Whole Life Insurance: Taxable Surrender Value?

Whole life insurance is a type of permanent plan that lasts for the rest of your life, provided you continue to pay your premiums. It has a death benefit and a secure cash value account that grows tax-free. However, there are certain situations where the cash value in a whole life insurance policy may be taxable. For example, if you surrender your whole life insurance policy, you may be taxed on the amount you receive over the policy's basis or the total premium you paid. Similarly, if you take out a loan against the cash value and the policy terminates before you repay it, you may be taxed on the loan amount. It's important to understand the tax implications of whole life insurance to make informed decisions about your financial planning.

Surrendering a whole life insurance policy: you may have to pay a surrender fee, and a portion of the money received may be taxable

Surrendering a whole life insurance policy means giving up your coverage and, in some cases, owing taxes on part of the money you receive. Here are some important things to know about surrendering a whole life insurance policy:

Surrender Charges and Fees

When you surrender a whole life insurance policy, you may be charged a surrender fee by the insurance company. Surrender fees tend to decrease over time and often phase out over the life of the policy. In addition, if you surrender your policy earlier in the term, you may face higher surrender charges and a lower cash surrender value since the cash value will be smaller.

Tax Implications

The cash surrender value of a life insurance policy is the amount you receive when you surrender your policy to the insurer. This amount may be taxable, depending on your situation. Any funds you receive over the policy's basis, or the amount you paid in premiums, can typically be taxed as income.

If you have outstanding policy loans that exceed the policy's cost basis, the insurance company will deduct the loan amount and interest from the cash surrender value. You will owe income tax on the lower surrender value if it exceeds the amount paid in premiums.

Steps to Surrender Your Policy

If you decide to surrender your whole life insurance policy, here are the steps you can follow:

• Review your policy documents: Gather your policy documents, including the contract, riders, amendments, and premium payment receipts. Look for information about cash surrender value, surrender charges, and other relevant terms.
• Contact your insurer: Inform your life insurance provider's customer service team that you intend to surrender your policy. They will guide you through their specific process for surrendering the policy and paying out the cash surrender value.
• Fill out the necessary paperwork: Your insurer will provide you with the required forms, such as a policy termination form or surrender request form. Complete these forms and provide all the requested information and documentation.
• Receive the cash surrender value: Your insurer will process your surrender request and calculate the cash surrender value based on the policy's terms. They will then send you the payment via check or direct deposit.
• Consult with tax and financial experts: Receiving a large payout may have tax implications, so it is advisable to consult a tax expert to ensure proper reporting. Additionally, consider consulting a financial advisor to determine the best way to save or invest your funds.

Alternatives to Surrendering Your Policy

Before surrendering your whole life insurance policy, it is worth considering alternative options to access your cash value while maintaining your coverage:

• Borrowing against your cash value: You can borrow against the cash value of your permanent life insurance policy at low-interest rates and favourable terms. Policy loans have no due date, but interest accumulates on the outstanding loan balance.
• Withdrawing from your cash value: Withdrawing from your cash value allows you to access your wealth without taking out a loan or surrendering your policy. However, withdrawals may trigger tax consequences on investment gains and could reduce your death benefit.
• Using your cash value to pay premiums: Many permanent life insurance policies allow you to use your accumulated cash value to pay premiums, helping you reduce your life insurance costs while maintaining full coverage.

Withdrawing funds from cash value: the IRS taxes distributions above the amount paid into the account through premiums

Withdrawing funds from the cash value of a whole life insurance policy is a way to access the money that builds up within the policy. This can be done without taking out a loan or surrendering the policy. However, it's important to note that withdrawing more than you've contributed in premiums may result in tax consequences.

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) taxes distributions from a life insurance policy's cash value that exceed the amount paid into the account through premiums. This means that if you withdraw any gains, such as interest or investment earnings, they will be taxed as ordinary income. The portion of the withdrawal that comes from premium payments is not taxable.

For example, if you have accumulated $20,000 in cash value, with $19,000 from premium payments and $1,000 from interest or investment gains, you can withdraw up to $19,000 tax-free. However, if you withdraw the full $20,000, you will owe taxes on the $1,000 that exceeds the amount you paid in premiums.

It's important to carefully consider the tax implications before withdrawing funds from the cash value of a whole life insurance policy. Withdrawing more than the amount you've contributed in premiums may result in a tax bill. Additionally, withdrawals may reduce the death benefit and could even cause the policy to lapse.

Consulting with a tax expert or financial advisor is recommended to understand the potential tax consequences and explore alternative options for accessing the cash value.

Selling your life insurance policy: viatical settlements are tax-free, but life settlements are considered taxable income

If you own a life insurance policy that you no longer want, need, or can afford, you have a few options. You could surrender the policy for its cash value, allow it to lapse, or sell it to a third party, which is known as a life settlement.

A life settlement is when you sell your life insurance policy (or the right to receive the death benefit) to an entity other than the insurance company that issued the policy. The amount you receive will depend on factors such as your age, health, and policy terms and conditions. This is generally more than the policy's cash surrender value but less than the net death benefit. In addition to the lump sum payment, the buyer agrees to pay any additional premiums required to support the cost of the policy for as long as you live and will receive the death benefit when you die.

A viatical settlement is a type of life settlement for those who are terminally or chronically ill. In this case, the buyer pays a lump sum in cash and all future premiums and becomes the sole beneficiary of the full amount of the policy when the original owner dies.

The cash value of life insurance is not usually taxable. However, there are some cases where you may have to pay taxes on it. For example, if you withdraw on any gains, such as dividends, you can expect them to be taxed as ordinary income. Similarly, if you take out a loan from your life insurance plan and the policy terminates before you've repaid the loan, you may be taxed.

In the case of life settlements, the lump sum payment received in exchange for your life insurance policy can be taxable, depending on your circumstances. It's important to understand the tax implications before entering into any contract. On the other hand, viatical settlements are tax-free.

Taking out a loan against the cash value: if the policy ends before the loan is repaid, you may have to pay taxes on the loan amount

Taking out a loan against the cash value of your whole life insurance policy is one of several ways to access the cash value of your policy while retaining coverage. This option is often preferred because there is no credit check or approval process, and the interest rate is usually lower than that of a personal or home equity loan. Additionally, the cash value continues to grow even while you have an outstanding loan.

However, it's important to be aware of the potential drawbacks. If you don't repay the loan, your death benefit will be reduced by the amount of the loan and any accrued interest. If the loan balance and interest exceed the cash value of your policy, the insurance company may cancel your coverage. Furthermore, if your policy ends before the loan is repaid, you may face tax consequences.

In the event that your policy lapses or is surrendered with an outstanding loan balance, you will likely owe income taxes on any gains made through investments. The taxable portion of the loan amount is the amount above the basis, which includes interest or investment earnings. On the other hand, the money you put into your cash value through premium payments is generally not taxable, even if your policy ends with an outstanding loan.

For example, if you borrow $50,000 against your policy's cash value and $45,000 of that amount came from premium payments, while the remaining $5,000 came from interest and investment earnings, you will owe taxes on the $5,000 above the basis. Therefore, it's crucial to keep a close eye on your outstanding loan balance to ensure it doesn't approach your cash value, which could lead to policy cancellation.

Naming your estate as a beneficiary: the payout may be subject to federal and state estate taxes

Naming your estate as a beneficiary may result in your death benefit payout being subject to federal and state estate taxes. This is because the payout becomes part of your taxable estate.

In the US, the federal estate tax exemption amount is currently $13.61 million per individual. This means that any assets of a deceased person that are worth more than this amount are subject to federal estate taxes. This limit is revised annually and is expected to increase to $13.66 million in 2025.

In addition to federal estate tax, your assets may also be subject to state estate tax if you reside in a state that imposes this tax. There are 12 states and the District of Columbia that charge estate taxes, which are paid in addition to any federal estate tax. The exemption levels vary and can reach as high as $13.61 million. It's important to note that your assets could be subject to state estate tax even if your estate isn't worth the federal estate tax filing limit at the time of your death.

The estate tax is assessed on the estate's fair market value, not on the price the deceased paid. This means that any appreciation in the estate's assets over time will be taxed, but it protects those who inherit assets that have dropped in value. For example, if a house was purchased for $5 million but its current market value is $4 million, the latter amount will be used for tax purposes.

It's worth noting that surviving spouses are generally exempt from federal and state estate taxes, regardless of the value of the estate or inheritance. Additionally, assets distributed to a qualified charitable organization may pass free of estate tax.

To minimize estate taxes, taxpayers whose estates are above the threshold can set up trusts to facilitate the transfer of wealth. One option is to set up an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT). By establishing a trust that owns an insurance policy on your life, you can make contributions to the trust that will be used to pay premiums on the insurance policy. At death, the proceeds are exempt from estate taxes as long as the trustee adheres to the requirements set by the IRS during the lifetime of the trust.

While the cash value of life insurance grows tax-free, there are some instances where you may owe taxes on it. If you name your estate as a beneficiary, the payout may be subject to federal and state estate taxes, depending on the value of your estate and the applicable tax laws. It's recommended to consult with a tax advisor to understand the specific tax implications for your situation.

Frequently asked questions