-pocket costs. Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and Exclusive Provider Organizations (EPOs) typically do not cover out-of-network care at all, unless it is an emergency. In this case, you will be responsible for paying 100% of the cost of non-emergency out-of-network care. Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) and Point-of-Service (POS) plans may pay for part of the cost of out-of-network care, but you will still have higher out-of-pocket expenses compared to in-network care.

Additionally, when using an out-of-network provider, you may be balance-billed, which means that the provider can charge you the difference between their bill and the amount your insurance company pays. This can result in unexpected and high medical bills.

To avoid unexpected costs, it is important to understand your insurance plan and whether your chosen healthcare provider is in-network or out-of-network. You can do this by reviewing your plan details, using your insurance company's provider directory, or directly contacting the healthcare provider to inquire about their network status.

Which treatments are covered: Not all treatments are covered by insurance plans, and there may be specific requirements that must be met before certain treatments are covered

The treatments covered by insurance plans vary by state and the type of insurance. In the US, fertility care is inaccessible to many due to the cost. While some private insurance plans cover diagnostic services, there is very little coverage for treatment services such as IUI and IVF, which are more expensive.

As of September 2023, 21 states and DC have passed fertility insurance coverage laws, 15 of which include IVF coverage, and 17 cover fertility preservation for iatrogenic (medically-induced) infertility. However, these laws do not apply to self-funded employer plans, which are regulated by federal law and cover 61% of workers with employer-sponsored health insurance.

In states with a mandate to cover infertility treatments, these laws only apply to certain insurers, treatments, and patients, and may include monetary caps on costs. For example, in Ohio and West Virginia, the requirement to cover infertility services only applies to health maintenance organizations (HMOs). In other states, almost all insurers and HMOs are included in the mandate. Many states also provide exemptions for small employers (fewer than 50 employees) or religious organizations.

In Illinois, the mandate includes coverage for diagnosis and treatment of infertility, including up to 4 IVF attempts (egg retrieval procedures). However, there are loopholes in this mandate, as some employers have found ways to offer plans that do not cover infertility services.

In New York, large group comprehensive health insurance policies must cover three cycles of IVF used to treat infertility and prescription drugs that are prescribed for the IVF treatment. Basic infertility treatments, such as intrauterine insemination, must also be covered under individual, small group, and large group comprehensive health insurance policies when the patient meets the definition of infertility.

In addition to IVF, some insurance plans cover other infertility treatments such as intrauterine insemination (IUI), gamete intrafallopian transfer (GIFT), and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). However, it is important to note that not all health insurance plans cover the cost of infertility treatment, and there may be a more extended waiting period, caps on expenses, or sub-limits.

• Check if the cost of fertility diagnosis is covered under the plan.
• Check the eligibility criteria to understand who is eligible under the plan.
• Check the treatment procedures covered under the plan.
• Check the sub-limits and extent of coverage.
• Check the waiting period for infertility treatment, as it can differ between insurers.
• Check if prescribed medication is also covered under the plan.
• Check if add-on covers other types of infertility treatment procedures.

Common IVF procedures that are not covered by insurance: Certain procedures that fall under an IVF cycle may not be covered by insurance

Common IVF Procedures Not Covered by Insurance

While the coverage of IVF procedures by insurance varies from state to state and by insurance provider, there are some common IVF procedures that are often not covered by insurance. Here are some of the standard IVF procedures that may not be covered:

• Diagnostic testing and treatment: While insurance plans may cover diagnostic testing for infertility, they may not cover the subsequent treatment. Some plans explicitly state that they will only cover diagnostic testing and will not pay for any fertility-related services once a diagnosis has been established. This is likely because covering diagnostic testing is relatively inexpensive compared to treatment.
• IVF and related procedures: Even in states that mandate IVF coverage, there may be limitations or exclusions. For example, some states only cover a certain number of IVF cycles (e.g., three or four cycles), and others have a dollar limit on coverage (e.g., $15,000 lifetime maximum). Additionally, insurance plans may only cover the monitoring of IVF ovarian stimulation (blood and ultrasound tests) but not the more expensive IVF codes.
• Fertility preservation: While some states include fertility preservation as part of their IVF coverage, others do not. Fertility preservation can include egg/sperm/embryo freezing, and this procedure is often not covered by insurance.
• Medications: Insurance plans may cover IVF procedures but not the accompanying injections or medications that are required during the process. These medications can be expensive, and patients may have to pay out of pocket for them.
• Out-of-network providers: Insurance plans usually have a list of in-network providers for IVF and other infertility treatments. If patients choose to go to an out-of-network provider, they may have to pay a higher amount out of pocket, as the insurance company will not cover as much of the cost.
• Surrogacy: Many insurance plans do not cover services received by a surrogate, and the intended parents may be responsible for those costs. Additionally, non-medical costs related to donor gametes, donor embryos, or surrogacy are typically not covered.
• Experimental procedures: Insurance plans usually do not cover experimental or investigational infertility procedures. This includes procedures that are not considered medically necessary or that are still in the research phase.

Cost differences: The cost of treatment may differ for individuals with the same insurance plan due to different CPT and diagnosis codes, treatment protocols, number of dependents, and whether deductibles have been met

The cost of treatment for IVF can vary for individuals with the same insurance plan due to several factors. These include different CPT and diagnosis codes, treatment protocols, number of dependents, and whether deductibles have been met.

CPT codes are used to identify medical services and procedures and are updated annually. CPT codes are essential for accurately communicating across stakeholders in the healthcare industry, including insurance companies, and ensuring proper reimbursement. CPT codes for IVF treatments include codes for specific procedures such as oocyte retrieval, embryo transfer, and sperm injection.

Diagnosis codes, on the other hand, relate to the patient's specific medical condition and are used to determine insurance coverage. For example, a patient with a diagnosis of female infertility associated with anovulation would have a diagnosis code of 628.0. It is important that both CPT and diagnosis codes are correct to avoid claim denials and unexpected costs for patients.

Treatment protocols can also impact the cost of IVF. For example, some patients may require additional procedures such as fertility drugs or surgical solutions, which can increase the overall cost. The number of dependents can also affect the cost, as insurance plans may have different coverage levels for individuals and families.

Finally, whether deductibles have been met can also impact the cost of IVF treatment. Deductibles refer to the amount a patient must pay out-of-pocket before their insurance company covers the remaining costs. If a patient has met their deductible, they may have lower out-of-pocket costs for IVF treatment.

In conclusion, while insurance coverage can provide some financial relief for IVF treatments, the cost can still vary significantly for individuals with the same insurance plan due to differences in CPT and diagnosis codes, treatment protocols, number of dependents, and whether deductibles have been met.

Frequently asked questions